1. Washington action alert - Spring blade knife ban repeal thread. Hearing is Tues, Vote is Friday, let your voice be heard!

CS vs SS

Discussion in 'Traditional Folders and Fixed Blades' started by Jim Hataway, Jan 1, 2020.

  1. aji1

    aji1 Gold Member Gold Member

    114
    Dec 19, 2016
    It is if you don't like patina...
    Exactly. If your preference is stainless, buy stainless. If it's carbon, buy carbon. If you like both, get both. Who cares what anyone else says (an exception being Bill Howard; I would like it if he said, "More stainless!")?

    I like stainless personally. Here are some of my favorites. The 2018 Buck forum 301 (CPM154), a Moki Kronos (VG10), a Camilus/Santa Fe Stoneworks (unknown, but definitely stainless), an A.G. Russell Pinched Peanut (VG10), a Canal Street Co-op (154CM) and a Fontenille-Pataud Laguiole XS (14C28N). All great knives with good steels. Apologies for the poor photo, but the thread needed one!

    stainless_trads.jpg
     
  2. Jsega51

    Jsega51 Gold Member Gold Member

    Feb 11, 2015
    I like to buy knives that have stainless steel forged over carbon:

    [​IMG]
    [​IMG]
     
    jmh33, gaj999, Pinemoon and 2 others like this.
  3. TheChunk91

    TheChunk91 Gold Member Gold Member

    Aug 15, 2013
    Stainless is very convenient in the summer heat and humidity but I use carbon most of the time. I really don't care about specific steel types anymore, it all cuts with proper geometry and all of them eventually need sharpening.
     
    jmh33, Jsega51 and JohnDF like this.
  4. tongueriver

    tongueriver Gold Member Gold Member

    Dec 28, 2007
    In my opinion you just 'cut' through you-know-what.
     
    jmh33 and TheChunk91 like this.
  5. Pinemoon

    Pinemoon Gold Member Gold Member

    Mar 25, 2005
    Wow, nice stuff :thumbsup:
     
    Jsega51 likes this.
  6. Frailer

    Frailer Gold Member Gold Member

    823
    Oct 25, 2009
    My thoughts exactly. On the list of factors I consider before buying a knife “steel type” isn’t in the top 10.
     
    jmh33 and TheChunk91 like this.
  7. DrHenley

    DrHenley

    269
    May 31, 2019
    AEB-L is a good stainless steel for people who like carbon steel. It has similar toughness and sharpenability and takes a smooth keen edge unlike the SS's with large carbides.

    So where does D2 fit into this discussion? LOL
     
    gaj999 likes this.
  8. Lansky1

    Lansky1

    310
    Apr 12, 2016
    Boy, I'll second that !! Those allen head screws are the first thing I notice ... just don't like the concept.
     
    JohnDF likes this.
  9. Jim Hataway

    Jim Hataway

    19
    Jun 19, 2016
    Re my original post. Should have stated that my SS preference was for folders, and more specifically EDC folders. My current favorites are the peanut, swayback gent, and mini copperhead. I have larger folders, but they don't get EDC. For fixed blade knives, I know very little. But I can appreciate the need for a robust steel to withstand tougher uses. All of myDad's folders were CS, and they worked fine. but SS wasn't an option back then. I have no beef with CS. Just a preference for SS in EDC folders. Cheers, and please don't ban me!
     
  10. hornetguy

    hornetguy Gold Member Gold Member

    850
    Feb 11, 2015
    You don't get banned for preferring SS...... SHUNNED, maybe, but not banned....:D
     
    peanutsxx, JohnDF and gaj999 like this.
  11. gaj999

    gaj999 Basic Member Basic Member

    Jan 25, 2004
    Another personal preference. I like them. And screwed together construction is definitely traditional, it's only the shape of the driver that's the issue ...
     
  12. Hickory n steel

    Hickory n steel Gold Member Gold Member Basic Member

    Feb 11, 2016
    What's not to like , a knife you use looking used ?

    Stainless is fine by me, just not my favorite.
     
  13. specgrade

    specgrade Gold Member Gold Member

    442
    Nov 21, 2009
    My knives have blades that cut....I'm sorry, what was the question? ;):cool::D
     
    jmh33 and Mayonardo like this.
  14. sailfish

    sailfish

    307
    Jan 1, 2019
    I probably don't really have a preference. If I like a knife and get it, I'll makes excuses for the advantages of whatever steel it happens to have. If it's carbon, it will patina and develop it's own personal character similar to my other non-knife tools. If it's stainless, I won't have to worry about rust and it will always have that mirror-like blade.
     
    Pinemoon likes this.
  15. Ace Rimmer

    Ace Rimmer

    Jul 4, 2017
    I like and use them both. I have a few examples of identical knife patterns in both Case CV and Case SS (two muskrats and several swaybacks) and I find that I'm able to get them equally sharp to the point where they will easily pop off individual arm hairs. (That's sharp enough for me.) I'm not a heavy enough user that I can comment on durability or which one will hold an edge longer. I do like the "romance" of CV (The "traditional knife with traditional steel" kind of thing) and a like a nice patina making a newer knife look older and well used.

    Here's an interesting series of videos that compare two Case tribal locks, one SS and one CV. It's long and detailed, with over 45 minutes of video. (skip to the last one for the 4.5 minute summary):



     
    Last edited: Jan 3, 2020
    JohnDF and Headwinds like this.

Share This Page