Best all around size for an axe?

Joined
Jun 4, 2008
Messages
1,944
Just like the title says......What size handle, head, would you guys prefer for all around use? Full size(35" like the felling axe from council), or smaller(around 24"-28" like the boys axe or hudson bay size)

And, size and shape of head between those choices.....what is better for what uses?

Thanks again for all the help with my questions! (And once again, your patience with all of my questions!)

dave
 
Last edited:
Also, size and shape of the head has got me wondering too. Hudson bay type head, or boys axe type head, felling head....????????
Whats the differences?

P.s. i am reading that only 1 axe link right now......
 
I would pick a 2-1/4 to 3 lb axe with a 28" to 32" haft. My friend has a 2-3/4 lb axe on a 32" handle. It acts like a full size axe yet it's a bit more nimble. But I slightly prefer my boy's axe.

There are so many variables that there can't be one best all around axe.
 
I was looking at the Boys axe Forest service edition, and i like it, but Bens is sold out. Can't seem to find it anywhere else?
GB has a 31" American Felling axe at 3 lbs. That is nice too, but im still wondering if the hudson bay head type is better or worse than this type. Thanks again.
 
I really think that different types of axes should be seen as specialty tools...

Want to knock down trees? 4lb axe if you're athletic (3-3.5 otherwise).
Rough terrain? I like 36" handle to keep the bit away from me. Doesn't work as well in dense forest though.
Nice terrain? 32? handle works.

In the summer...
Want to canoe in and make camp? Consider a SFA sized axe if you have to portage -- cutting takes longer but less weight.

Backpacking/bushcraft? Consider a 20" handle and a 1.75-2.5lb head, depending on how much you depend on the axe. With this size, you can still make a campfire quickly by splitting out smaller stuff (hold log against axe bit parallel to handle and hit both on bigger log)

In the winter...
Consider sizing up, since you're going to need a lot of wood to stay warm. I wouldn't like to be snow backpacking with a mini-hatchet or whatever unless there were lots of easy timber already down.

Personally, I mostly buy 4-5lb felling axes. I don't hike more than 2 miles with them -- they're used to work blowdown sites deep in the canadian bush (read: chop many very large trees quickly). If you tried to do this with a smaller axe or anything that wasn't very nicely sharpened, you'd be chopping for the rest of time (ask me how I know...). Sure wouldn't want to try to find room for a 36" handle in my backpacking pack, though (or add 5lbs to the load)
 
Okay, I changed my list a bit. I really want to go as big as i can with still being able to strap it to my huge pack. thanks
 
Welcome to the discussion. Be ready to explain the 1.5 million variables that can effect your decision.

Then decide on a basic axe and all will be right with the world again.
 
Ok, this may sound silly. I went to home depot, not to buy anything, just to hold their 3.5 lb. 32" piece of junk single bitted axe that they carry. Now, i did pull a muscle in my hand, the muscle that controls the whole thumb area, down into the hand, so my hand is a bit sore. But, the axe there felt very heavy to me, and like i said before, i swing a 6 lb sledge hammer at work a lot. But this just felt very heavy, almost too heavy. Now, this can very well be because of my hand, so i will try again tomorrow. But, I was looking at the GB American Felling at 31", and now Im kind of shyed away from it in my choices.
I don't want something that won't work for anything than strictly splitting wood, and I can't imaging chopping wood with even a heavier axe. Im not weak, but like i said my hand does hurt a bit. And, maybe it was the fiberglass handle that made it feel heavier? I don't know, but Im 5"11" and skinny, about 160 lbs, but strong as hell. So, im not sure why im a bit intimidated by the 3.5 lb axe. I can't see swinging it at a piece of wood or tree without throwing it like a sledge over my shoulder.
Is there a reason I feel like this? i don't want to get an axe thats too heavy for me, but from what i read 3.5 lb is not that heavy, and again, please refrain from the "everyone is different" speech, as I really am stronger than most guys even a good deal heavier than me. But that axe just felt like a freaking sledge hammer in my hands. Any advice? At the same time, if I need a good light axe, I don't want to go out and spend tons of cash on a fancy "hatchet" type of axe either.
I hope i explained this right. I will go to the store again to see if my hand feels better about it.... thanks

dave
 
Okkay, I went to the store again, and it seems my hand is feeling better, and the 3 lb axe with 32" handles doesnt seem really TOOOO heavy, so now im thinking more between the GB American Felling, and the CT Boys axe. any real differences in these?
 
Back
Top