I've posted this before...
Before purchasing a micarta insingo, I'd never seen one in person. Frankly, I didn't think it looked like anything special. On a whim, I purchased one - wondering what all the buzz was about. As soon as I removed it from the signature white box, it was love at first sight. It looks SO MUCH better in person.
Pictures really don't do it justice, you must hold it to understand the attraction. If you're able to, I would try to go to a local shop and try them out. Worst case scenario, purchase both and you will have no problem selling the one you like least. Of course, that is if you're able to let one go.