Real, Usable Sword Cane/staff?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Aug 26, 2010
Messages
4,441
I'm kinda looking for a 5' staff that has a concealed sword of usable (reads aggressor ventilating) quality.

I would prefer something that actually LOOKS like a walking stick rather than a katana without a tsuba.


I know there are a few sword canes out there, but i'm not old enough to pull that look off, so a staff would be great.
 
I'm kinda looking for a 5' staff that has a concealed sword of usable (reads aggressor ventilating) quality.

I would prefer something that actually LOOKS like a walking stick rather than a katana without a tsuba.


I know there are a few sword canes out there, but i'm not old enough to pull that look off, so a staff would be great.

...because young guys in your area typically carry 5 foot staffs around? :)
 
i walk in the woods a lot... i carry my Bo with me everywhere out there (looks like a walking stick)... I'm very proficient with it, so it'd be highly effective for defense, but since i'm utterly inexperienced with the use of a sword, i thought it'd be a great idea to get one to defend myself with, rather than the Bo that I know so well
 
i walk in the woods a lot... i carry my Bo with me everywhere out there (looks like a walking stick)... I'm very proficient with it, so it'd be highly effective for defense, but since i'm utterly inexperienced with the use of a sword, i thought it'd be a great idea to get one to defend myself with, rather than the Bo that I know so well

Sounds like a good plan...

I would submit that "aggressor ventilating" with a concealed sword is going to take a lot of explaining in court even if totally justified. I would further submit that any situation where deadly force is required would probably mean that your "aggressor" is armed with a firearm which means the only person getting ventilated is you. If you were walking around in an area that is that dangerous... don't. If it's not that dangerous your bo should be fine. YMMV.
 
I have a cheapo Zatoichi sword, it's not 5' long, and it's too heavy to use as a cane, for me. It's straight, not curved like a katana. I suspect that a 5' walking stick, with a 36" to 40" blade inside would be even heavier. The straight blade is also more difficult to draw out, compared to a curved sword. In fact it's pretty akward, unless you're just throwing the rest of the stick away from you.
I personally like swords, bokken, and have a bo staff as well. But in the woods my walking stick is a couple of golf club shafts paired up with a trekking pole tip. And my self defense is either a 9mm or .357 magnum and a large knife. If I really needed a sword in the woods, it would be my Swamp Rat Waki. It's curved, and with a 17.5" blade it's short enough to swing near trees, and better if an animal is already on you, I think. Maybe a knife or a point blank shot would be in order?
Good luck in your search.
 
id rather be alive and explaining, then being lowered into a hole and buried, while your loved ones watch.
 
i walk in the woods a lot... i carry my Bo with me everywhere out there (looks like a walking stick)... I'm very proficient with it, so it'd be highly effective for defense, but since i'm utterly inexperienced with the use of a sword, i thought it'd be a great idea to get one to defend myself with, rather than the Bo that I know so well
What do you think a sword can do for you that the Bo cannot? You sort of answered this question when you said "the Bo that I know so well". The bo gives distance. If you really need a bladed weapon then consider getting a knife with a socketed handle that can be fit over the bo to make a makeshift spear.
 
Spear (what mross recommended)> Bo Staff> Running away> Not going to Dangerous areas> Knife> Private body guard> Sword

This is what I recommend for your situation OP.

-A spear gives you distance that your ninja attacker will likely not have, unless he's carrying throwing stars. A bo staff also gives you greater distance.
-Running away gives you a good chance of leaving safely and not harming anyone. Unless you cannot run, then I am not sure how you are able to physically walk the woods for long periods of time.
-Not going to dangerous areas is boring but also safer.
-A knife means you dont have to explain to court or to your prison buddy why you were carrying a concealed sword which is illegal iirc in pretty much any USA state.
-Private Body Guard, Chuck Norris comes highly recommended but if you think you need real protection there are a number of escort security companies that would be happy to bring some mercenaries who just finished wiping out a town in some foreign country in to protect you. They may even bring out a helicopter to scout out the area.
-A sword gives you short distance that an attack may be able to close before you pull your sword out. Or may be able to dodge. Either way if he ends up killing you or you end up killing him it's a loose loose.
 
i love my Bo... it's not optimal in close quarters, and it lacks a certain "Tacticool" feel that you get from carrying a sword which you are grosely undertrained to use.

As to what a sword can do that my bo cannot... from my experience sparing against people with boken, it can fall to the ground while you get whacked a few good times to the head... My Bo has never done that for me.
 
but since i'm utterly inexperienced with the use of a sword, i thought it'd be a great idea to get one to defend myself with, rather than the Bo that I know so well

I have to admit, this is kind of amusing after your "you are making assumptions about me and my martial arts experience, or lack thereof." If you're good with a staff, stick to that. Many of the great swordsmen had issues facing someone with a staff. Staff is one of the greatest weapons out there. If you must have a blade, get an HI survival knife or CS Bushman, since you seem to prefer buying cheap to buying quality, and then you have a knife that you can use to easily convert a staff to a spear. Bear in mind if you haven't used a spear, the technique is quite different; balance will be off, effective style is different, so it may take some adaptation.

The tacticool comments and bit about reach honestly make you sound like a mall ninja. Not exactly in the best flavor around here. A sword is generally not a close quarters weapon. If you can't use a staff, chances are a sword won't be much better. There aren't any jurisdictions where you're allowed to carry a concealed sword without a permit, and if you're getting a CCW, you should be getting a firearm. Sword canes in particular are generally illegal. I've used a staff in a hallway before; there are plenty of techniques that I'd think you would/should know that support close-in combat; otherwise you'd lose every fight once someone got close.

If you are in a combat situation, you should also be using the weapon you know best. If you don't know how to use a sword, you're more likely to hurt yourself than your attacker, who, as previously noted, will probably just shoot you before you can so much as draw your sword.

I have to wonder at your motivations here. I'm going to forego offering any product recommendations, because you're making yourself sound like a "tacticool mall ninja" who is exactly the sort of person who gets blade lovers bad media coverage by doing something utterly moronic, and thus create more trouble for the rest of us who actually use our blades responsibly. If you aren't that kind of person, then you should probably temper your comments with more common sense. If you are, please cease and desist. And remember, self defense isn't generally a valid affirmative defense for knife carry. It will be worse for a sword. If you don't know how to use one, chances are you're going to get buried anyways if you get yourself into a situation where you have to defend yourself.
 
lol... you seemed to have missed the majority of the irony in my replies... I'll leave it at that.
 
my opinion ( and that of a majority oflaw enforcement) you get caught with a concealed sword in a cane/staff, you're looking at a felony- don't do it.
Beprepared, how old are you by chance?
 
uh, you know that you carry a swordcane while carrying a gun, and you probably would get a minumum sentance guideline for involving a firearm.
they're a fun collectors item, but I wouldn't go to jail over wanting to carry a cool toy
 
Wait you carry a .45 and you want to carry a sword? Yeah man I can assure you jail time for carrying the sword and a gun and using a sword anyways. Specially when you are IN THE WOODS where you can RUN. Understandable if you are in your room, or in a confined space to pull out your gun but in plain open woods?

Man you are trolling or something. Don't go to jail for something this silly.
 
A long staff wins any day. And providing you're outside, it'll still work in close quarters. This is for pollaxe but demonstrates this ability well.

[video=youtube;gTVC25hYJaY]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gTVC25hYJaY&feature=related[/video]
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top