- Joined
- Jul 31, 2015
- Messages
- 2,556
Jack of all trades, master of none.
My Charge AL is a good example. If I'm using the 'tool' tools - pliers, screwdriver, file, ruler and scissors I'm unlikely to be needing both blades and a saw. If I'm using blades, can opener and saw I'm unlikely to be needing a screwdriver. I can see certain occupations where it all comes together but they're not all that widespread. As such having a 'workshop' tool and an 'outdoors' tool seems to make more sense, you're not carrying a bunch of weight that is rarely going to be used. If you're just tossing it into the car or boat then why not have either real tools or a more dedicated tool set for either. That and the tools being very much 'I can't reach the real stuff', especially the pliers (weak), saw (small), scissors (tiny) and flat screwdriver bits (very prone to stripping phillips and hex) mean that I'm not hugely convinced by the application of the concept. More task specific multitool tool sets would make more sense to me. There are some out there, I carried the Skeletool for a couple of years but again, the toolsets are not all that pleasant to use if you could get your hands on real tools.
That said I think SAK options are indeed better segregated by use case and small enough to make much more sense. If you need something bigger you should be using something bigger anyway. It's not trying to be something that it isn't.
My Charge AL is a good example. If I'm using the 'tool' tools - pliers, screwdriver, file, ruler and scissors I'm unlikely to be needing both blades and a saw. If I'm using blades, can opener and saw I'm unlikely to be needing a screwdriver. I can see certain occupations where it all comes together but they're not all that widespread. As such having a 'workshop' tool and an 'outdoors' tool seems to make more sense, you're not carrying a bunch of weight that is rarely going to be used. If you're just tossing it into the car or boat then why not have either real tools or a more dedicated tool set for either. That and the tools being very much 'I can't reach the real stuff', especially the pliers (weak), saw (small), scissors (tiny) and flat screwdriver bits (very prone to stripping phillips and hex) mean that I'm not hugely convinced by the application of the concept. More task specific multitool tool sets would make more sense to me. There are some out there, I carried the Skeletool for a couple of years but again, the toolsets are not all that pleasant to use if you could get your hands on real tools.
That said I think SAK options are indeed better segregated by use case and small enough to make much more sense. If you need something bigger you should be using something bigger anyway. It's not trying to be something that it isn't.