Harpoon

[FrozenTurtle]

Does it seem like there are more Harpoon style knives? Like some of the Tops or Spartan blades. Does the hook like thing really do anything for the blade? I heard someone say they hate using their Hinderer Harpoon.

 

[corwise]

I would agree they're popping up more. I don't think it changes the ergonomics of using the blade though, more cosmetic than anything else. I'm sure there are some uses that it might interfere but as an EDC (a Hinderer for example) I can't imagine how it would get in the way.

 

[mbkryan]

I think it looks cool. And, on this Mini it works nicely as a thumb/finger ramp if I am needing to apply controlled pressure to the tip or front of the blade. I actually find myself using it a lot. The top of the blade is pretty flat and comfortable for this sort of use, and the knife is only 6in. long so it feels very natural to choke up on the blade.

 

[Wolverine666]

I like how the harpoon blades look. Reminds me of a shark head. My Umnumzaan has one and it looks great.

 

[sharp_edge]

Harpoon blade shape looks great. I am thinking about getting on knife in that grind from Spartan, Hinderer, or Reate.

 

[evilgreg]

Does it seem like there are more Harpoon style knives? Like some of the Tops or Spartan blades. Does the hook like thing really do anything for the blade? I heard someone say they hate using their Hinderer Harpoon.

Cosmetic, the spine doesn't get used a ton beyond having a spot for your thumb sometimes and whacking the odd firesteel on a camp knife.

I like them because it lets me say 'poon a lot, and that makes me happy.

 

[katanas]

evilgreg, Would you be even happier if the poon was on the tang?

 

[Wolf7]

Another modern stupid fad designed for looks only, rather than function like ex: compound grinds, giant finger choils, chisel grinds, or multiple speed holes!
When I go through my check list of options that knife must have, I stop immediately and won't buy knife if it has one of these stupid fads on it.

Harpoon style blades belong ONLY on fishing harpoons, so they stay stuck in target without coming out.
Last thing you want is having your folder getting stuck in material you are stabbing!

In fact great functional blade shape should either be straight line on top spine like on drop point or clean smooth curve on spear point!
No bumps, humps or harpoons allowed!

 

[katanas]

Wolf7, many of my knives have been purchased for looks (they do, of course, also cut). One can have a rather limited supply of "functional only" knives. I'm at 400+ with no plans to stop, so something different in steel or looks or many other variables, is appealing. Some foods are not as nourishing as others, but have other appeal. Vive le difference. To each his own.

 

[FrozenTurtle]

I think it looks cool. And, on this Mini it works nicely as a thumb/finger ramp if I am needing to apply controlled pressure to the tip or front of the blade. I actually find myself using it a lot. The top of the blade is pretty flat and comfortable for this sort of use, and the knife is only 6in. long so it feels very natural to choke up on the blade.

Which knife is it?

 

[FrozenTurtle]

Another modern stupid fad designed for looks only, rather than function like ex: compound grinds, giant finger choils, chisel grinds, or multiple speed holes!
When I go through my check list of options that knife must have, I stop immediately and won't buy knife if it has one of these stupid fads on it.

Harpoon style blades belong ONLY on fishing harpoons, so they stay stuck in target without coming out.
Last thing you want is having your folder getting stuck in material you are stabbing!

In fact great functional blade shape should either be straight line on top spine like on drop point or clean smooth curve on spear point!
No bumps, humps or harpoons allowed!

I always wondered if the bumb would get caught on something.

 

[FrozenTurtle]

Another modern stupid fad designed for looks only, rather than function like ex: compound grinds, giant finger choils, chisel grinds, or multiple speed holes!
When I go through my check list of options that knife must have, I stop immediately and won't buy knife if it has one of these stupid fads on it.

Harpoon style blades belong ONLY on fishing harpoons, so they stay stuck in target without coming out.
Last thing you want is having your folder getting stuck in material you are stabbing!

In fact great functional blade shape should either be straight line on top spine like on drop point or clean smooth curve on spear point!
No bumps, humps or harpoons allowed!

What about a clip point?

 

[evilgreg]

evilgreg, Would you be even happier if the poon was on the tang?

Yes indeed!

 

[Wolverine666]

Another modern stupid fad designed for looks only, rather than function like ex: compound grinds, giant finger choils, chisel grinds, or multiple speed holes!
When I go through my check list of options that knife must have, I stop immediately and won't buy knife if it has one of these stupid fads on it.

Harpoon style blades belong ONLY on fishing harpoons, so they stay stuck in target without coming out.
Last thing you want is having your folder getting stuck in material you are stabbing!

In fact great functional blade shape should either be straight line on top spine like on drop point or clean smooth curve on spear point!
No bumps, humps or harpoons allowed!

Guess what , Adolf ...harpoon style blades look sick on folders. So if you're having that much trouble pulling your knife out of something you shanked then might I recommend working in your upper body strength a bit. But to each their own , little buddy

 

[mbkryan]

It is the S1 Mini by Michael Zieba. If you are unfamiliar with him, you should look him up. I have heard he works alone and makes his blades/handles/clips/back spacers by hand without CNC or other computerized machines. I like his stuff a lot and it is priced at the low end for customs.

Which knife is it?

 

[FrozenTurtle]

It is the S1 Mini by Michael Zieba. If you are unfamiliar with him, you should look him up. I have heard he works alone and makes his blades/handles/clips/back spacers by hand without CNC or other computerized machines. I like his stuff a lot and it is priced at the low end for customs.

I like the oyster shucker alot.

 

[DocJD]

evilgreg, Would you be even happier if the poon was on the tang?

Harpy poontang ? That's just nasty !

 

[wensynch]

I think the harpoon shape is a reference to the blade shape rather than utlity in that it's not designed to actually hook a target like a harpoon; it just looks like a harpoon.

There is an practical utility to the design and it's to extend and isolate the thumb "ramp" to allow your thumb to move with weight through the cutting motion.

Cutting is as much form in action and synergy with the tool. Ya know, the force.

I think it looks cool. And, on this Mini it works nicely as a thumb/finger ramp if I am needing to apply controlled pressure to the tip or front of the blade. I actually find myself using it a lot. The top of the blade is pretty flat and comfortable for this sort of use, and the knife is only 6in. long so it feels very natural to choke up on the blade.

 

[mbkryan]

I like the oyster shucker alot.

Yea, I like that. Don't think i would ever spend the $$ for one of his cooking knives, but they are the coolest cooking knives I have ever seen. I just got the regular S1 with M390 to go with my mini. Both knives are really well made, especially for a new guy that does everything by hand.

 

[mbkryan]

Here is the big one with the little one. Haven't used the big one yet, but I don't thin the harpoon will be a problem. I do like the look of the Zieba Bold better, which is basically the same blade but without the harpoon. That is next on the list.