AlwaysTomboy
Gold Member
- Joined
- Jan 31, 2016
- Messages
- 748
Oooo, osage orange. Yes, please!
I voted for the micarta version. As mentioned above and in earlier threads the natural handle materials can be very inconsistent. I guess I prefer symmetry and like to receive a predictable product. I would be OK with a smooth or jigged bone, but not elk or stag. Even some of the exotic woods can run the gambit of visual beauty. Also the more exotic choices add to the cost which may eventually impact the product being produced once we have to cough up the cash.
Can I as the typical forum knife costs in the past? I have never participated before.
,,,Mike in Canada
How about including it with the Burl and ironwood and narrowing it down if it’s chosen ?Orange Osage is also an option. I'm working on how to redo this poll to stream line it and include Bocote.
We've tried to keep the price at 100.00 or less.I voted for the micarta version. As mentioned above and in earlier threads the natural handle materials can be very inconsistent. I guess I prefer symmetry and like to receive a predictable product. I would be OK with a smooth or jigged bone, but not elk or stag. Even some of the exotic woods can run the gambit of visual beauty. Also the more exotic choices add to the cost which may eventually impact the product being produced once we have to cough up the cash.
Can I as the typical forum knife costs in the past? I have never participated before.
,,,Mike in Canada
I like this idea.I think we might be seeing the effects of having way too many options to choose from. Hindsight might tell us that it would have perhaps been better to do the cover material polling in stages.
This isn't a critique by any means, just an observation. When face with so many choices, the results can often be convoluted and exasperating.
- First round - Divide materials by type (synthetic, wood, horn/antler, bone)
- Second round - List and vote on choices within specific type chosen in first round. (e.g. Elk, Sambar, Ram's Horn, Buffalo, etc.) (e.g. Micarta, G10, Carbon Fiber, Delrin, etc.) (e.g. Ebony, Ironwood, Bocote, Zebrawood, etc.)
I like this idea.
Though I think I'd prefer three simultaneous polls where folks vote for their favorite wood in one poll, favorite synthetic in another, and favorite animal parts in another.
Then pit the three winners against each other in a no holds barred, battle Royale, final poll.
This is just brainstorming though, and certainly not a request. I'm very happy with how things are going so far with the process.
Those will go into the "Battle Royale" round 1 for the Wood poll.How about including it with the Burl and ironwood and narrowing it down if it’s chosen ?
When I created the poll, I did it according to price rather than according to type. The reason for this is that everyone is constantly asking for price. So we did price, and now we want type. If I did type, we would want price. I still haven't figured out how to do the "do over" perfectly. Right now I think I'm going to watch a while longer, and then take the leaders out of the comments and voting. Clearly, we need to whittle the list down from it's current state. I would bet it is safe to rule out Diamondwood, CF, shell and mother of pearl. I don't know if we can back track to the larger groupings (synthetic, wood, etc.)
I really like the idea of having the next round be the Battle Royale. Animal vs. Wood vs. Synthetics. I think you have a winner with that!
Though this poll is not set up perfectly, I do believe we are getting the data we need to refine it for the next rounds.
Those will go into the "Battle Royale" round 1 for the Wood poll.