NAVAL JELLY: Is it too harsh for knife use???

Joined
Jul 2, 1999
Messages
1,347
Hello all,

I need some first hand info on the rust remover, "Naval jelly". Is it too harsh for knives? I have heard that it can stain or etch the blade, is this true? Please let me know what your experience is with the stuff and what kind of metal you used it on. Thanks.
 
Louis, Naval Jelly is evil, wicked, mean and nasty. It is used for removing rust from naval vessels and gear, and I wouldn't want it within a good yard of my knives. I suppose with some experimenting it could be used for etching, but it is a vile, foul substance that I hope I never have to use again.
 
Originally posted by stjames
Louis, Naval Jelly is evil, wicked, mean and nasty. It is used for removing rust from naval vessels and gear, and I wouldn't want it within a good yard of my knives. I suppose with some experimenting it could be used for etching, but it is a vile, foul substance that I hope I never have to use again.

So, is that good or bad? :rolleyes: :p lol

What happened when you used it? I am curious. Also, maybe it can be diluted???
 
Bad, very bad. I had to use it to remove rust from lighting gear used in an outdoor theater, nasty work, paint the jelly on, wait, rinse, repeat. I don't know if it can be thinned out, just what do you want to use it for?
 
It is also excellent as a blue remover,takes it off right now.It is an acid so be careful how long you leave it on.
 
Thanks for the info so far, guys. I am trying to find a rust,grime remover/knife polishing compound and I am sick of using polish/remover in a tube such as Metal Glo. I have cleaned knives that were so "Dirty" that I could blow through almost an entire tube of metal Glo and could still remove "black stuff" from the blade. There has to be a better way. Right? What other methods/products are good for removing the "Black stuff" and rust? Is Flitz any better than Metal glo?
 
Naval Jelly will discolor and or stain knife blades. And yes, it will remove some etching on knife blades. I use it on my work knives when they get REALLY nasty/rusty. But I don't care if it messes them up or not. I would not use the stuff on any knives I cared about because I try not to let them rust in the first place. I also use flitz and it is good for cleaning the blade. I then follow it up with tuff glide for protection.
 
Anyone ever try muriatic acid? I used Mar-Hyde rust dissolver when I was reoving some rust on an old car before I painted it, it wasn't too harsh (in fact it wasn't harsh enough). If your knives are that dirty and oxidized, would it matter if you used some sandpaper or heavy duty polishing compound on them?
 
I wore a Perrin La Griffe to Friday's NY Custom Knife Show. I took it out of its sheath this morning for the first time since the show & was shocked to see that the blade was practically covered with rough, ugly orange rust.

Backing up a bit, Friday was unusually warm here in NYC with temps around 80 F. Since both the subway system & the hotel seem to practice climate control by calendar, not temperature, both were pumping heat. Although all I wore was a t-shirt with an open cotton shirt over it, I was uncomfortably warm for hours. (Even the cigar bar in the lobby was cranking out the heat.;)) Earlier in the week, I had cleaned the Perrin's blade (I've deliberately allowed the handle to oxydize.) with Simichrome & then gave it a good rub down with a Tuf-Cloth.

Back to this morning, I was pissed. Even though I used Tuf-Cloth & had vent holes drilled in the sheath, apparently sweat had become trapped against the blade & did its ugly work. I anticipated hours of cleaning & polishing with Simichrome when my wife suggested I try CLR.

CLR is the stuff you see advertised on TV for removing calcium, lime & rust. (It's also sold in Genovese stores.) The bottle cautions that it is corrosive (contains sulfamic & citric acids) & can etch certain materials but I decided to take a chance. It worked great! Using rubber gloves, I poured some on a paper towel & wiped down the blade. The rust began to come off instantly. Only a minute or so later & it was all gone, leaving only a light gray patina in a few places on the metal. I rinsed & dried the knife, applied Simichrome & polished it back to its original condition.

Of course, YMMV. CLR may have removed the gray patina or it may have etched the blade if I used it for a longer period of time. I didn't want to take that chance. What it did do was save me a long stretch of manual polishing.
 
Back
Top