Mr. Clean Magic Eraser. Say what?

Joined
Apr 28, 2011
Messages
1,528
The Mr. Clean Magic Eraser was recommended to me by a fellow Hog and forumite drbarnes when I complained about rub marks on a couple of my blades. (Call me OCD, but I hate marks on my coated blades.)

I'll start by saying this, the Magic Eraser really is Magic!

The first blade that I wanted to clean up had a beautiful unused, light colored smooth coating that was marred by black rub marks on the coating right near the edge, on the edge itself, and on other parts of the blade. (Not going to say what blade or who made it. It's irrelevant and I don't want to give any Blade company a bad image, unless they deserve it.) So anyways I took barnes' suggestion and bought a two pack of Magic Erasers.

I wish I had before and after pics, because the blade is spotless now!

I used the eraser on a couple other CG users and it also worked to clean them up quite a bit.

Here's a quick guide if you want to try this yourself:
1. Buy Mr. Clean Magic Erasers.
2. Fill a cereal bowl, or other small container half full with water.
3. Lay the blade on an old towel or cloth on top of a work bench or other flat surface and keep a roll of paper towels or a cloth nearby. (I also wore heavy duty rubber gloves for protection and cleanliness.)
4. Cut one or two 1/4" - 1/2" slices off one of the erasers (depending upon size and number of blades you wish to remove rub marks from.)
5. Submerge one of the pieces of Magic Eraser in the bowl of water for a second, then remove it and squeeze a lot of the water out (should be damp, not soaked.)
6. Apply pressure (not too much) to the affected area and rub it back and forth along the area you wish to remove rub marks from. (Be careful not to apply too much pressure or rub the blade for too long. The Magic Eraser has grit to it and could potentially cause damage to the coating or edge. In my case it did not.)
7. Soak up any water that was left behind on the blade with paper towels or other cloth (will get dirty.)
8. Repeat steps 5-7 on all areas that you wish to remove rub marks from. You can reuse the piece of Magic Eraser until it falls apart or gets too dirty to use.

It's that simple!

Disclaimer: Test this at your own risk. Please don't hold me responsible if you end up with less than desirable results. The Mr. Clean Magic Eraser is very ingenious scientifically. That's not what this thread is about, so do some research on it first like I did. Note: I did not try this on Satin INFI or on a blade with a crinkle coat, they all had smooth coats. I think it could work on a Satin Busse or kin blade, but proceed with caution. Best practice would be to test a small area of your blade before proceeding.
 
Last edited:
I use the Magic eraser all the time at home, never thought about using it on my knives. Thanks for the tip Flux:thumbup:
 
I use the Magic eraser all the time at home, never thought about using it on my knives. Thanks for the tip Flux:thumbup:

You're quite welcome! After I used it on my blades, I cleaned up some scuff marks on my wall. I believe it says not to use it on paint, but it worked great for me!
 
Nifty idea! Thanks for the heads up Flux! :)
 
You're quite welcome! After I used it on my blades, I cleaned up some scuff marks on my wall. I believe it says not to use it on paint, but it worked great for me!



I use it on my walls at home all the time and they are painted, work's like a charm:)
 
Awesome tip, Flux!!! I use the magic eraser on almost everything and never fails!
 
I've always got a couple of these around the kitchen and bathroom... I consider them an adjunct to the WD40 / Duct Tape rule:

"If it's dirty, hit it with a Magic Eraser"

Can't believe I never thought to use them on my knives... Great tip!
 
I love cleaning with magic erasers, but a magic wand would be more fun.
 
I love cleaning with magic erasers, but a magic wand would be more fun.
I am pretty sure Jerry could invent one. How about a TGLBS Magic Wand with dual holy terrors or paracord D-guards? Bring it Jerry!!! While you're at it, bring on the Mini-Muk. PLEASE!!!!? Also it's time for a re-release of SHBAs.
It will take a coat off a blade.

I would agree, but would change it to: It could take the coat off a blade. This is why I added the disclaimer. It worked on the coatings I tried it on, but I have not tried it on crinkle coat, and other type of blade coatings. Proceed with caution and always test it out on a small portion of the coating of a blade that is already beat up.

I am sure you could strip a coating with enough pressure and time, and I would venture a guess that you could polish a satin blade or even sharpen your edge. Think of it as a very fine grit sandpaper and proceed with caution. Don't say I didn't warn you.
 
Last edited:
Like others have already stated, I have used these on lots of things but never thought to try it on knives. Thanks for the tip Flux.

Garth
 
Like others have already stated, I have used these on lots of things but never thought to try it on knives. Thanks for the tip Flux.

Garth

No problem Garth! I hope it works out well.

If anyone is brave enough to try it on Satin INFI, or any of the other Satin Busse Kin steels, please share your results. I'm guessing it could mess up a brand new Satin finish, but who knows.
 
No problem Garth! I hope it works out well.

If anyone is brave enough to try it on Satin INFI, or any of the other Satin Busse Kin steels, please share your results. I'm guessing it could mess up a brand new Satin finish, but who knows.

I've used them on my satin knives before with no problems. They don't mark the finish at all, well they didn't on mine anyway. Awesome invention. Great for cleaning the shower too :)
 
I use a magic eraser with Goof Off on all my blades. Cuts right through sap ect. and is fine on Busse coatings. I also use a magic eraser with Soft Scrub spray on all my micarta. Rince with water, it dries in seconds and comes out like new but the texture on the scales chews up the eraser a bit.
 
Be very careful using on painted walls - it will take off the paint. Ask me how I know :grumpy:
 
Thanks for the last minute " stocking stuffer " idea for the wife! I'll buy her a few and she'll never miss one.
 
Like others have already stated, I have used these on lots of things but never thought to try it on knives. Thanks for the tip Flux.

Garth

DId I read this right? You have cleaned lots of things before!? lol. I am impressed and shocked.
 
Thanks RobStanley, FTR, MVF and others for posting your experiences, tips and warnings.

I'm sure the Magic Eraser can remove paint, but it may depend on the type of paint because it seems to work just fine for myself and others.

DId I read this right? You have cleaned lots of things before!? lol. I am impressed and shocked.

Haha. Maybe that's why the custom shop is so busy - Garth is cleaning his shop all day ;). Or maybe it's because he is cranking out gorgeous customs like a madman?

Hey thats a good idea flux!
I'm full good ideas. Why don't you try one for a change?
 
Back
Top