Recommendation? Choosing my first Bushcraft, Camping, Hiking knife

Joined
Dec 16, 2018
Messages
21
like the title says, I’m looking for a all around knife for general bushcraft, camping, hiking. Im left handed and have smaller hands. I really like the handle on my buddy’s Tops knife that gets grippier when wet. I’ve been putting a list together, but I’m overwhelmed by the endless options and wanted some of your recommendations. My budget is $100-200. I like the idea of stainless, but a coated carbon blade isn’t a dealer breaker if you guys think it won’t rust too bad out in the wilderness. I definitely want a fixed blade for strength. Here is a list of what I’m looking at so far:

-Benchmade 162 Bushcraft

-Esee 5P

-Tops BOB in CPM154

-Bark River Aurora CPM 3V

-Bark River Trakker Companion

-Buck 863 Selkirk

-SOG Pillar

-Ontario Knife Company SK-5 Blackbird

-LT Wright Bushcrafter

-Cold Steel 3V Master Hunter

-Gerber LMFII

-Bradford Guardian 5

-Swamp Rat
 
I have the cold steel master hunter in 3V. Not bad, but the tip gets pretty thin. That might be exactly what you want, or not. The handle is huge and grippy. It’s not a very pretty knife, but it does work.

I prefer my Fallkniven F1, especially the new one in Laminated CoS steel.
 
When I reach for a knife in that size, I pick up a Becker BK10. If you want to go for a smaller handle, I use a BK15--they aren't available, but the BK 16 would fill in nicely. Beckers are quite budget friendly, too.
 
I’d say any knife approaching the weight of the ESEE 5 for overnight trips, carrying it all with you, is not something you would choose to take on the next trip. It is a fun beast, but far too heavy as part of a full kit - was never designed as such. Lots of tough, lighter options available.
 
like the title says, I’m looking for a all around knife for general bushcraft, camping, hiking. Im left handed and have smaller hands. I really like the handle on my buddy’s Tops knife that gets grippier when wet. I’ve been putting a list together, but I’m overwhelmed by the endless options and wanted some of your recommendations. My budget is $100-200. I like the idea of stainless, but a coated carbon blade isn’t a dealer breaker if you guys think it won’t rust too bad out in the wilderness. I definitely want a fixed blade for strength. Here is a list of what I’m looking at so far:

-Benchmade 162 Bushcraft

-Esee 5P

-Tops BOB in CPM154

-Bark River Aurora CPM 3V

-Bark River Trakker Companion

-Buck 863 Selkirk

-SOG Pillar

-Ontario Knife Company SK-5 Blackbird

-LT Wright Bushcrafter

-Cold Steel 3V Master Hunter

-Gerber LMFII

-Bradford Guardian 5

-Swamp Rat


Oooohhh boy. That list is all over the map on steels, build quality, price, grinds, blade shapes/length, etc. A list like that is a strong indicator of someone who is running high on enthusiasm, but low on knowledge. That’s not a bad thing. We’ve all been there. None of us is born with the knowledge and individual preferences we have developed.

My suggestion is to get a Mora Companion. It’s an excellent bushcrafting knife, but more importantly you can drop $15 on the knife, and use it to learn what you want/need.

Use it in the kitchen. Use it backpacking, car camping, fire pit in the back yard, construction projects, etc... use the hell out of it. With each use, you’ll learn what you like and don’t like. Let that knife teach you. It will teach you more than we can. You don’t really learn by reading about using knives. You learn by using them.

THEN and only then, once you have the knowledge that one gains from experience, your list is going to shrink, and the knives that will likely work FOR YOU will become much more obvious.

Until that time, you’re just a drowning person flailing in the water and not knowing what you’re grabbing at.
 
like the title says, I’m looking for a all around knife for general bushcraft, camping, hiking. Im left handed and have smaller hands. I really like the handle on my buddy’s Tops knife that gets grippier when wet. I’ve been putting a list together, but I’m overwhelmed by the endless options and wanted some of your recommendations. My budget is $100-200. I like the idea of stainless, but a coated carbon blade isn’t a dealer breaker if you guys think it won’t rust too bad out in the wilderness. I definitely want a fixed blade for strength. Here is a list of what I’m looking at so far:

-Benchmade 162 Bushcraft

-Esee 5P

-Tops BOB in CPM154

-Bark River Aurora CPM 3V

-Bark River Trakker Companion

-Buck 863 Selkirk

-SOG Pillar

-Ontario Knife Company SK-5 Blackbird

-LT Wright Bushcrafter

-Cold Steel 3V Master Hunter

-Gerber LMFII

-Bradford Guardian 5

-Swamp Rat
Dude... you've been a member of this Fantastic forum since Sunday. There is a plethora of information available at your fingertips. I was a member here for months before I asked a question.
Look...and you shall find.
https://www.bladeforums.com/threads/choosing-my-first-bushcraft-camping-hiking-knife.1631196/
There is a TON of information available. And...if you find you like it here and the free information you glean, consider being a paid member.
Welcome aboard.
 
like the title says, I’m looking for a all around knife for general bushcraft, camping, hiking. Im left handed and have smaller hands. I really like the handle on my buddy’s Tops knife that gets grippier when wet. I’ve been putting a list together, but I’m overwhelmed by the endless options and wanted some of your recommendations. My budget is $100-200. I like the idea of stainless, but a coated carbon blade isn’t a dealer breaker if you guys think it won’t rust too bad out in the wilderness. I definitely want a fixed blade for strength. Here is a list of what I’m looking at so far:

-Benchmade 162 Bushcraft

-Esee 5P

-Tops BOB in CPM154

-Bark River Aurora CPM 3V

-Bark River Trakker Companion

-Buck 863 Selkirk

-SOG Pillar

-Ontario Knife Company SK-5 Blackbird

-LT Wright Bushcrafter

-Cold Steel 3V Master Hunter

-Gerber LMFII

-Bradford Guardian 5

-Swamp Rat
This is always a tough question because for many people it will take years of experience in working with various knives to find out what you like best for what you do. I can give you a bit of advice on a few of the knives on your list.

The esee 5 isn't as much a knife as a sharpened prybar. It's quality but I wouldn't carry it as a hiking knife. I like esee products. I'd look at something more like the 4 or 6. More knife like.

With bark river you might not get the steel you are paying for and the owner of the company is questionable at best.

The lmf2 has a bunch of plastic that is brittle. Also not full tang.

I like the looks of the tops. Never owned one of their products.

I would like to get that sog. Looks like a fantastic field knife.

Take a look at becker as well. Lots of offerings in many sizes. Great company.
 
I hate to be THAT guy, but if we are talking a literal FIRST dedicated Bush craft knife. I'd take your $200 budget, purchase a Mora Companion HD, and put $180 back in my wallet. For now....then force patina the carbon blade, take it outside, use the heck out of it, then pull $100 back out of your wallet and buy a Garberg. Choose carbon or stainless, but I'm telling you I have been really impressed with the stainless version.
I went with the multi mount sheath and it has been outstanding for belt, pack, roof rack of my Rav, on the ground.
I could tell you about all my "bushcraft" knives, 4 of which are on your list and dozens that aren't, or, I could give you my honest opinion after 30 years of hiking, camping, fishing. Buy a couple Mora's, dont baby them, go outside and have fun.
There will be plenty of others on the forum to stop by, argue that, and tell you to add $200 to your $200 and get a super steel wonder whizzle...I've got some, and I go back to the Mora.
 
I agree with B BitingSarcasm a Becker BK-16 would be a perfect knife to start with. That Becker will carve slice and baton without a problem, it’s easy to sharpen and will take a scary edge. Then after you get out and use it you’ll know more about what you’re looking for.
dE5guQT.jpg
 
8 years ago I was on the same quest. I was looking for the best “bushcraft” knife and found this forum to be the most beneficial resource. That and YouTube. You can find SO much information between the two that your head will spin.

I found Becker to be what I was looking for, but it’s all personal taste. I like the high carbon blades at a relatively low cost, great warranty, good quality and the designer is a great guy and participates on his subforum. You can’t go wrong with that company and many different options to chose from.

You can go more of a traditional look and feel too! LT Wright makes a helluva knife.

My suggestion as stated above would be to hold off on spending the big bucks until you have done the research into the steels, handle material, sheath material, the different blade profiles, and grind options. So much to choose.

I recently bought a Blindhorse Boat Tail Scandi. So nice and comfy, but the search continues....
 
I agree with B BitingSarcasm a Becker BK-16 would be a perfect knife to start with. That Becker will carve slice and baton without a problem, it’s easy to sharpen and will take a scary edge. Then after you get out and use it you’ll know more about what you’re looking for.
dE5guQT.jpg
Great suggestion. I've got the 15 with tkc scales. The tweeners are excellent value.
 
Of those you listed LT Wright stands out ... great quality several different models and options ... the bushcrfter is a nice knife the GNS slightly bigger but another great knife for hiking/camping ... you can find the GNS in carbon steel or AEB-L stainless which is one of my favorites.

As some mentioned Becker BK16 is less expensive but another great quailty knife ... it is a carbon coated blade but tough and with minor care will give you years of use.

Mora does offer a very inexpensive option and they are nice knives but not as robust as others ... they can be had in stainless or carbon blades for about the same price.
 
How much money are you willing to spend on a knife you will hate.
Instead of jumping into the high end, I would recommend a few knives at the lower end so that you can find out what actually works for what you want. A Scandi grind is great for a lot of things, and and Full flat is great for all the others. A knife that doesn't fit within you weight budget and uses isn't going to get much carry time. If you are only in areas where bushcraft is limited to whittling a few twigs, then a big heavy chopper is pointless. If all you are chopping is light brush, then a 14-18 inch Tram machete will be way more fun and easy to use than a 300$ short chopper. See what I mean?

So presume you are going to learn by doing, and the cost of knives is your tuition. Spending all you money on one knife will only teach you that you can convince your self any choice was great because you spent the money. Cruise the sale forums, buy use, buy beaters, put up wanted listings.
 
My suggestion is to get a Mora Companion. It’s an excellent bushcrafting knife, but more importantly you can drop $15 on the knife, and use it to learn what you want/need.

Use it in the kitchen. Use it backpacking, car camping, fire pit in the back yard, construction projects, etc... use the hell out of it. With each use, you’ll learn what you like and don’t like. Let that knife teach you. It will teach you more than we can. You don’t really learn by reading about using knives. You learn by using them.

.

Nothing to add except this seems like great advice and is exactly what I've been thinking about doing. Thanks for validating the Mora as a first bushcraft knife.
 
If you want to stick to that budget, buy several. What I like and what you like are 2 different things.

What I will caution, based on your list, is blade thickness and weight. Weight for backpacking and thickness because it hinders cutting, generally speaking.

What knives have you used? What did you like about them? Think about that in the kitchen too. Does a chef's knife feel unwieldy? Do you prefer a small pairing knife or something in between?

Even though you used bushcraft and camping in the description, what do you plan to use it for? Will it really see a lot of wood processing?

Here's what I like as a "do it all" type of knife:
  • 4-6" blade, 4 for ease of carry, 6" for ease of knee lever grip if I'm processing a lot of wood (I have big legs), many of my knives are 4.25-5" for this type of use.
  • A handle at least 4" long and mostly round with light contouring. Handle shape is as important as the blade for bushcraft because you'll use it a lot.
  • Balance of the knife to be in the hand, not blade heavy but not excessively nimble like a fighting knife
  • Blade point nearly inline with the center of the knife. If processing game is called for then a higher tip is fine.
  • It comes with a nice sheath or it's cheap enough that getting a sheath made is affordable.
From your list, here's how I respond to each
-Benchmade 162 Bushcraft - Don't know, it's interested me but I've not tried this one. I think you could get something similar for less money but this is supposed to be nice

-Esee 5P NO, too heavy and thick Go esee 4 or 6 instead. Or the PR4, even better

-Tops BOB in CPM154 - maybe, I've heard the grind is thick on these but I've never used one

-Bark River Aurora CPM 3V - no too expensive if you don't know what you want. Nice knife but you're likely to end up trying a few.

-Bark River Trakker Companion - no, see above for other bark river

-Buck 863 Selkirk - I've not tried this but it could be decent. I don't care for the looks of the sheath.

-SOG Pillar - I avoid SOG's because I think they're over-priced for what you get, there are too many other good options

-Ontario Knife Company SK-5 Blackbird - YES

-LT Wright Bushcrafter - No/yes, I love LT wright knives but they are a little pricey if it doesn't work out for you. I have 3 of them, bushbaby (3"), genesis (4.25"), and bushcrafter Mark II (5") and really like them all. The bushcrafter HC would be a good option

-Cold Steel 3V Master Hunter - I think this has a lot of potential but not one I've looked at in a while. I would probably get the lower priced one though

-Gerber LMFII - no, only comes in combo edge, that i've seen. Serrations suck on wood compared to plain edge

-Bradford Guardian 5 - I've read the longer guardians aren't comfortable in hand but I've not tried one myself and I don't know anyone who has. I know the smaller guardians are very nice.

-Swamp Rat - Swamp rat is a brand, not a knife, but I'll assume you're talking about the ratmandu since that's a bit of the poster child. It's an amazing knife and a favorite of mine for it's size but it's expensive and won't come with a sheath so you'll need to account for that. I don't own one anymore because of the LT Wright bushcrafter mark II, if that says anything. Both are amazingly capable and comfortable in hand.


If i had to pick one, and you really wanted stainless, I would go ontario blackbird. The Kephart design it is modeled after is time proven, very nice, and the blade isn't excessively priced. I feel this is one that will get a lot done and last for a long time.

If you want to stay on the cheap side and plan to do a lot of woodcrafting, get a stainless mora companion. It's worth having one anyway just to try. Great knife, outstanding for the price. I don't personally like the scandi grind for anything except wood processing but it will still cut fine. It's super light so it will treat you well as a lightweight hiking knife too.

Side note: If you happen to be located in SE Michigan, let's meet up and I'll show you what I have and we can cut some wood and see what you like. The best way to know what's best is to try some stuff. Unfortunately, stores aren't going to let you do that but some of the forum members here will. Additionally, enjoy this time as it's awesome trying out new things and finding what you like and don't like if you tend to be a gear junkie.

lTMKBAPl.jpg

LreLGYcl.jpg

31sjjLIl.jpg


I do more wood processing and woodcrafting than hiking and camping these days but I do give my tools a workout regularly still.
WWeZSBfl.jpg
 
Last edited:
Dude... you've been a member of this Fantastic forum since Sunday. There is a plethora of information available at your fingertips. I was a member here for months before I asked a question.
Look...and you shall find.
https://www.bladeforums.com/threads/choosing-my-first-bushcraft-camping-hiking-knife.1631196/
There is a TON of information available. And...if you find you like it here and the free information you glean, consider being a paid member.
Welcome aboard.

Got to love the guys trying to tell you youre not allowed to post, because I’ve been a member for a couple of days? That’s the reason I am posting, is to get peoples knowledge and help.

I realize the blades are all over the map, it that’s precisely why I posted, so people can share their knowledge of the knives. Help me learn and be inviting, share the knowledge. Don’t be like the guys in my AR and Glock group
 
Back
Top