Experiences with chiropractors?

David Mary

pass the mustard - after you cut it
Moderator
Knifemaker / Craftsman / Service Provider
Joined
Jul 23, 2015
Messages
16,113
When I was young, I read a book by Kevin Trudeau called "Natural Cures They Don't Want You to Know About" and one thing he suggested that wasn't laughable to me was go visit a chiropractor, even if you don't think you need one.

Well, I had an active lifestyle, and was pretty fit so I was convinced that it couldn't hurt, and benefits at work (this was over ten years ago now) covered a portion, so why not? I had an active life style, what did I have to lose.

I tried one chiropractor I met through martial arts only to be given the hard and fast sell by his colleague and him nowhere in sight. And with no education other than, and I paraphrase "you seriously need this, and we presuppose you're in it for the long haul, and oh here is the price going forward, and by the way, you though you were getting a free assessment, but we're disabusing you of that notion now with this hefty bill for telling you nothing other than 'trust us, you need us'". Needless to say I left with no delay nor a penny less.

I was up front with the next one, who came recommended by another friend. I told him about that experience, and he assured me (as had my friend, whom I told first) he had nothing of the sort in mind, and walked me through his process. It sounded logical and comprehensive with consideration of the patient's right to understand (to a point). Here is where I learned of scoliosis affecting my posture, and even though I hadn't felt the need, nor debilitated in any way, in light of my reading of the aforesaid book, I saw him for at least a year. And after a period of time away, I returned another few months.

I always felt good after. I just treated the whole thing as another part of the physical culture lifestyle, because the adjustment itself was very much the least time of the whole thing. There were appropriate warmups beforehand while every one waited together. And then afterwards he prescribed exercises for 10-15 minutes immediately following the adjustment once my turn came up. These often included a head weight and perhaps a belt I recall. Essentially, he was helping me strengthen and reinforce the muscles and posture that should go with the new alignment of my spine. One thing I really miss is the wobble chair, and neck traction.

I once told one of the chiropractor's aids one time that I could crack my own back, and was told not to. The aid said it's bad and dangerous, and it sounded like scare tactics more than a legitimately concerned warning. Because the thing is, those adjustments loosened things enough, and the exercises and "homework" he prescribed along with muscle memory have left me able to do it on my own, on the fly, whenever I start to feel out of alignment. But I can really make a creaky sound. And with my knees, too. But it's been this way since I can remember. Maybe part of scoliosis? It never occurred to me when I was young that might be why I was fidgeting and cracking knuckles. I wouldn't have even heard of it.

In fact it was the chiropractor who told me not to crack my knuckles. I said, "why ever not, surely it's a wives tail that it will give you arthritis?", and he said because it compresses the knuckles. He said any joint is at greater risk if it is exposed to greater compression. So I asked him "what about this?" and I pulled one of my fingers producing a satisfying crack, and alleviating some pressure I felt in my hand. He said he had no problem with the idea of decompressing a joint, as long as it was not pulled out of joint.

Anyway, I once told someone about the adjustments, and he proposed to me that I had damaged my body, and it would come back to haunt me. He said that chiropractors separate joints that are supposed to be fused, but I don't think so. My sacral spine is fused as it should be, but now I can crack my back if it feels too compressed or out of alignment. It feels like I'm decompressing them and it can provide relief especially after too long in one position. But then I usually have to fine tune something else, like pulling on a couple fingers, cracking my jaw, or stretching my leg until I get the right pop in my knee. I provisionally attribute this floating anomaly to the scoliosis, which makes, full and perfect postural alignment an impossibility for me. When I am sufficiently warmed up I don't feel it because everything fits better and more easily until I cool down again.

So, cricketty creakitty crackitty, that's the sound of my posterior chain.

Et vous?
 
Some chiropractors are excellent, some are quacks. Your odds are improved if you can find one who is board certified by the American Academy of Chiropractic Orthopedists, the American College of Chiropractic Orthopedics, and the Academy of Neuromusculoskeletal Medicine.
 
There are over a dozen types of chiropractor. Many, indeed, are quacks and frauds, others are miracle workers.

One chiropractor I went to insisted on Xrays, then used a "clicker" to move the vertabrae a fraction of an inch... that was the whole "adjustment" and I felt ripped off and never went back.

The chiropractor I saw back in NY would put you on a roller table with electrostim pads on the affected muscles, then use an industrial strength vibration wand to loosen everything up before cracking every joint in your back. Went to that guy for years.

He warned me that the main danger of self adjustments is if you do it too frequently the result could be "hyperflexibility" which weakens the joints making them more prone to injury.
 
IMO? Relax, stretch, us a foam roller and you're getting about 90% of the benefit you'll get from any kind of manipulation therapy.

On the other hand, if you feel like it really helps you I strongly recommend seeking out a DO that practices osteopathic manipulation therapy rather than a chiropractor. One of the big advantages is that they're full medical doctors, so if they think an issue is better served with other medical interventions they're capable of doing that. I think part of the issue with Chiropractors is that when all you have is a hammer, everything looks a lot like a nail.
 
Over 45 years as a dealership auto mechanic working flat rate I beat my body up pretty hard. After 15 years of lifting engines and transmissions I began having back problems. Relaxing and flexing my body in a certain way worked for a few years and then I finally went to the MD who suggested I might need surgery to my spine. A friend recommended I try a chiro and after two visits my back was back to normal but the guy wanted me to come twice a week forever and I never went back. Several years later I messed my back up again and went to a different chiro. This guy had electrodes and a funny table and I left after one quackish treatment and suffered for two weeks unti it healed back up. Then I was dating a cute woman and my back went out at work again and she berated me for enduring the pain and refusing treatment. It turned out her father, her brother, and one of her sister's boyfriends were all chiropracters. I was miserable on her birthday and we went to her father's place where they all told me to relax and let her brother give me an adjustment. FIVE MINUTES later the pain was halved. I went to his office two days later for another adjustment and was back to norma soon after. He also wanted me to get regular adjustments but I declined. As I have aged (70s) sometimes my back goes out just mopping or working on my car and I go to the guy to this day when in pain and one or two adjustments sets me straight for another couple years. Get the right chiro for you if you suffer back pain and he may just help you greatly.
 
Couple questions...?

Have you ever tried yoga?

it's like everything else, some instructors are amazing, some not so much....

I agree about using hard foam rollers, and I have an inversion table when things get really bad. :)

I too am curious about seeing a chiropractor and I'd be up for acupuncture.
 
I went once. I had sprain where a floating rib connected. They insisted that if they straightened my spine it would fix my rib ( as well as the arthritis in my joints) after about three sessions where he only wanted to manipulate the spine and not address my rib pain I said no more and went to my orthopedist. He fixed my up in short order.
I just don't have much faith in a chiropractor; it seems like no matter what your ailment is, a mis-aligned spine is cxausing it.
 
I think they are a pain in the neck!😆

Just kidding. I have had really good luck with my guy. After falling down a flight of stairs and breaking a few bones I was very lopsided after healing. He got my back right fairly quickly and relatively painlessly.
 
Couple questions...?

Have you ever tried yoga?

it's like everything else, some instructors are amazing, some not so much....

I agree about using hard foam rollers, and I have an inversion table when things get really bad. :)

I too am curious about seeing a chiropractor and I'd be up for acupuncture.

I tried Rodney Yee's "AM yoga for your week" a few years ago. I have avoided the really "hardcore" yoga that gets all into their spiritual stuff, since I don't subscribe to it. But many of the movements, poses and holds did feel good. I have continued to practice some of them to this day, as well stretches and stances I learned as a teenager in karate, and they feel all great.

I just don't have much faith in a chiropractor; it seems like no matter what your ailment is, a mis-aligned spine is cxausing it.

As I understand, the spine is the CNS superhighway, so it seems to make sense to me that if it is misaligned, all sorts of things could be out of whack as a result. That being said, I also recognize the vested interest a chiropractor might have in saying that is the issue when it's not.

I think they are a pain in the neck!😆

🤣
 
My personal opinion is that the proof of the best approach is in how much follow-up care you’ll need.

Chiropractors make their living on repeat customers, so they tell you that you’ll need to keep coming back.

Medical Doctors ethically do not want you to come back if you don’t need to.

I have seen it with friends and family.. they go once, the chiropractor does their “assessment”, they get their bones cracked and feel good for a few hours, and they’re going back the rest of their lives. I see these video clips on the internet of people getting their bones cracked and they act like it’s the coolest thing since sliced bread.. but all it is is air releasing from between the joints. I also know there are a lot of green science types that act like bone cracking cures cancer. I’m not joking.

So in summary, a good medical doctor, a good physical therapist, a good exercise plan, and a good diet will take care of all the things a chiropractor promises to be able to do… and when they’re done with you, they won’t need you to keep coming back to stay in business.
 
I go, I enjoy it, it works for me. That said, I understand it’s not everybody’s cup of tea. My wife hates it.

By virtue of my profession, I wear gear all day which forces me to sit in unnatural positions (particularly in a vehicle) and adds additional weight where there probably shouldn’t be, therefore back/neck/shoulder issues are inevitable. I’ve been to chiropractors before who want you to come back every week, you know, because science, but that’s unreasonable. I like my current chiropractor’s office as it’s come whenever YOU feel you need to, no pressure. They put me on a TENS machine for awhile then get to work. I always feel significantly better afterward. I may have to come back in three months, six months, but my last stretch was almost a year.
 
Man salads are awesome. Everything about them is great. Loads of greens with olive oil and humus and salmon, you have to be crazy not to feel fantastic after one of these and they taste delicious! In fact imma grab me a late night salad right now.
 
I put bacon in it too. Om nom nom
 
Been to poor ones. Been to a couple of great ones.
The last doc I went to turned me from a hobbling old man with knee and back issues to being able to move right sprightly with no sore back and no knee problems.
 
I never believed in them in the past. had a sciatica nerve problem. leg just hurt couldn't sit in a car ride without massive pain and discomfort. hurt laying down. hurt standing up. just awful pain. sometimes so.bad I felt being dead would be better. foot went numb on the outer half and half my toes permanently. made it hard to walk and very uncomfortable.

I toughed it out for years eating bottles of Tylenol and advil daily trying to suffer through it. stomach was hurting from the Tylenol and advil. finally wife made me go to doctors. they sent me to nerve and chiropractor specialists who took xrays and cat scan, etc. had no solutions. tried to put me on opiate pain killers which I declined. finally one of the nerve specialists told me to try a chiropractor.


I finally was suffering so badly I said what the hell. went to a back cracker one.. found it hurt my back and didn't help at all. tried a few different ones. finally fell into one who was more of a stretching and pushed in spots while he stretched and pushed limb in awkward directions type. think he said it was A.R.T. or something like that. also a back cracker, but told him that wasnt working on me. he also sold lots of hocky crap and nonsense stuff at top dollar. which i refused to pay for.

at first little relief and would creep back to suffering. after many, so many 2 a week I lost count over a year i think it was sessions, got feeling in my toes and foot and could lay, sit and stand without massive pain. eventually pain and numbness went away.

I'm a believer now since it worked for my issue. I dont go anymore as I dont need to and he tried to keep me coming in, but once I felt better I stopped. been lucky or fixed or whatever for years now. knock on wood.
 
Yeah,that last Doc I went to was all about stretching and pulling, not much into cracking. He taught me stretching exercises, which I spend about 30 minutes doing every morning. Makes a world of difference.
 
I've gone to three chiros in my lifetime. They all made me feel better. Two were total money grubbers, one much less.
They will take lots of X-rays initially and get you hooked into a lifetime of scheduled appointments. I won't say that they are
useless or outright quacks. But I wouldn't go unless (1) you have a specific problem you want fixed, and (2) your insurance covers it.
 
Back
Top