Best value/quality chef's knife for $50

Joined
Feb 7, 2014
Messages
198
If you could only spend $50 on a chef's knife, what would you buy, and why? I've been looking at 8" blades from Victorinox/Forschner as well as the Wasabi series by Kershaw. From reading here, it seems like the Old Hickory blades are not what they used to be? The edge retention of a carbon steel does interest me.
 
Shun Sora Model VB0706. It's a hair over $50 (about $56) from my favorite large online retailer, but this is an incredible knife - even more so in person. Easily the sharpest factory edge of any knife, and the fit/finish is impeccable.
 
What do you want to do with the knife? (ex: some knives are heavier/tougher and can cut tougher materials but lack in the finer cutting versus some knives that favor a thinner blade that is much more comfortable for general usage but are not advised for things like bone.) I personally prefer having a few thick cheapies to do that occasional harsh cutting and a nicer thinner gyuto for the large majority of what I do that isn't on foods that tend to damage blades.

Does reactivity matter?

I like most Kershaw products but am not a fan of their kitchen knives and I think some less expensive makers do a better job with their VG-10. Also at the upper-end of their price range, there are a lot of other options using really attractive steels like Super Blue, for example. Overall, I just haven't felt the models I have owned/used were very good values because of other offerings that were equal or less costly and what I feel are knives of equal or superior quality.

I am a really big fan of Tojiro knives and think that relative to their pricing that they have an excellent fit and finish, great VG-10 heat treatment, and very good edge retention. While a little over $50, I think one would be hard-pressed to find many other knives of that quality for that price. And I think compared to Wustof, Global, or Shun it is a pretty noticeable improvement. So if it were me personally, that in an 8 inch is what I would probably buy.

I have also used some of the less expensive products from Kikuichi, SETO, Fujiwara, and Richmond, and I think all of these brands have some really nice knives relative to the cost and deliver a great product. Most of the entry models these makers offer are still a little higher than budget, but you can sometimes find them for reasonable discounts and huge discounts if buying used.

I also like most of the kitchen products coming from Spyderco and Victorinox. Neither currently offers a chef's knife that fits me personally, but many of their other knives I find to be value priced and of great quality for that price.
 
For home use, the Victorinox/forschner's are hard to beat. others to check -out.
mundial's 5100 series
http://www.amazon.com/Mundial-Series-8-Inch-Chefs-Knife/dp/B0002LXWAM/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1404188635&sr=8-2&keywords=mundial+knives

Messermeister has some good quality knives in different price ranges
http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=sr_nr_n_1?rh=n%3A1055398%2Cn%3A289857%2Ck%3Amessermeister+knives&keywords=messermeister+knives&ie=UTF8&qid=1404189072&rnid=1063498

I have a set of the Meridian Elite, they came super sharp out of the box & sharpen easily.
 
I just need a good, basic knife, for general use in the kitchen. I don't foresee myself needing to chop through bones. A nice balance between stain resistance and edge retention would be ideal. Thanks for the suggestions so far!
 
If that is the case, then if it were me personally I would buy a Tojiro 8 or 9 inch gyuto (chef's knife) as I think relative to the price that it is very hard to beat and performs like a knife priced much higher than it is.
 
I think its hard to beat my suggestion.
Its ginsanko steel (stainless), got a great profile and I think it got a good geometry.

The seller is famous for low price kitchenknives and is highly respected for his flawless service.
 
They are good knives for the money and many people really like their forged products. The Genesis line (which is forged) is the one people generally speak most highly of, and I like their 8 inch Genesis Chef Knife. Like Wustof, they are hefty, tough, versatile, durable, but on the softer side and edge-holding reflects this. It's often compared with the Victorinox Fibrox, which I really like and really, really like the handle on.
 
Dexter Russell, if you walk into a professional kitchen, nine times out of ten the house knives will be Dexter Russell. They are solid, simple, no frills tools. I have a couple in my knife roll, specifically a 10" bread knife, an 8" Chinese Cleaver, and an Oyster knife.
 
Dexter Russell, if you walk into a professional kitchen, nine times out of ten the house knives will be Dexter Russell. They are solid, simple, no frills tools. I have a couple in my knife roll, specifically a 10" bread knife, an 8" Chinese Cleaver, and an Oyster knife.

This. Back before I landed a job in a kitchen, I thought a Wusthof was the end-all, be-all that I should strive for. After a month, I realized almost all the knives were Dexter Russells. Wound up picking one up while at the supply store, and I couldn't find one complaint to give you. And you could walk away with more than a few bucks in change (was less than 35 bucks for the V-Low 8" Chef Knife...I'm actually planning on getting a Nakiri from DR now).
 
I'm a big fan of the Friedrich Dick ProDynamic series. Friedrich Dick uses the same steel on most of their knives that Vic/Forschner does, but uses a slightly harder heat treatment. I feel the edge stability and retention on them is a noticeable notch up from the Vic/Forschner knives, as are the ergonomics. Funny name, great knives. Just stick with their industrial models with polymer handles like the ProDynamic and ErgoGrip series. They're the strongest value in my opinion.
 
For home use, the Victorinox/forschner's are hard to beat. others to check -out.
mundial's 5100 series
http://www.amazon.com/Mundial-Series-8-Inch-Chefs-Knife/dp/B0002LXWAM/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1404188635&sr=8-2&keywords=mundial+knives

Messermeister has some good quality knives in different price ranges
http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=sr_nr_n_1?rh=n%3A1055398%2Cn%3A289857%2Ck%3Amessermeister+knives&keywords=messermeister+knives&ie=UTF8&qid=1404189072&rnid=1063498

I have a set of the Meridian Elite, they came super sharp out of the box & sharpen easily.


I concur with the Victorinox/Forschner recommendation. It is a commercial chef's favorite according to certain tests. They also make a great boning/filet knife. Here are some videos of the knives in action. Great bang for the buck, IMHO.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2q9vle7zJBE



https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mNmrxFzz1Xw



http://www.chefsresource.com/cooks-illustrated-recommends.html



Certain cutlery must meet hygiene tests in commercial kitchens and these do that.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e8o6Hh4tb-E
 
Last edited:
i own a forschner 10" wood handle, solid knife with over a decade of serious use on it. there are also tons of dexter russel knives banging around as house knives as others have mentioned. i have used these knives and sharpened them. they take a serious beating and keep on keeping on. these knives stand the test of time. get one. then learn how to sharpen it! :)
 
Bump your budget up to ~$70 and pick up a Fujiwara FKH (Japanese Carbon steel SKD-4) that takes a great edge, durable and will be great to start you down the rabbit hole of high quality kitchen cutlery.
 
Back
Top