• The rules for The Exchange can be found here. Please read and follow them. Stop using Paypal Friends & Family and follow our best practices to prevent getting ripped off or having a bad deal.
  • The BladeForums.com 2024 Traditional Knife is ready to order! See this thread for details: https://www.bladeforums.com/threads/bladeforums-2024-traditional-knife.2003187/
    Price is $300 ea (shipped within CONUS). Now open to the forums as a whole. If you live outside the US, I will contact you after your order for extra shipping charges. If there are customs issues? On you.

    User Name
    Serial number request
  • Merry Christmas and Happy Hannukah from all of us here on BladeForums! We hope that your holidays are filled with cheer!

Northwoods Knives horrible customer service!

Feedback: +21 / =0 / -0
Joined
Oct 13, 2006
Messages
781
Here's the details(so far) about my customer service experience with Northwoods knives.

The knife I'm having a problem with is my 2008 bladeforums.com traditional forum knife by Northwoods Knives. It's a small stockman slipjoint knife with stag scales in the $100 price range.

Problems with the knife right out of the box:
All three blades had burnt tips from sharpening on a belt sander.
Shield was poorly fit.
The spring pin was very sloppy (spun off center with chunky pieces of brass hanging off it).
The stag looked almost like tan smooth bone. Very weak compared to all Northwoods knives I've seen before.
I can live with some of these problems, but the burnt blade tips are totally unacceptable for a $100 production knife.

January 13th: I expressed my disappointment with the knife in an e-mail addressed to David Shirley of Northwoods.

January 13th: I received a reply stating that per Dave Shirley, I should send the knife in for repair. They said "we will see what we can do."

January 14th: I mailed the knife to Northwoods.

February 2nd: Around three weeks after mailing the knife to Northwoods, I e-mailed asking if they received my knife. I also requested a repair status.

February 3rd: Received an e-mail from Northwoods stating that they received the knife on the 19th. They said "it is on our schedule to be fixed."

March 25th: I e-mailed Northwoods requesting an update on the repair. I specifically mentioned that I sent the knife to them 10 weeks ago. I received no reply to this e-mail message.

March 30th: I called Northwoods on the phone and left a detailed voice mail message asking for an update on my knife repair via a return phone call.

March 31st: I received no return call from Northwoods so I called them again around 3:00 PM today. The guy on the phone told me they are waiting on a part. My attempts to get more information about the part or the expected repair date were answered with an "I don't know." All he said was "I'll call you when it's fixed."

I've had the knife in my possession for 5 days of the 82 days that I've owned it. Exactly 11 weeks(nearly three months!!!!) have passed and I still have no knife or any idea how much longer I have to wait. Northwoods Knives hasn't returned recent e-mails or phone calls, so I'm not holding my breath. I'm starting to doubt that I'll ever see my knife again.

I absolutely won't be buying or recommending Northwoods knives EVER again. I'm simply amazed at the lack of customer service during such a slow economy. Guess my $100 or future business isn't important to them.

In comparison, the Case Doctor's knife I sent back to Case because of blade play and a weak back-spring was back in my hands after only 9 days. A confirmation e-mail and door to door in 9 days!!! That's customer service!
 
Last edited:
I will call Dave Shirley in the morning and see if I can help. I hope you don't mind.
There must be something not right (obviously) because this situation does not sound like the Dave Shirley I know.

Let's nobody jump to any conclusions and let's stick to whatever facts come out.

Back to you in the morning Augustus88.

Keep Care,

Pappy
 
Tim(Pappy),
Feel free to contact Dave. I've presented the facts that I have so far. I appreciate any help getting this taken care of.
Ultimately I don't mind waiting if the knife is going to be fixed correctly. What I hate is not getting a reply from Northwoods about this after 11 weeks of patiently waiting. This thread wouldn't be here if they e-mailed me back sometime last week or returned my call earlier today. I've been patient and polite so far, but I hate being ignored and brushed off. All I wanted was an update on the repair. Getting the knife back in a timely manner would've been great, but an update on the progress would've sufficed.

Thanks,
Octavio(augustus88)
PS Thanks again for that great little Cattaraugus Doctor's knife. She's a dandy!
 
12 weeks and still no knife.

The owner of Northwoods was contacted as mentioned two posts up and still no phone call or e-mail with an explanation, apology or estimated date. :mad::mad::mad:

Looks like Dave Shirley is going to get lots of calls from me tomorrow until he calls me back.

I've heard you're a great guy Dave. Step up to the plate and live up to your reputation!
 
What happened with this? Did they get the knife back to you? Was it fixed right? I was about to pull the trigger on a northwoods stockman and this stopped me dead in my tracks. It kind of reminds me of strider knives and god knows how much I don't like strider after the nightmare I experienced with their cs.
 
I heard Dave Shirley has retired and now Derrick Bohn of knives ship free has taken over these knives along with the Scagels.
Scott
 
Originally Posted by Gossman Knives
I heard Dave Shirley has retired and now Derrick Bohn of knives ship free has taken over these knives along with the Scagels.
Scott

Yeah but who isn't giving the customer service -- Shirley or Bohn?

I was just pointing out a problem thread about Northwoods Knives.

The knife you got is beautiful. Very nice. Good luck with it.
 
Originally Posted by Gossman Knives
I heard Dave Shirley has retired and now Derrick Bohn of knives ship free has taken over these knives along with the Scagels.
Scott

Yeah but who isn't giving the customer service -- Shirley or Bohn?

I was just pointing out a problem thread about Northwoods Knives.

The knife you got is beautiful. Very nice. Good luck with it.

This thread is more than a year old. I believe that Dave Shirley owned the company then, but Derrick has since taken over. ;)
 
Last edited:
We just purchased the Northwoods trademark and all of the back inventory. We just signed the papers last week.

We will be doing the customer service from here on out.

The knives will be made by Queen and I had a long discussion with them at Blade and they are going to honor warranties (still send them in through me). We should be in good shape even on the older stuff.
 
Back
Top