Leatherman Wingman: Recommended!

Joined
May 3, 2006
Messages
3,092
I just got one of these at Home Depot. I have to disagree with powernoodle's previous post. To address his criticisms: I find the rolled stamped handle construction reminds me of my Vic Spirit. It's true that the scissor spring will not work unless they are fully extended so that the lock engages. This doesn't seem to be a problem. The thumb pad on the scissors are about the same thickness as large Victorinox scissors, and thicker than full size Wenger scissors. They seem plenty good, nicer than the scissors on the Vic Spirit, and the Leatherman Wave, not as nice as the scissors on the Leatherman Juice XE6. They don't have a nail nick as such, but the spring seems to function just as well, and they deploy easily.

Upsides: The individual implements seem about as good as any. Scissors are decent size and look more robust than those on the Wave. Knife blade is nicely ground combo edge. Blade is accessible without opening the tool. Price is crazy low for what you get.

Downsides as I see them. Implements other than blade and scissors don't lock and each implement on either side shares a common backspring. This means they clump. Nothing new here, as this is a trait that goes back to the original PST, but no improvement either. The knife blade has a hole for one hand opening. However, it's small and heavily buffed such that it's a bit difficult for the thumb to get purchase. The blade could be a quarter inch longer with no interference. A couple of the implements are odd to me. The file is nice and toothy, single cut. But it's short, and the backside features a tiny rule with inch and cm gradiations. These aren't really bad things, but seem of limited usefulness. And the package opener is a novel, single use hook-like blade, presumably intended to open clamshell like packages. Does what it's supposed to (I used it on the leftover packaging as a test), but feels like it's there due to lack of ideas or something.

The intertesting: Action is smooth, and the sprung plier head is a very nice advance that somehow seems to have migrated up from cheap imported multitools. Hopefully the Wingman won't be prone to rusting like the bead blasted models. Comes with a removable pocket clip! Another unusual touch: the wire cutters are not bypass type cutters found on every other Leatherman. Instead, they are diagonal cutters. They seem to work fine on wire coat hangers. I'd be curious to see how durable they are in the long run, especially with the internal spring cavity, versus their traditional plier head. Also, the cutters have what appear to be hard wire cutter notch. This is not specified in the instructions, and I'm not sure it would be necessary with the diagonal cutter design anyway. I suspect it's a stress relief. I'm in awe at what can be had for the price here. This is not a simple PST type tool. Typically Leatherman, they went with something completely different and new, that seems to recycle few if any parts and ideas from previous lines, with a keen eye on cost cutting. Bravo.

The bottom line: looks like a winner for the low end multitool market.
 
If by precise, you mean smaller bladed, smaller jawed, and harder to sharpen, then yes. I always thought the scissors were the weak link on the Spirit, more like thread nippers. On the whole, the Spirit is a nicer tool. But it's almost three times the price. It damn well better be nicer!
 
I don't post much (at all really), but I'm glad someone is sticking up for the Leatherman Wingman.

I'll admit that the marketing is hokey, and the construction is below the level of my Supertool 300 or my Wave. Coming from a background of using those tool nearly everyday I admit that the wire cutters are underwhelming. The scissors really force you to open the implement fully before normal functioning use, and the markings are stamped not engraved (the ruler for example.) but these are minor issues. I think it is a great tool overall, provided that you remember the maxim, you get what you pay for.

I got mine at about $25 some retailers have it at $35 which for us knife knuts is bargain. How many of us think twice about that $100+ price tag on that new Spyderco or Benchmade? I for one am really just excited about getting a new blade at that point. My argument is that it is unfair to compare the Wingman to those higher quality multitools. This was designed for the causal consumer who is put off by the price point of a Supertool, not us. We have discerning taste, and wallets that are used to the strain. If we are to give an accurate review, we need to differentiate between the people who buy this as part of a collection (us) and those who will buy this as their only multitool or *gasp* their only pocket knife!

That being said, I actually recommend it for both groups. Its not designed for hard (combat) use but will work in a pinch if one does not have immediate access to their tool box. For the average consumer this is practically a steal. Commonly used tools in a nice discreet package for life's daily inconveniences. Collectors and knife enthusiasts should buy this to show a demand for this type of budget multitool. Honestly, we have all seen the flea market chinese junk. We will all be better off with companies like leathermen providing options instead of enforcing a terrible dichotomy of 5 buck junk and $80 dollar quality tool. I would like to tell my non-knut friends that there is a quality multitool that doesn't require budgeting in advance for to purchase.
 
I picked one up at HD today just to see for myself. For the $25 price, I have no complaints.

Jeff
 
If by precise, you mean smaller bladed, smaller jawed, and harder to sharpen, then yes.

You know what precise means, and if you try to cut your fingernails or a hangnail with both scissors, you figure it out pretty quick.

Edited to add: if arguing about scissors with a stranger on the internet is the worst thing I do today, I'm doing pretty good! :thumbup:
 
Last edited:
Nicer in what way? The Spirit's scissors are probably 10x more precise, wouldn't you agree?

After a fair trial period, I gave up on the Spirit. One reason (there were others) was the dinky scissors, which time and again didn't open wide enough for some materials and with blades effectively no longer than those on the 58 mm Vics. It was good for cutting fishing line, snipping threads, and nipping the occasional hangnail, but other than that, largely a waste of space that could have been better utilized by a more useful implement. Even Charge Tti scissors, only slightly larger, can handle a wider variety of cutting chores.

I agree, Vic makes the best scissors, but those are found on regular SAKs. Those on the Spirit are too compromised to be effective in a heavier duty multi-tool.
 
You know what precise means, and if you try to cut your fingernails or a hangnail with both scissors, you figure it out pretty quick.

:thumbup:

How often are you cutting your fingernails with scissors??? Seems to be an incorrect use of tools..use nail clippers, not scissors. BTW I just got a wingman and now edc it. It is about 10x better then my SAK..Granted that the sak is the super tinker, which doesnt have pliers.
 
Per my write up on the Wingman, it would be good at a price point of about $19.95, I got a pretty good price from Home Depot because I have heard of some paying around $30.00 bucks for this tool, Ouch!!!!!!! I will not pick up another one, but this one I have will get used everytime I get the chance just to save wear and tear on my ST300.
 
Good review!
Whats the thickness difference between the Wingman and the Spirit? I like the slenderness of my Spirit but i wish it had a pocket clip.
If the Wingman is close to the same thickness of the Spirit then i'll probably pick one up.
Anyone have any side by side pics of both for dimensional comparison?
For me the pocket clip is a big selling point, how durable is it?
 
Whats the thickness difference between the Wingman and the Spirit? I like the slenderness of my Spirit but i wish it had a pocket clip.
If the Wingman is close to the same thickness of the Spirit then i'll probably pick one up.
Anyone have any side by side pics of both for dimensional comparison?
For me the pocket clip is a big selling point, how durable is it?

Here's comparison shots of mine.









Hope that helps out some.
 
Back
Top