I actually replied to the owner of the last site I tried to buy from and explained to him that it is legal to own that knife in NYC, just not to carry it around in public places. After explaining that it was to be a BOB,SHTF/camping knife he said he would sell it to me. Basically saying that NYC laws are so vague and worded so poorly that he just wants to avoid any problems, which is perfectly understandable.
I was going to go to eBay but, after getting such quick customer service from this guy I really wanted to stick with him and his site for the purchase. I read good things about his site and apparently it was all true.
By the way, my knife will be shipped out on Tuesday.