Chinese whetstones of various materials

nox

Joined
Mar 15, 2016
Messages
2
I'm looking for some good stones for an edge pro clone. I've never heard of these types of stones:

s-l1600.jpg


Does anyone have any experience with these types of products or dmdtools from china?

Thanks!

http://www.ebay.com/itm/8PCS-Fix-An...8172d3d&pid=100005&rk=2&rkt=6&sd=311379381317
 
I'm looking for some good stones for an edge pro clone. I've never heard of these types of stones:
Does anyone have any experience with these types of products or dmdtools from china?
Thanks!
http://www.ebay.com/itm/8PCS-Fix-An...8172d3d&pid=100005&rk=2&rkt=6&sd=311379381317

Doesn't the clone come with stones already?
FWIW, I've seen on ebay ruixin or ADAEE 6 piece stone sets up to 3k for under $15 with shipping included (or even $2)
You can get diamonds for under 5 a piece ...
theoretically you should be to piece together a progression up to 10k for cheaper than that particular set,

Diamond Edge Pro stones (Ruixin Pro) on eBay. Any good?

Some short review of the ADAEE stones and diamonds Edge Pro Clone-Three Step/Plateau on Guided System

Boron Carbide stones

Basically, they all work, some stones may need conditioning/lapping, other might need gluing to backing again sometimes (ruixin, not adaee)
 
I've got a Boron Carbide 400/1000 combo stone from DMD. It's an OK stone but nothing special. The Chosera 1k cuts faster than the 1k from the DMD stone. The binder on the DMD stone is also very soft, so it will probably wear out pretty quick.
 
I spend well over $300 on stones, heck for $30 I would least give it a try, its not good as shapton or other high end stone, but base on my experience with ruxin pro stone its bargain. as long as it cuts the blade, $300 vs $30:) some people not gonna spend $2-400 on stones, if you rather spend that much on knife, I would just get some cheap one from ebay, it will still sharpen the knife, may not be as quick as shapton glass etc. you could also buy 1-2 pc cost you about $5 and give it a try.
 
I got a,Large 2 side from Hong Kong back in the 1980's off one of those Old Harbor Freight type Trucks that just to come through 3-4 Times a year. It still work great.
 
I bought several of these for the Edge Apex Pro, some smaller stones (some of these combination stones with the chinese #3000 "ruby whetstone") as dressing stones and some benchstones.

The Edge Pro format (i believe the #1500 is some kind of boroncarbide variant as well) comes well trued and is a good performer if your grinding surface is small. So scandi and flat grinds are a no-go. These stones perform well up to the highest imaginable pressures, they stay flat a very long time and if they feel dull you dress them with a coarse siliconcarbide stone.

The benchstones are a mystery for me. The #800 is hard like a dressing stone for grinding wheels, the #1500 is still harder than every stone in that grid rating i've ever seen. Every standard 1000 King or comparable gives you more performance for simple knife sharpening. I bought these as dressing and flattening stones for harder fine stones. They give a better surface condition than siliconcarbide stones. I have the DMT #800 and the #1500 boroncarbide benchstone, but other than stone maintenance they are of little use for me. I have used them to smooth the surface of a Spyderco ceramics fine benchstone i trued. The #1500 with oil will do a good job for refinement of the surface. My best guess is that a translucent arkansas will benefit as well of that tratment. But i like the smaller stones of 5x2 cm and 10x2,5 cm more for this task. In my view these are very versatile for stone maintenance.

Since there were a lot more and far larger stones in boroncarbide available half a year ago, my best guess is the big ones were a novelty that will slowly vanish. Siliconcarbide is cheaper and there is plenty of experience in the industry how to use that for a grinding stone. I think the large boroncarbide blocks are used in manufacturing together with finer grinding compound as a high performance grinding solution. So maybe you could true and polish your chisels and other hard tools in one go with the matching polishing paste?
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the help everyone, you might be saving me a ton of money because I was considering a set of Chosera 400/1000/3000 edge pro compatible stones from http://www.chefknivestogo.com/edgepro.html or http://stores.ebay.com/sharpeningstones/. I'm dealing with nice hardness 60 knives and I don't want to mess them up, though I'm uncertain about learning sharpening on ceramics.

I've seen piles of negative reviews for ADAEE/Ruixin stones, recommending upgrading to real edge pro stones. Mostly complaints about finish quality or glue. You're right - it's really not a big deal!

I'm not an expert so I can't tell the difference and I'm not familiar with the Chinese products. I really just need to grab some glass and sandpaper to fix up the stock stones?

I've already ordered these diamond ones for a ceramic knife I have, but I'm not sure if they're good to use on my steel knives:
http://www.aliexpress.com/item/DMD-...-sharpener-sharpenning-stone/32532198898.html
 
Last edited:
Back
Top