Hi,I'm looking for a pair of high quality gloves. I've done some research, but would like some more opinions from you guys.
SO far my top choices are (Line of fire,Outdoor Research,Masley,Wiley X,Arcteryx)
Criteria: From most important to least important
1)Quality and Fit Finish= Double stitching, tape seam, no fraying, long lasting materials.
2)Comfort and Dexterity= Good fit and ability to move fingers easily.
3)Protection= From fire and cuts, puncture, and abrasion resistance.
4)Grip and Padding= Strong gripping surface and rubber padding in the right places without losing mobility.
5)Breathable and water resistance= a good balance of water resistance, but still allow it to be cool.
the only gloves on your list i have experience with are the "wiley x" ones and they SUCK!!! they cost to much even if you get them at the px.
i went through 4 pair of gloves my last trip over seas, the wileys were the worst gloves i ever had.
I spent a lot of time resewing the seems and putting them back together.
i saved the emails i sent to wiley x because i couldn't believe the crap customer service they had.
i tried out a few over there, i took a pair of the mechanix, hatch hard knuckle, Damascus hard knuckle, and blue force gear hard knuckle.
none of them are perfect, the best were-
hatch,(wore them everyday at least 10 hrs a day, for 3 months) ran about 40. -45.00, good fit, padding, QC, good grip, finger movement,(staying cool when its 120 in the shade isn't going to happen)
Damascus were great too,(wore them for 3 months, 10 hrs a day) they ran me about 45. -50.00, good fit, padding, QC, grip, was great, lot more dexterity than the hatch but didn't last as long, its a trade off.
the mechanix( didn't last 3 months, got about 1.5 out of them) were nice but not as much protection and didn't last as long either, but the price is cheap so you can take more than a few pair.
blue force were alright,(wore them for 3 months,10 hrs a day) the grip seemed slick and the seems weren't sewn as well as the others, but not bad overall.
when my glove try out ended i still had some time left i went back to the hatch gloves.
the hard knuckle gloves aren't for punching or hitting,(this is a misconception held by people that haven't had the need to actually use them) its to protect your knuckles when moving around obstacles with a weapon(pistol, or carbine) that will shred the backs of your hands.
my advice, go somewhere you can try them on, no matter what you get, then when you know your size buy them online. don't get them to tight, they will shrink up abit, then get them wet and wear them dry. get more than one pair, they will wear out. and if you plan on shooting in them, wear them when you practice, especially pistol work, but once you get used to them they are a necessary piece of kit, they do serve a purpose.