Benchmade 551 Pardue Griptilian

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Jun 18, 2000
Messages
10,761
This knife is a true rarity.
How often do you find an American made one-hand folder, with excellent blade-steel, with one of the strongest locks in the industry, designed by a master knife craftsman, and all at a price that the average "working Joe" can afford?
A very rare find indeed.

One thing becomes obvious when you get your hands on the 551:
it is more than the sum of its parts.

The parts themselves, while totally serviceable, are decidedly not the creme de la creme.
Noryl GTX instead of G-10
410 SS liners instead of titanium
440C instead of S30V or BG-42 (or whatever the latest and greatest blade-steel is at the time)

However, Benchmade and Mel Pardue certainly make the most of these parts and created one terrific knife.

The Blade:
Some folks will spend hundreds of dollars (sometimes thousands) and search far and wide for that "Holy Grail" of blade-steel. A steel that does not rust or tarnish or stain. A steel that can obtain a razor-edge and never lose that edge no matter what you cut or how much you cut.
440C is not that steel.
But it is a very good steel that accomplishes alot of the "Grail" requirments.
It is very resistant to rust and corrosion.
It can be honed to a razor-sharpness.
And, with the proper heat treatment, it will hold an edge for a long time.
Benchmade does an excellent job with the heat treatment (58-60 HRC) for their 440C.
I have used several knives with 440C from Spyderco, Benchmade, and Boker.
I like this steel because it holds its edge for a very respectable amount of useage yet it is'nt too difficult to resharpen.
It also holds up extremely well to the humid Carolina summers without showing signs of rust.

I also like the blade design of the 551.
Mel Pardue certainly knows what he's doing when it comes to blades.
The 551 has a beautiful drop-point with plenty of belly. Combine that with the flat-grind and it makes a great slicer.
And the tip of the blade is strong enough for any task that requires a knife.

The dual thumbstuds on the blade (in conjunction with the amazing Axis-lock) work with the greatest of ease.
They are not too long or too short. And they are not too rough (like the CRKT M16) or too smooth.
And they don't get in the way when sharpening.

The pocket-clip works very well, and with the help of the handle texturing, will keep the knife in your pocket even when running and jumping.
The clip can be moved for left-handers or right-handers but only allows for tip-up carry.

The Axis-lock is simply amazing.
It's hard for words to describe just how secure and strong yet simple to operate this lock performs.
If you don't have an Axis-lock knife then you really are missing out.
A forum search of the Axis-lock will give you alot more information.

The handle:
I both like and dislike the 551's handle.
I like how the handle fills the hand. In fact, it's one of the most comfortable one-hand folders that I've ever used.
The checkering on the sides of the handle may or may not be helpful (except to assist the pocket-clip in keeping the knife in the pocket). Since the pocket-clip rests against my palm, only my fingers actually come in to contact with the checkering.
I think the real security-of-grip comes from the grooves and ridges on the top and bottom of the handle, and from the slight intergrated guard.

What I don't like about the handle is the hollow sound and plastic feel.
From the lock upwards, the knife feels bulldog tough.
But from just below the lock and downward to the butt, the knife feels much less substantial.
Mind you, I say "FEELS" less substantial.
And it is just that--a feeling.
Actually, the entire handle is very tough and rugged and can take about whatever you can dish out.

I sometimes wish that Benchmade would release a G-10 Griptilian, but then I think "would there be a real performance advantage when used in a folding knife with dual steel liners?".
Maybe and maybe not.
Maybe I would only want G-10 because it would "feel" better.

G-10 aside, I think the 551 is one of the very best one-hand folders that is affordable to the average guy.
I bought mine from a local hunting store and paid $65.oo dollars.
After using the knife for a while, I think I got a real bargain.

So if you're looking for a full-sized one-hand folder, with great blade-steel, a terrific lock, excellent blade design, tough yet comfortable handle, at a great price, then check out a Benchmade 551 Pardue Griptilian.

Thanks for listening,
Allen.
 
nice review, i'm currently eyeing the 550 with holes instead of studs.
thanks for the reading!
 
I had a 550 with the Olive Drab handle (and I did an initial impressions review here on the forum).
I gave it to my brother-in-law because it was partially serrated (I now prefer plain-edged knives) and my thumb would often slip off the hole without opening the blade.

Give both models a good test before you decide.

Good luck,
Allen.
 
Great review. I have 552,555,556 and 558 Griptilians.
I don't dislike the Noryl GTX handles. Modern Polymers are lightweight and strong.
The Glock series of pistols have proved this.
 
Great review Allen!

I think the checkered texture make it "grippier" to handle when pulling the knife out of your pocket and while manipulating int into position to open the blade. It's not going to slip out of your hand!

The "hollow" handle is what makes this knife light enough to carry without much notice. It's sturdy where it needs to be...I consider this good engineering!

After reaserching all the one-hand folders I chose the 550OD with plain edge. The OD is discontinued but I found it on sale for $49. I wasn't sure about the olive drab color but it's grown on me I now prefer it over the black. I'm very pleased with it.

Had I not found that 550OD, I would have bought the Ritter Griptialian. It's few $$$ more than the typical street price of the 550 & 551's but better grind and S30V steel.

I'm a happy 550 owner! :)

Collecter
 
allenC,

What a great and awesome post. I realize this is an old thread but simply doing a search and reading your thread has caused me to simply go buy a Griptilian.

I've been looking all around trying to find the best EDC knife and I've come to understand that I could be looking for the rest of my life.

I'm going to take the plunge and spend $60 on a Griptilian from Benchmade. The other $40 I save I can buy a Swiss Army Knife with or a slipjoint, or go out to dinner with.

I think we all get way to caught up in the Steel Hype Thing.

Thanks allenC!:thumbup:
 
Thanks you for the kind words.

It really is a very nice knife, and I'm sure that you will enjoy it.
Now if only we can do something about that handle...
Maybe Benchmade is afraid that if they put G-10 on the 551, it will kill the sales of their other knives?


Allen.
 
I agree, I have a 551 and love it. I end up carrying it more than my BM 710 due to its size.
 
OUTSTANDING review....you cover just about everything. I happen to agree with you.....its just a remarkable folding knife for the price !........
I think the 551 is one of the very best one-hand folders that is affordable to the average guy.
I bought mine from a local hunting store and paid $65.oo dollars.
After using the knife for a while, I think I got a real bargain.
So if you're looking for a full-sized one-hand folder, with great blade-steel, a terrific lock, excellent blade design, tough yet comfortable handle, at a great price, then check out a Benchmade 551 Pardue Griptilian.

-Regards
 
I have a 550/thumbhole/modified sheepsfoot and also enjoy using it. For most of my EDC things during the week, it is a little large, but then, that's what the Mini-Grip is for:D I also have a 556/drop point/PE and between it and my Delica, they are probably my most used.

- gord
 
That's a great review. The Grips are becoming (if not already there) legendary for their overall performance.

I also like the less expensive PIKA in 440C. Have you ever handled one?
 
Nope, I have never handled a PIKA.
Give us a review if you have the time.

Cheers,
Allen.
 
I must stay I'm always interested in a better steel, but the better steel isnt always the newest. 440C does a credible job on my TSEK 805, but I find it neccessary to remove the thumb studs for sharpening. For that reason, I would probably choose a 550 or 555 instead of the drop point. I handled/sharpened a friends 551S and didnt need to remove them for the serrations on the sharpmaker, but my 805 is plain edge and to get the angle I want near the handle, the studs have to come off.
 
Me2 - If you want to win some bets with knife users bet them that 440C has a higher chromium content than their favorite steel. You will almost be guaranteed to win (17% vrs. 14% for ATS-34). Heat treated properly it is one of my favorites.

http://www.ajh-knives.com/metals.html


AllenC -

Here is some Benchmade "PIKA" info.

http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=334954&highlight=pika

http://benchmadeforum.com/groupee/forums/a/tpc/f/158106573/m/906109183/r/888100136#888100136

http://www.benchmade.com/products/product_detail.aspx?model=10400

The Griptillian is still a classic!
 
for the same price i would rather have my spyderco manix 2 its still made in the U.S but it has a much better steel (CTS BD1) and it still has spydercos version of the axis lock
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top