I'm a very happy camper today. I managed to acquire my first Remington scout last fall, and it was a very good one. The only issues were a slightly short punch, a twisted bail, and some mostly cosmetic digs in the edge of the main blade. After getting that one excellent Remington, I embarked on a journey to find one that was as close to functionally perfect as possible. I tried a few auction Remingtons, as well a handful of bargain Pal scouts, but none of them totally panned out. I either ended up with short blades or cracked covers.
Well I finally paid the piper last week, and ordered another Remington at a higher price than I'd ordinarily pay. Nothing too extravagant, but definitely outside my comfort zone. The new knife arrived in my mailbox yesterday, and I'm very relieved to say that it's in wonderful condition. I'm not sure if the spear blade has ever been sharpened, it's so long and full. The awl is so clean, it still has that bluish discoloration inside the scoop. The caplifter/screwdriver is full, with maybe just the slightest twist in the flathead tip. The two-piece can opener is in great shape. All tools are perfectly tight and properly crinked. Every tool opens and closes with an authoritative snap. The Remington bone covers are flat out gorgeous, well matched, and have no noticeable cracks or chips. The tang stamps on both the main blade and punch are in great shape, as is the BSA shield on the mark side cover. The bail is even straight.
I'd say that the only problem with the knife is that somebody tried to clean it up a bit at one point, and removed most of the patina. But that I can add back on, so it's not a huge issue. I'll be doing that at my earliest convenience, because
I hate the look of an antique knife that's obviously had the patina removed.
I hate to say it, but I think I may have now hit somewhat of an endpoint in my scout collecting. My scout search has always been about finding that perfect knife to use. I've nailed my perfect scout model down to either the Camillus Engineer knife or the Remington RS3333 BSA knife, and I now have two excellent examples of both knives, that aren't so crazy rare that I'm afraid to use them. All that's left is for me to finish my long term evaluation of the Camillus, and to perform the same testing on the Remington.