Mora replacement: Victorinox Forschner boning knives?

RokJok

Gold Member
Joined
Oct 6, 2000
Messages
4,092
Since we've been flogging the Mora horse lately, usually to enthusiastic endorsements, consider the Victorinox Forschner model 40612 (6" blade), model 40614 (5" blade), and model 40811 (4" blade) stiff boning knives as a nearly-as-cheap replacement for the cheaper Mora models and a cheaper alternative to the higher priced Mora style knife mfr/model versions as carried by Ragweed Forge, who is to be commended for carrying models from several manufacturers.

Whew....... Yes, sometimes I fall into run-on sentences. ;)

Those models of Forschners have a couple of distinctions from the Mora knives: full flat ground primary bevels and the fact that they are made from stainless steel stock. IMHO those are both good things for a low-maintenance beat-around knife. YMMV. Also, the decently ergonomic shape of their Fibrox handles offers more security of grip than the straight, no-guard, round or oval cross-sectioned Mora handles.

The typical price range for the Forschners on the web is $17-$25. However, using the 40614 model as my search criteria I found it for $12 at restaurantsource.net and for $13.95 at cadcutlery.com.

In a previous life as a meatcutter we used the Forschner Fibox-handled knives (which these models are) on a daily basis. While they won't hold an edge like a well-heat-treated 52100 or A2 carbon steel knife, they were easy to re-steel or re-stone into a usable edge for trimming and cutting meat, which is likely sharper than you'll need for wood slicing since wood is more rigid than refrigerated meat fiber.

The 12" blade models, being also made of relatively thin stock, may work as a 12" machete alternative. That idea is less likely to appeal since cheap machetes are, after all, typically **VERY** cheap to buy. However, if you spot one of the Forschners at a garage/yard sale for a few bucks, it's something to think about.

Just another alternative to add to the database of "cheap and good bang-for-the-buck knives" when you are looking to save some $$ for other gear.
 
Nothing will replace my Mora's, but seems there are lots of nice blades by Forschners. I like the 6" riveted chefs knife, the short straight blade butcher and a few others.
 
Just another alternative to add to the database of "cheap and good bang-for-the-buck knives" when you are looking to save some $$ for other gear.

Nuttin' wrong with that. I got a Tramontina Sport/Universal knife on Ebay for $3.50 that is like that. Came with a sheath too. It is thinner stock, like most chef's knives. I was hoping for a heavier blade, but for $3.50, what the heck!


7258_1.JPG


The same commercial fishing supply I get my mora's from has a whole wall full of the Forshner-syle knives. Feast yer eyeballs here, Matey :)

http://www.seattlemarine.net/productcart/pc/viewCategories.asp?idCategory=948

Make shure you look at "deck knives" and the "Russell Harrington" link too.
 
As a professional meat cutter and wild game processor during my high school and college years (family business), I learned early of the utility and price/value of Forschner knives. I commissioned a $250 custom skinning knife (semi-skinner) for hunting (BG42 blade, 5/32" thick stock, flat ground, micarta handle), but my $16 Forschner Model 40532 5" Lamb Skinner does a good job also. Actually, I could field dress, skin, and muscle bone an elk with a piece of broken coke bottle! It's hard to get people to quit thinking about which expensive knife to use on the animal and start thinking about the job itself and what tools would be adequate. Oh well, when you're a hammer, everything looks like a nail.
 
The small victorinox parers are very nice as well, and I think they would make a nice addition to a minimalist kit, as they are very small and light. A friend of mine uses their "buffalo skinner" model for everything including cleaning fish, and just loves it.
 
Nuttin' wrong with that. I got a Tramontina Sport/Universal knife on Ebay for $3.50 that is like that. Came with a sheath too. It is thinner stock, like most chef's knives. I was hoping for a heavier blade, but for $3.50, what the heck!


7258_1.JPG


The same commercial fishing supply I get my mora's from has a whole wall full of the Forshner-syle knives. Feast yer eyeballs here, Matey :)

http://www.seattlemarine.net/productcart/pc/viewCategories.asp?idCategory=948

Make shure you look at "deck knives" and the "Russell Harrington" link too.

Nice looking Tramontina! Stainless, I bet?
 
I use the Forsh in the kitchen everyday---never took it out in the field. I love it and have used it on Sushi grade Ahi, Mahi-Mahi, Ling Cod, huge Sea Bass (Toothfish), Lamb, beef sides and maybe a thousand chickens. Next to my Tojiro Gyuto in the kitchen, its tops.
 
I think that the forshners are realy good knives,I like that there easy to sharpen and I love the handles.I like fixed blades and kitchen knives for cleaning game because there so much easier to clean up than a folder.

Dalew,that looks like alot of knife for $3.50!:thumbup:
 
The small victorinox parers are very nice as well, and I think they would make a nice addition to a minimalist kit, as they are very small and light. A friend of mine uses their "buffalo skinner" model for everything including cleaning fish, and just loves it.


Seattle Marine had the Victorinox cordura sheaths for the paring knives as well as Kydex models. Commercial fishermen use the serrated paring knives for net repair and general cutting. I don't know how many they go through in a season, but my hunch is they go overboard when they are dull.
 
I think that the forshners are realy good knives,I like that there easy to sharpen and I love the handles.I like fixed blades and kitchen knives for cleaning game because there so much easier to clean up than a folder.

Dalew,that looks like alot of knife for $3.50!:thumbup:

heheh-- almost as good as the 10" Forschner chef's knife I got in a thrift store for $1.99. :D That thing is more like a short sword in the kitchen. One nice thing about hanging around these forums-- enough has rubbed off on me to improve my eye for decent cutting tools. I continue to study with the masters :)
 
As a professional meat cutter and wild game processor during my high school and college years (family business), I learned early of the utility and price/value of Forschner knives. I commissioned a $250 custom skinning knife (semi-skinner) for hunting (BG42 blade, 5/32" thick stock, flat ground, micarta handle), but my $16 Forschner Model 40532 5" Lamb Skinner does a good job also. Actually, I could field dress, skin, and muscle bone an elk with a piece of broken coke bottle! It's hard to get people to quit thinking about which expensive knife to use on the animal and start thinking about the job itself and what tools would be adequate. Oh well, when you're a hammer, everything looks like a nail.

Good point.
 
Nice looking Tramontina! Stainless, I bet?

Yes-- INOX stainless. It's really just a light kitchen style blade-- about half the thickness of a mora. Perfect for camp kitchen stuff. You're not going to use it to chop wood or other heavier chores. BBQ steak, tomatoes and onions beware! Now I'm hungry-- drat!
 
I love Moras but i also have two fibrox Vic kitchen knives, one modded into a pseudo Nessmuk. The Moras and Vics are both great knives are easy to sharpen and hold a keen edge.
I have an old 60's/70's tramontina 1/4 inch thick carbon steel bowie (great knife) do they make anything in carbon steel anymore or is it all stainless?
 
Back
Top