I have a new Every Day Carry -- the Camillus/BFC 154CM version. To bring the bottom line right up to the top: My thumbs are up.
Some other comments: This is a very stylish and sturdy knife. A very high cool factor! I just got it yesterday, so I can't really say all that much yet, but it's got a lot going for it. The design is elegant. It's so simple. The two handle slabs are joined only at the pivot, the stop pin and another pin at the other end, so the back is entirely open, yet the slabs are completely stable and rigid. The way the numerous small cutouts match up on the two slabs and the clip is elegant and impressive. That's something you can see in the pictures, but it is especially neat in person.
If it's going to live up to its name, it will have to displace my BM 705 to become my everyday carry. So I'll mention a few comparisons with the 705 here.
I've never really liked the feel of the textured G10 on the 705. It's very grippy, but also pretty aggressive. I really like the bead-blast finish on the handles of the EDC. Combined with the cutouts, the knife does not feel at all slippery. Admittedly, I haven't given it any severe tests, but so far it feels secure and comfortable. The cutouts are terrific. Not only for looks, but the weight of the knife is quite good. Although the steel slabs are thicker than the steel liners of the 705, the two knives' weights are almost identical, both to my hand and to the kitchen scale that I compared them on. The EDC is less than 3/4 of the thickness of the 705, which is quite nice.
The EDC really packs an incredible amount of blade. The handle is perhaps 1/8" longer than that of the 705, and the length of the open blade seems to be almost identical, but the blade of the EDC seems to dwarf the 705 blade. You wonder where it all came from.
I like the finish of the handles, but I have to say that so far, I'm less sure of the blade finish. (Is this stonewashed?) I don't strongly DISlike it, but I'm not yet sure I like it either. It seems very dull. There isn't much sheen to it. I'm not into "combat" blades so I don't feel like I need a "surpressed" blade. Maybe it'll grow on me.
The blade on mine locks up very tightly and solidly. When it's locked, it does not move at all. It takes a positive effort to unlock. It will not come unlocked accidentally. The blade is centered between the handle slabs perfectly, or if it is imperfect, it would take a micrometer to detect it. OTOH, the edge grind is less than spectacular. It is pretty visibly not symmetrical and although it is ok for a factory edge, it is not by any means great. I'm only pretty good as a sharpener. My knives normally do okay on the hanging paper tests, but can't cleanly cut toilet paper or do the "snap rubber bands into large numbers of pieces" trick. Furthermore, my knives tend to get sharper the longer I own them, which also says that I can't be counted on to get them right the first time.
I expect to improve the edge of the EDC as soon as I get a chance to work on it. This is by no means a big deal to me, since I will have to sharpen it anyway as I use it, but it would be nice to be able to say I was impressed, as a couple of forumites have.
The only other quibble I have is that the pivot of mine seems very tight. The pivot screw looks like an allen head rather than torx. Someone commented on the need to heat the clip screws with a soldering iron to loosen the locktite. Do you need to do the same to the pivot screw? Or is it just that the detente is extremely strong? In any case, the knife is not easy to open. I like the fact that it takes effort to close, but the knife rides tip down in the pocket so it isn't going to fall open. It seems like it ought to be easier to open than it is.
Overall, I like it, but if it is going to become my real "everyday carry" I will certainly want to get it adjusted so that it opens easier.
------------------
Paul Neubauer
prn@bsu.edu
A tool is, basically, an object that enables you to take advantage of the laws of physics and mechanics in such a way that you can seriously injure yourself.