2019 Forum Knife : Poll - Slab Type

Slab Type

  • Acrylic

    Votes: 7 2.2%
  • Bone Smooth

    Votes: 21 6.6%
  • Bone Jigged

    Votes: 132 41.6%
  • Wood Smooth

    Votes: 133 42.0%
  • Wood Jigged

    Votes: 7 2.2%
  • Micarta

    Votes: 17 5.4%

  • Total voters
    317
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
My recollection is that there's been a number of times the Charlie rope knife jigging has been requested - and it hasn't worked out each time. It's possible it might not matter because jigged bone votes might be for Sawcut.
I don’t know. I’ve been paying attention for the past few years and haven’t heard anything other than the Rob Bixley story repeated a few times. Also, that was a lack of communication mistake, probably on GEC’s part. It wasn’t like they heard the request for one type of jigging and on purpose made another type.

We have Mike Latham of Collector Knives as our representative with GEC. He is the King of awesome SFO’s from GEC. I’m pretty sure he will be able to convey our requested type of handles to Bill Howard.
 
Some of the jigged bone images shown so far are truly amazing. If you could guarantee the jig/color for the whole lot of 400+ knives, that would be an incredible knife. However, I've learned in my experience that if there is a chance I'll get dull color bone or lackluster stag, it happens almost every time. I've learned to either play it safe, or only buy knives in person when I can handle it before paying.

I envisioned this knife from the start with black smooth wood handles, and I'm going to keep my vote there.
 
My favorite jogged GEC knives I have are grizzly and cougar clawed. I seldom have seen a jigged bone example that I didn’t like or thought was boring but I can’t say the same for wood options.

I hear the arguments for ebony but it’s just not that one extra level of awesome we could have here. I’m all for sawcut or clawed.
 
Last edited:
When I first opened this thread I was about 50/50 jig bone and smooth wood.

Then I looked at the few smooth wood I have and they look so good.
And my last jigged was the blood red 85. I don’t think it was the jigging that bothered me that much, but it was the color. I kept it hoping it would grow on me and it didn’t .

Also the weight of bone on this knife may really make a difference. I had a smooth bone 43 and loved it, but it was one heavy MF.

And if some cool wood was offered that would be fantastic. If it landed on ebony or coco it wouldn’t be horrible.

yFZOkcm.jpg
 
I do agree that if we select ebony or African Blackwood is a safe choice. I don’t think many of us have ever been let down by GEC’s darkest woods.

However, I don’t buy the aurguement that wood in general is the safe choice. Just because two people thought their jigged bone handles didn’t look as nice as someone else’s doesn’t mean that a vast majority didn’t look gourgeous. For the record, the three 48’s that were shown actually looked pretty nice, just not as nice some. This is no different than stag or wood or any natural material. Of the dozen or so of the GEC’s that I have been disappointed in, most of them have been wood. Usally I’m disappointed because of lack-luster wood grain or just the fact that the beautiful wood grain pics on GEC’s website are a lot nicer than the one I received. Dessert Ironwood, Cocobolo, Bocote and others are very hard to get good looking versions, especially if you are hoping for matching good looking sides. Unless, you get the one in the advertising photo, yours is probably not as nice.

Also, the #15 Rope knife jigging isn’t going to be the only jigged bone on the menu. The Grizzly cut and Pony cut and plenty of other good looking choices are going to be available.

Edit: Smooth White or Ivory bone is another super safe choice; always consistently great looking.
 
Last edited:
Yup, changed my vote to smooth wood due to the fact we don't have a guarantee that we'll get a good Roger's type jigging even if it was included in the next round of voting. And we don't even know if it would be included!
How can one vote jigging when we don't know what jig we'll be dancing to?!
I personally think the majority of GEC's jigging is horrendously ugly and that is the reason I don't own but two GEC knives and neither are jigged bone.
 
For reference, here is a list of all the different jigged bones GEC has offered in the past...only 184 of them.
Amber_Barnboard_Jig_Bone
Amber_Fine_Jig_Bone
Amber_Grizzly_Jig_Bone
Amber_Jig_Bone
Antique_Amber_Barnboard_Jig_Bone
Antique_Amber_Big_Jig_Bone
Antique_Amber_Jig_Bone
Antique_Amber_Little_Jig_Bone
Antique_Autumn_Jig_Bone
Antique_Black_Jig_Bone
Antique_Brown_Jig_Bone
Antique_Calico_Jig_Bone
Antique_Goldenrod_Jig_Bone
Antique_Green_Jig_Bone
Antique_Honey_Jig_Bone
Antique_Ivory_Jig_Bone
Antique_Peach_Seed_Jig_Bone
Antique_Seen_Jig_Bone
Antique_Walnut_Jig_Bone
Antique_Weave_Jig_Bone
Antique_Yellow_Jig_Bone
Apple_Red_Jig_Bone
Arrowhead_Jig_Bone
Autumn_Gold_Jig_Bone
Autumn_Leaf_Jig_Bone
Autumn_Oak_Jig_Bone
Banana_Peel_Herringbone_Jig
Banana_Peel_Jig_Bone
Banana_Peel_Rodgers_Jig
Banana_Peel_Sheffield_Jig
Banana_Peel_Single_Wave_Jig
Bear_Clawed_Jig_Bone
Beet_Red_Jig_Bone
Black_Box_Brown_Jig_Bone
Black_Cherry_Jig_Bone
Black_Jig_Bone
Black_Olive_Jig_Bone
Black_Plum_Jig_Bone
Black_Water_Jig_Bone
Blood_Jig_Bone
Blood_Red_Jig_Bone
Blood_Red_Peach_Seed_Jig_Bone
Blue/Green_Jig_Bone
Blue_Basketweave_Jig_Bone
Blue_Jig_Bone
Blueberry_Jig_Bone
Brimstone_Jig_Bone
Brown_Jig_Bone
Brown_Peach_Seed_Jig_Bone
Bumble_Bee_Jig_Bone
Burgundy_Jig_Bone
Burnt_Arrowhead_Jig_Bone
Burnt_Chocolate_Jig_Bone
Burnt_Goldenrod_Jig_Bone
Burnt_Orange_Jig_Bone
Burnt_Orange_Wave_Jig_Bone
Burnt_Sienna_Jig_Bone
Cardinal_Red_Jig_Bone
Cherry_Jig_Bone
Chestnut_Jig_Bone
Chestnut_Peach_Seed_Jig_Bone
Chocolate_Diamond_Black_Jig_Bone
Chocolate_Jig_Bone
Cobblestone_Jig_Bone
Cola_Jig_Bone
Copperhead_Jig_Bone
Coyote_Brown_Jig_Bone
Cranberry_Jig_Bone
Cranberry_Red_Jig_Bone
Cranberry_Wine_Jig_Bone
Dark_Autumn_Gold_Jig_Bone
Dark_Blue_Jigged_Bone
Dark_Brown_Jig_Bone
Dark_Cherry_Jig_Bone
Dark_Chestnut_Jig_Bone
Dark_Chestnut_Peach_Seed_Jig_Bone
Dark_Green_Jig_Bone
Dark_Red_Jig_Bone
Dark_Saddle_Brown_Jig_Bone
Dark_Tan_Jig_Bone
Deep_Chestnut_Peach_Seed_Jig
Deep_Purple_Jig_Bone
Deep_Red_Wine_Jig_Bone
Deep_Woods_Green_Jig_Bone
Desert_Sand_Jig_Bone
Dusk_Blue_Jig_Bone
Dusty_Rose_Jig_Bone
Elderberry_Jig_Bone
Evening_Blue_Fishnet_Jig_Bone
Evergreen_Jig_Bone
Forest_Green_Jig_Bone
Forest_Moss_Jig_Bone
Fuschia_Jigged_Bone
Garnet_Jig_Bone
Golden_Ale_Jig_Bone
Golden_Brown_Jig_Bone
Goldenrod_Jig_Bone
Goldenrod_Wave_Jig_Bone
Grape_Jig_Bone
Green_Boker_Jig
Green_Bottle_Glass_Jig_Bone
Green_Herringbone_Jig
Green_Herringbone_Jig_Bone
Green_Jig_Bone
Green_Tea_Jig_Bone
Greenbriar_Jig_Bone
Hemlock_Green_Jig_Bone
Hemlock_Jig_Bone
Honey_Brown_Jig_Bone
Honey_Jig_Bone
Horesecut_Walnut_Jig_Bone
Indian_Choffee_Jig_Bone
Indian_Paint_Brush_Jig_Bone
Jigged_Bone_Blue
Jigged_Bone_Green
Jigged_Bone_Red
Jigged_Frontier_Bone
Jigged_Motley_Bone
Jigged_Pioneer_Bone
Jigged_Walnut_Bone
Jigged_Yellow_Rose
Light_Brown_Jig_Bone
Light_Chestnut_Jig_Bone
Light_Red_Jig_Bone
Light_Saddle_Brown_Jig_Bone
Mahogany_Jig_Bone
Midnight_Blue_Jig_Bone
Midnight_Jig_Bone
Moose_Green_Jig_Bone
Moss_Green_Jig_Bone
Mustard_Jig_Bon
Mustard_Jig_Bone
Old_Green_Jig_Bone
Olive_Green_Jig_Bone
Olive_Standard_Jig
Orange_Jig_Bone
Peach_Seed_Antique_Amber_Jig_Bone
Pickle_Green_Jig_Bone
Pine_Green_Jig_Bone
Pioneer_Jig_Bone
Plum_Jig_Bone
Pony_Cut_Autumn_Leaf_Jig_Bone
Purple_Peach_Pit_Jig_Bone
Purple_Sage_Jig_Bone
Raisin_Jig_Bone
Red_Barnboard_Jig_Bone
Red_Bluegrass_Jig
Red_Bottle_Glass_Jig_Bone
Red_Dawn_Jig_Bone
Red_Glass_Jig_Bone
Red_Jig_Bone
Red_Licorice_Jig_Bone
Red_Peach_Seed_Jig_Bone
Red_Sienna_Jig_Bone
Red_Wine_Jig_Bone
Red_Wine_Jigged_Bone
Reddish_Brown_Jig_Bone
Relish_Jig_Bone
River_Blue_Jig_Bone
River_Blue_Wave_Jig_Bone
River_Valley_Green_Jig_Bone
Ruby_Red_Jig_Bone
Rust_Red_Jig_Bone
Saddle_Brown_Jig_Bone
Sand_Art_Jig_Bone
Sanded_Brown_Jig_Bone
Sangria_Jig_Bone
Spring_Green_Jig_Bone
Spruce_Green_Jig_Bone
Standard_Jig_Orange_Bone
Stone_Moss_Green_Jig_Bone
Stonewashed_Blue_Jig_Bone
Strawberry_Jig_Bone
Summer_Green_Jig_Bone
Sunset_Yellow_Jig_Bone
Sweet_Pickle_Jig_Bone
Tan_Jig_Bone
Teal_Jig_Bone
Tractor_Green_Jig_Bone
Tractor_Red_Jig_Bone
Turquoise_Jig_Bone
Walnut_Stain_Jig_Bone
Yellow_Jig_Bone
Yellow_Rose_Jig_Bone
 
Smooth bones
Blood_Red_Smooth_Bone
Emerald_Smooth_Bone
Goldenrod_Smooth_Bone
Oiled_Smooth_Bone
Old_Smooth_Ivory_Bone
Rust_Orange_Smooth_Bone
Smooth_Amber_Bone
Smooth_Antique_Ivory_Bone
Smooth_Antique_Yellow_Bone
Smooth_Appaloosa_Bone
Smooth_Autumn_Gold_Bone
Smooth_Blood_Red_Bone
Smooth_Brown_Wood_Bone
Smooth_Buckthorn_Bone
Smooth_Calico_Bone
Smooth_Camel_Bone
Smooth_Cherry_Bone
Smooth_Chestnut_Bone
Smooth_Deep_Woods_Green_Bone
Smooth_Green_Banana_Bone
Smooth_Green_Bone
Smooth_Ivory_Bone
Smooth_Mango_Bone
Smooth_Motley_Bone
Smooth_Oiled_Bone
Smooth_Oiled_Camel_Bone
Smooth_Orange_Bone
Smooth_Parchment_Bone
Smooth_Red_Bone
Smooth_Rotten_Banana_Bone
Smooth_White_Bone
Smooth_White_Engraved_Bone
Smooth_Yellow_Bone
Smooth_Yellow_Rose_Bone
 
Last edited:
Micartas
Black_Canvas_Micarta
Black_Linen_Micarta
Black_Micarta
Blue_Denim_Micarta
Bone_Canvas_Micarta
Brown_Burlap_Micarta
Brown_Canvas_Micarta
Burgundy_Linen_Micarta
Burgundy_Micarta
Burlap_Micarta
Canvas_Micarta
Denim_Micarta
Goldenrod_Micarta
Green_Burlap_Micarta
Ivory_Micarta
Jigged_Natural_Canvas_Micarta
Jigged_Od_Green_Canvas_Micarta
Maroon_Jigged_Micarta
Maroon_Linen_Micarta
Muslin_Micarta
Natural_Canvas_Micarta
Natural_Jigged_Micarta
Natural_Linen_Micarta
Natural_Paper_Micarta
OD_Green_Canvas_Micarta
OD_Green_Linen_Micarta
OD_Green_Micarta
Orange_Burlap_Micarta
Orange_Curacao_Burlap_Micarta
Red_Burlap_Micarta
Red_Linen_Micarta
Rust_Red_Micarta
Smoke_Burlap_Micarta
Smooth_Goldenrod_Micarta
Tan_Burlap_Micarta
 
Acrylics/Perylics
American_Patriot_Acrylic
Babylon_Copper_Acrylic
Babylon_Silver_Acrylic
Babylon_Yellow_Acrylic
Black/Gray_Acrylic
Black/White_Acrylic
Black/Yellow_Acrylic
Black_Gold_Acrylic
Black_Pearl_Acrylic
Blood_Stone_Acrylic
Blue/Black_Acrylic
Blue/Brown_Acrylic
Blue_Angel_Acrylic
Blue_Corduroy_Acrylic
Blue_Denim_Acrylic
Blue_Oyster_Acrylic
Blue_Streak_Acrylic
Blue_Swirl_Acrylic
Blue_Tuna_Acrylic
Burnt_Sky_Acrylic
Caribbean_Acrylic
Carmel_Apple_Acrylic
Cats_Cradle_Acrylic
Charcoal_Acrylic
Cherry_Soda_Acrylic
Chocolate_Acrylic
Chocolate_Swirl_Acrylic
Christmas_Lights_Acrylic
Cinnamon_Sugar_Acrylic
Coffeehouse_Acrylic
Copper_Melt_Acrylic
Copper_Snake_Acrylic
Coppertone_Acrylic
Coyote_Camo_Acrylic
Cracked_Marble_Acrylic
Cranberry_Acrylic
Crusader_Acrylic
Crushed_Pineapple_Acrylic
Dead_Skunk_Acrylic
Draft_Beer_Acrylic
Dreamsicle_Acrylic
Emerald_Green_Acrylic
Faded_Denim_Acrylic
Fall_Harvest_Acrylic
Fire_Brick_Acrylic
Fire_Flames_Acrylic
Fish_Scale_Acrylic
Fools_Gold_Acrylic
Glitter_Gold_Acrylic
Gray/White_Acrylic
Green_Swirl_Acrylic
Green_Velvet_Acrylic
Grey_Pearl_Acrylic
Grits_and_Molasses_Acrylic
Hummingbird_Acrylic
Inferno_Red_Acrylic
Ivory_Acrylic
Kryptonite_Acrylic
Lava_Acrylic
Lava_Flow_Acrylic
Leprechaun_Acrylic
Lightning_Bug_Acrylic
Mardi_Gras_Acrylic
Mint_Chocolate_Swirl_Acrylic
Neon_Blue_Acrylic
Neptune_Acrylic
Nifebrite_Acrylic
Northern_Lights_Acrylic
Olive_Acrylic
Orange/Black_Acrylic
Orange_Peel_Acrylic
Patriot_Acrylic
Pheasant_Feather_Acrylic
Pumpkin_Patch_Acrylic
Radiation_Acrylic
Red_Acrylic
Red_River_Acrylic
Rhubarb_Acrylic
Rootbeer_Float_Acrylic
Runaway_Beagle_Acrylic
Salmon_Acrylic
Sandbar_Acrylic
Sandstone_Acrylic
Sea_Glass_Acrylic
Seashell_Acrylic
Shark_Attack_Acrylic
Smokey_Pearl_Acrylic
Snakeskin_Acrylic
Solar_Flare_Acrylic
Southwest_Turquoise_Acrylic
Spring_Tulip_Acrylic
St_Pattys_Day_Acrylic
Staffordshire_Blue_Acrylic
Strawberry_Shortcake_Acrylic
Sunbrite_Acrylic
Tan/White_Acrylic
Tiger_Acrylic
Tiger_Eye_Acrylic
Tomato_Acrylic
Tortoise_Shell_Acrylic
Twilight_Acrylic
Unicorn_Ivory_Acrylic
Water_Snake_Acrylic
Western_Sunset_Acrylic
White_Acrylic
White_Pearl_Acrylic
Wildfire_Acrylic
 
Jigged woods
Jigged_American_Cherry_Wood
Jigged_Bocote_Wood
Jigged_Brazilian_Cherry_Wood
Jigged_Bubinga_Wood
Jigged_Cherry_Wood
Jigged_Wenge_Wood
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top