15 year long review of Ontario U.S. Army machete

kgriggs8

BANNED
Joined
Jan 28, 2002
Messages
1,634
I have been "testing" above for at least 15 straight years. My dad gave it to me when I was about 14 and now I am nearly 30. I have cut brush, weeds, shrubs, small and medium trees (8-10" in diameter) with it and just about everything else that it came into contact with.

When I first got it, I used it as a throwing knife for some stupid reason. I threw it into a telephone pole until the handle started to get loose. I was going to continue to try and break it but I remembered how well it did when I did use it. I decided not to break it since it worked well when my dad asked me to cut down a pine tree in his front yard. I hammered the rivets back tight on the handle and to my surprise, they have never come loose since.

They only mods I have ever done was recently paint the blade black just to keep it from rusting since there is little to no black finish remaining from years of use. I also wrapped the handle in black fabric tape like what hockey players put on their sticks. It helps keep a better grip when wet from sweat. Other than that, i just sharpen it with a fine file and it is ready to go. It doesn’t need a fine edge and seems to cut better with a rough but sharp edge I can get from a file.

I have tested numerous other machetes, Kukris, and axes but nothing has preformed as well as my $15 U.S. machete. It can do just about anything except split large pieces of firewood, hammer things or cut roots out of the earth, for those three things I use a small axe. I have used the expensive Kukris but they don’t work as well in clearing brush as the machete and they don’t dig roots out as well as an axe, you also can’t hammer with them.

Had I paid for this, this would have been the best $15 I ever spent on a cutting tool, since I got it for free, I can’t say that.

To put it simply, a $15 dollar machete out performs every other tool of the type that I have ever used. I can’t see spending hundreds on anything else. I have tried other machetes and they have not been good. The U.S. issue one is the best because it is the right size, steel and shape. Any larger and it become hard to control, any smaller and you lose performance.
 
Nice link Frank. Very interesting!

When I was an Anthropolgy undergrad, I worked for the CRM dept getting paid to dig archaeological sites. It was very cool work since it was in my major. The dept. gave us 3-4 orange D-handled 22" long machetes. I think they may have been Barteaux but I can't remember. I remember they hurt my hand from the vibrations and the D-loop gave me a blister. Several times they sprung out of my hand because of the whipping action of the blade. They did a decent job of clearing long grasses but anything else was too much for it. For as big and heavy as they were, they couldn't cut worth a darn. I ended up bringing my old Ontario to work becuase it preformed so much better. My Ontario is the 18" version.

I placed a bet with the biggest guy in our class that I could cut through a 4-6" tree in under a certain number of swings. I forget the number. I bet him that I could cut through in much less time and swings than he could using the larger machete. He was 6' 4' 300lbs ex-army so he took the bet. He tried as hard as he could to cut the tree but it took him many times longer and more swings than I took. I had large chunks of wood flying every other swing as I notched through the wood and he seemed to bash it.

The last big blade I used was a Colt Steel Kukuri. It did nothing as well as the Ontario but wan't nearly as bad as some. The rubber grips are not comfortable when cutting into hard wood. They feel like they would be but aren't.
 
I have used a 12" and 18" one, they are solid in many respects, the plastic handles will break however if you baton on it extensively, and both blades I had were brittle, but Ontario's heat treating is the problem here, based on the other blades I have seen from Ontario I have no doubt that if you got a good one you would be very pleased with the durablity.

Barteaux makes solid ones as well, like many machetes they may need initial edge work. Both of the Barteaux's I had would want edge reprofiling to be optimal for wood and brush work. They are not whippy though as they were the 1/8" models, the 1/16" models would be fairly unsuitable for thick wood work as they would have far too much vibration in the hand.

-Cliff
 
My favorite machete/bush-blade is the 12" Ontario.

It has served me faithfully for many years and it is just the pefect size for the most utility without being too heavy or awkward.

Allen.
 
You guys don't know good machetes. The best ones were the Legitimus Collins brand from Collinsville Connecticut. Unfortunately they closed the plant in the mid 1960's. I had one of the cheapest models that they made and it was so much finer than any of the military models that it wasn't funny. As I recall my research they made their blades out of an alloy akin to 1084. It was hardened more than other brands that I tried. When I would flick it with my finger nail it would ring like a sword in the movies. I reduced the edge bevel on my using a file. I would guess that I went lower than 10 degrees per side. I chopped everything in creation with that thing and only had occasional dents. I used cloth tape on the handle for comfort.

Unfortunately somebody stole my beloved Collins when I was around 20. The only replacement models I could find at the time were made in Columbia. I didn't realize that those were well made. Since then I have been able to find the originals on Ebay and at militaria stores. They are just as good as I remember. I also found a heavy duty 1905 military model designed for places like the Philipines. That one has a blade about 1/4 inch thick with horn grips. The Collins company had a very long history of being the world's premier machete company. You really ought to look for one.
 
Jeff Clark said:
The best ones were the Legitimus Collins brand from Collinsville Connecticut. The Collins company had a very long history of being the world's premier machete company. You really ought to look for one.

Jeff...oh man! A blast from the past. Those Collins machetes are legendary and have a cult like following. I don't have my dad's any more, sorry yours is gone too.
 
I've had a foreign made Collins (Columbia or Guatemala?) for about 25 years. I've really abused it and it's held up quite well. It rings when I use it just as Jeff describes.
 
I spent about a month in Central America, Guatamala and Costa Rica mostly, and saw many fine machetes in use. They were often decorated and beautiful while functional. I saw them used for cutting small lawns, cutting bamboo for huts/houses and a guy in a loincloth jumped onto the caboose with one in between his teeth, blade toward me and about a foot from my face. He had come out of the jungle and hitched a ride while I was silently sitting on the small bench on the tiny rear platform. I wish I had acquired some... Aww the seventies were good.

All the best,

Oregon
 
Back
Top