Circles in steel after HT

T

TRAVIS R HENNINGER

Joined
Jul 23, 2017
Messages
38
Can someone tell me what causes these circles in the steel after HT. I am using a homemade forge burning lump charcoal.

The steel is 5160 from Jantz.
FPBdzRf.jpg
 
From scale building up on the surface when you heat treated. this is why we remove all the decarb layer after heat treat.
 
It's not a good or bad thing, it's a surface condition. Normalising is most likely what did it. Extended exposure to heat creates lots of scale and some times it forums in little round blister shapes. There is also a layer on the surface called decarb that has had the carbon burned out of it. This is why we normally grind or sand after heat treat. If you don't have a grinder then use a corse grit paper and start sanding till all the scale scaring and decarb is gone then move up in grit and finish the blade. But like I said as long as the heat treat was done right and everything is spot on then it's just a finish issue and not a structural problem.
 
Thanks for the help. The heat treat went well, and the portable hardness tester I am using is showing around 57 Rockwell. Should be ok.

I am hand sanding now.
 
Just remember to get an accurate hardness reading you have to remove the decarb becaus it is much softer the the hardened steel.
 
As a side question, if the OP doesn't mind me jumping in here, how do I know when I am completely through the decarb layer?
 
If it's a simple carbon steel you can just give it a dunk in some ferric chloride. Steel with real low carbon content will etch much lighter color then the hardened steel.
 
I had that happened early on with some O1. It looked like beach sand when i broke it. I am voting for overheating.
 
+1^
That's why I said "if" the heat treat was done correctly.
 
Just finished it. Plan on abusing it tomorrow to see if it holds up. We will see. I am still figuring it all out. This is knife #4 i am not to worried about the mirror finish yet, until I get the basics down.
ii2rGYn.jpg
 
I do. It is not a great picture. The bevel near the tip needs corrected. I will work on that tomorrow. I made a jig to help hold my angles. I am not real good at it yet. But I will keep practicing.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top