I have used OSFO extensively on farm equipment, tree stands, property gates, etc. prior to painting. I would be really reluctant to use it on a knife. It is an incredibly caustic product. I think the chance of ruining the knife would be high, IMHO. I would be more likely to thoroughly clean the knife, clean it with alcohol, and soak the blade in warm vinegar until it formed a patina. If it was a delrin handled fixed blade, I would put the whole thing in vinegar. If not, I would only put the blade in vinegar.