Buck Marksman detailed review

Joined
Jul 9, 2013
Messages
220
Buck Marksman review (this specific Buck Marksman was built on 6-18-14)

The Marksman is an eye catching knife, and possibly the biggest leap for Buck in quite awhile. I'm glad they took the leap. This knife is one of a kind, and other than a few very small mishaps, the knife would be in a league of it's own at this price point. It features Buck's new Strong Lock System, which is a strap lock with a few modifications, and a nice 154CM 3.5'' blade. The Marksman is a collaboration between Buck and Grant & Gavin Hawk. Another plus, the Marksman is 100% Made in the USA. I picked up the Marksman for $82.99 from an online retailing giant.

2la50xz.jpg

2zrpd1e.jpg

34xj5g3.jpg

30087r8.jpg

f046lu.jpg


Aesthetics: The Marksman is stunning, no question about it. It has a look of none other, and the blade shape in my opinion is PERFECT. The Black Aluminum handles really offset the bead blasted blade finish.

Materials: The Marksman is put together very well, with the exception of a few pieces of soft (pot metal) hardware, which I will get to later. The knife is also extremely light when accounted for the quality of materials it is made up of, the Marksman clocks in at 4 oz. The knife is shockingly light.

The handles are milled Aluminum, and feel very high quality. The Blade is 3.5'' 154CM with BOS Heat Treat in a bead blasted finish.
The negative on this front are what I consider to be cheap pot metal screws that hold the strap lock in place. These are located on the top of the strap lock. When adjusting the strap lock one must be very careful not to over tighten these screws, they will distort and strip if not careful. I have replacement screws being sent from Buck free of charge. The strap lock screws need to be hardened, plain and simple. Another negative, is that the blade stop pin is metal inserted into an Aluminum handle. Metal beats steel, and thus after hard use the stop pin will wiggle slightly. This can be compensated by loosening the top two strap lock screws, and slightly tightening the strap lock adjustment screw, followed by tightening back up the strap lock screws.

Cutting ability: The Marksman will cut through cardboard, foam, wire, string without effort. I found it to also hold its own with some moderate wood work such as whittling, cutting small branches, etc. The knife came extremely sharp, possibly the sharpest knife I've ever owned. The hollow grind really helps the knife cut through various materials like they are butter.

Function: The Marksman is ultra smooth thanks to the blade riding on two sets of caged ball bearings. You will be stunned how smooth this knife pivots.

The knife can be opened by either a flipper or thumb hole. The flipper works fantastic, and is the fastest non assisted flipper I've ever used. The thumb hole is also a nice option, especially when in an office environment. The thumb hole provides a smooth, steady, and quite way to open, as the flipper method provides a clank when opening.

When opened, and closed the knife is held in place by a strap lock at the top of the knife.

At first glance, closing the blade may be a two handed ordeal for a day or so for some folks. Buck states to pull up on the strap lock while pulling down on the blade to close the knife. I was very surprised and pleased to find one handed closing very easy, although you will develop a callous on the tip of your Right index finger if you follow this closing method. With the knife open, simply hold the knife in your Right hand, pull the front of strap lock upwards with your Right index finger, hold knife parallel to ground, the weight of the blade and gravity will do the rest to close the blade. In terms of how the Marksman feels in the hands, superb. The grooves in the handle scales really lock your hands in, and the overall shape is well designed.

Over time parts will wear, settle in to place, and leave a bit of play in the lockup. No fear, there is an adjustment screw in Marksman that will pull the strap lock towards the rear of the knife, thus making lockup feel like a bank vault.

Also worth mentioning is the deep carry pocket clip. In my opinion, there is none better. Simple, elegant design.

Tools needed for disassembly:

-Pivot: T10
-Handle screws & pocket clip screws: T6

-2 Strap Lock screws: 1/16'' Hex
-1 Strap Lock adjustment screw: .050'' Hex

Conclusion: There's no doubt Buck should offer the Marksman in different sizes, blade types, and color configurations. This knife aims to be fill a tactical, military, EDC role, and no doubt a Marksman with OD Green handle scales with a Black blade coating would sell like hotcakes. Not too mention various other combinations.

To finish up, if I lost this knife, or somehow broke the blade, I would go out and buy another one. It's a fantastic knife, and a very modern knife from Buck.

Buy it.
 
Last edited:
I agree. My favorite knife on the market. High cut power and great heat treat. Tough as nails and reliable lock. Also my first buck in years. Way to kick it up a notch.
 
Last edited:
Could you please go into more detail on your issue with the pick lock screws?

The threads, or the tool interface or both parts of the screw are at issue?

I adjust the top screws with a high end hex tool without issue on my early production 830. Are you certain that you have been using the correct tool, of good quality, on the top two screws? For example, use a low quality tool that isn't fitting properly could damage the tool seat on the screw. Or, using a wrong tool like a torx when a hex is called for could also damage the screw/tool interface. Small hex screws can look like torx screws so if your tool fits poorly then apply force at your risk or obtain the correct tool of proper quality.

Thank you.
 
Excellent review, Bradytx. :thumbup: It looks like next month's knife is picked out for me. Unless of course I run across an Alpha Dorado I am missing. ;)
 
Could you please go into more detail on your issue with the pick lock screws?

The threads, or the tool interface or both parts of the screw are at issue?

I adjust the top screws with a high end hex tool without issue on my early production 830. Are you certain that you have been using the correct tool, of good quality, on the top two screws? For example, use a low quality tool that isn't fitting properly could damage the tool seat on the screw. Or, using a wrong tool like a torx when a hex is called for could also damage the screw/tool interface. Small hex screws can look like torx screws so if your tool fits poorly then apply force at your risk or obtain the correct tool of proper quality.

Thank you.

The tool interface/seat distorts when using a proper 1/16'' Hex Key when tightening down the strap lock screws. On another Marksman, one of the strap lock screws were stripped from the factory at the tool interface. From what I understand a good portion of Buck Marksman's have Torx strap lock screws, but on the newer Marksman's these are now Hex screws. Even when I contacted Buck they said to use a T6 instead of the required 1/16'' Hex as I have on mine. The Marksman with, in my opinion, the soft screws were built on 6-18-14.
 
Here is the hex tool that I use to work the strap screws, professional quality snap-on. It fits like a glove and doesn't flop about when inserted into the screw, unlike a cheaper hex wrench I tried once and never again. I use two fingers on the socket and ignore the socket wrench.



The user errors on adjustable Buck knives is legendary (not that this is you, of course). For example, titanium 186 was produced for one year because users took them down and couldn't build them back up. The next year they were pinned together and re-named 560. Buck was overwhelmed with taken apart knives that needed building back is the story/problem.

The mis-information from Buck about the screw being hex or torx is unfortunate. The solution would be a factory tool kit endorsement or actual provision of the kit. The 186 came with a tool attached to the knife!!! I am skeptical that the screw used has been changed to or from hex. In the old days someone from Buck would chime in to clarify...
 
Back
Top