Benchmade Black Class, failing pommel strike tests (Axis lock failure)

Discussion in 'Benchmade Knife Company' started by Londinium Armoury, Jul 27, 2020.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. dano

    dano

    Oct 3, 1998
    Or...tighten the pivot a bit. The whole notion of "Drop shutting" is silly (and offtopic....)
     
    Knife-Nut-79, Lee D and Silent H like this.
  2. Halfneck

    Halfneck

    Jun 30, 2005
    Something I was wondering about. One of the knives mentioned was a de-assisted Barrage. Maybe the others have had the pivots loosened quite a bit so the knife can be easily opened & closed?
     
  3. Roy Batty

    Roy Batty Y'all can sling load DEEZ NUTS Platinum Member

    May 25, 2016
    If pommel strikes are a big deal for you, and Benchmade knives don’t fit your need, buy a new knife.

    Benchmade isn’t going to just suddenly stop making the axis lock just because a self proclaimed “knife fighting expert” has an issue. It’s statistically insignificant.

    A knife is a cutting instrument. What next? Complaints about hammers not being able to cut tomatoes? Or screwdrivers that don’t make great chisels? There are plenty of other knives out there that pommel just fine if that’s your thing.
     
    mdrgn79 likes this.
  4. craytab

    craytab

    Jan 26, 2012
    So, you are going to ask other people to post videos of their knives not failing but you yourself will not test the problem in a more realistic way with your hand actually gripping the knife? Sorry, this isn't valid.

    Also, the whole premise of this is silly. Just because a knife used in a way not intended by the manufacturer, fails a test that no one but a tiny portion of the knife buying population cares about, you think benchmade should change their marketing? Just silly...
     
    mdrgn79, Nbrackett and Airborne 1 like this.
  5. tokerblue

    tokerblue

    May 1, 2010
    I'm not sure what this video is supposed to show either. If you use a knife or lock how it isn't intended to be used, I'm not surprised when it fails. It's not really better than spine whack tests. If you need a knife that has a lock that won't fail, get a fixed blade.
     
  6. Scott321

    Scott321

    Jul 20, 2016
    IMO, I prefer to have the knife closed for pommel strikes. Some blade shapes and designs work better than others, i.e. the BM 523's spine shape makes it very uncomfortable to tightly grasp it when closed, where the Stryker 2 is very comfortable when closed. Similarly, the Spyderco Yojimbo 2's spine shape, IMO, seems more designed for a closed blade pommel strike than a thumb rest while cutting.

    Additionally, it seems like from all the spine wack videos, that most locks have an increased chance to fail when you start bouncing on the spines repeatedly... and although the Tri-Ad lock might not have this issue, most of their pommels are Grivory.

    I do think that if you plan on using a knife in a certain way, that it is important to test that technique. An old used tire (or a stack of them) can be used. It might also make one adjust or eliminate a technique that we thought was valid, or change the tool to something more task specific. For example, I wouldn't keep open the blade on my MT while trying to use the Phillips head to tighten a screw.
     
    Silent H likes this.
  7. Makael

    Makael Books temporarily closed on sheath orders. Knifemaker / Craftsman / Service Provider

    Oct 17, 2015
    These replies are awesome:thumbsup:
    Im suprised when someone posts a complaint like this. Took the time to post a video, lengthy write up but didn't catch on as to why the lock disengaged. I'm guessing the owner sitting there looking at the lock and wondering how much force would it take to unlock the blade and came up with this example.
     
    sv4, mdrgn79 and pnsxyr like this.
  8. colin.p

    colin.p

    Feb 4, 2017
    ^^Yup, just someone looking for a way, to go out of their way, to make something fail even though in normal use, they would never be in that situation.
     
    mdrgn79 and pnsxyr like this.
  9. not2sharp

    not2sharp Gold Member Gold Member

    Jun 29, 1999
    Next up, we will find out the Triad lock fails due to pocket lint.

    n2s
     
    mdrgn79, pnsxyr and Nbrackett like this.
  10. Random Dan

    Random Dan Gold Member Gold Member

    Jan 21, 2012
    Don't forget framelocks and linerlocks failing when you grip the handle tightly and twist your grip just right.
     
    pnsxyr likes this.
  11. not2sharp

    not2sharp Gold Member Gold Member

    Jun 29, 1999
    The take away is simply, that none of these locks are fail proof and when you are going to do something other than cutting with the edge, you should put the folder away and go with a fixed blade.

    n2s
     
    AaronMB, mdrgn79, pnsxyr and 3 others like this.
  12. pnsxyr

    pnsxyr Gold Member Gold Member

    Aug 29, 2013
    That about sums it up. If I am going to spine whack my coffee table with all my might, I would much prefer to do that with my ESEE 6 than my Sebenza. :p
     
    AaronMB and mdrgn79 like this.
  13. brownshoe

    brownshoe I support this site with my MIND

    Sep 6, 2002
    Per his statements here, he's a knife fighter. Per his Youtube channel he's:

    Combining all known sword based historical fighting systems from across the globe, HEMA, Kenjutsu, Chinese Swordsmanship and much more.

    Sword is not a knife. He ain't no cop. He's trolling for hits, this video has about 3x more than his usual youtube video.
     
    Last edited: Aug 9, 2020
  14. colin.p

    colin.p

    Feb 4, 2017
    I do have to confess I didn't watch any of his videos, but I figured that was what he was aiming for.
     
  15. JBC6650

    JBC6650 Gold Member Gold Member Basic Member

    388
    Jul 19, 2008
    I'd hate to have to slap the snot out of my son if I found him doing something stupid like this. I'm glad my kids aren't autistic or mentally challenged, whatever the politically correct term is now...but it makes for entertaining YouTube when idiots like this one injury themselves.

    Side note, can't believe I found myself agreeing with Roy, crazy 2020.
     
    Airborne 1, scottc3 and mdrgn79 like this.
  16. Silent H

    Silent H

    986
    Feb 1, 2018
    You might want to differentiate between garden variety stupid and actual mental disorders. This case falls into the former for sure.

    As for the second part... Broken clocks and what not...
     
    brownshoe likes this.
  17. brownshoe

    brownshoe I support this site with my MIND

    Sep 6, 2002
    I know a PhD and an MD who have autism.

    The original poster hasn't returned to his thread. Guess he agrees it's BS
     
  18. scottc3

    scottc3 Gold Member Gold Member

    542
    Oct 11, 2014
    Many such folks on the spectrum may be described as brilliant. The marry have babies , voila.
     
  19. DMG

    DMG Gold Member Gold Member

    478
    Dec 30, 2005
    If I ever get to the point that I am doing pommel strikes on a barstool I really hope someone takes the knife away from me and drives me home.
     
    colin.p, Nbrackett and Roy Batty like this.
  20. Roy Batty

    Roy Batty Y'all can sling load DEEZ NUTS Platinum Member

    May 25, 2016
    Well who even uses the pommel in a close quarters knife fight, with the blade open? How does that play out? “Well I was going to stab this guy but I found out at last second that he’s really my long lost brother and he’s in a drug induced psychotic rage so I don’t want to stab him, just bop him on the noggin with my pommel and take him home to sleep it off”.
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page