Review: If I had to choose just one knife....

Joined
Apr 3, 2006
Messages
1,465
Victory1_zpsjibpgaeb.jpg



I recently bought a Victory brand wide boning knife, and I am very pleased with it. If I had to pick just one knife to take hunting, this is my current favourite.

I'm having difficulty uploading this post, so I will do it in several 'pieces'. To be continued....
 
I have hunted, fished and foraged for over fifty years. I feel naked without a knife in my pocket or on my belt. I’ve made, bought, sold, given away and lost dozens of knives.

I’ve been setting traps for feral pigs and brushtailed possums. A few weeks ago I decided that the knives I’d sometimes use to dispatch an animal were either too short, or too unsafe to tackle a big pig with. That’s when I bought the new knife as my hunting and butchery companion. It cost me less than NZ$30.

When I set traps I sometimes need a sharp blade to slash through weeds, vines or twigs that need to be cleared away from my snares. I also have to sharpen the occasional peg, or carve a notch in the release toggles of my spring snares. If I catch something, it needs to be killed, skinned and butchered. My new knife suits me well...

I’ve often said that a three or four inch blade is all that is needed for an all-purpose knife. And while that is largely true for many activities, I prefer the longer blade on the new knife. At about six and a half inches long, it is much more likely to reach the vitals in the ‘boiler room’ of a large hog when I have to stick it behind the shoulder. Sticking a pig in the artery alongside the brisket can be done with a very short knife, but it is hard to get at the brisket of a big boar thrashing about in a snare. The extra length makes it easier to chop through brush too. Although I haven’t done it yet, I can tell that this knife would make a pretty good job of filleting a fish if a narrower blade were not available.

The blade shape is similar to that of the traditional Sami leuku. It is great for skinning, and the shape helps, slightly, to keep the weight forward for chopping. While some might choose a more pointed knife for sticking pigs, I found that my knife worked just fine on the two small animals I recently dispatched with it.

The relatively thin blade (about 0.095”), is tapered from spine to edge. This makes it ideal for cutting meat, clearing light scrub... and re-sharpening. Folks may argue that there are better blades for hacking and levering your way out of a locked trunk, but I seldom find myself in such a situation while hunting.

A guard (quillon) on a knife undoubtedly makes it safer to use when sticking a pig. But guards can get in the way, and they may also make it difficult to use a simple sheath. The handle on this knife has a pattern of raised ‘truncated pyramids’ which really help to prevent my hand slipping, even when wet. The moulded shape of the handle also creates a integral guard that slips easily into a simple sheath while still preventing my hand from sliding forward. I once had to get into the water to cut away a monofilament net that had fouled our boat propellor as we were being swept toward a rocky beach. The only knife I had was fitted with a brass guard which kept on getting caught in the netting. I managed to remove the net before the boat was damaged, but I might have done it with less stress if I’d had my new knife with the moulded guard.

Victory3_zpsa24y5dme.jpg


I like the white handle. If I drop the knife in the scrub, it is much easier to find compared to a darker handle. And the polypropylene (I think) plastic is a good choice for someone like me who thinks that hygiene is very important for a food-preparation knife.

Continued.......

I
 
I made my own sheath from low density polythene water pipe. There are miles of this pipe used around New Zealand and I found a suitable piece where some earthworks were being done near my home. I wrapped the knife in cling film, and built up the hollow areas of the handle with cardboard and tape. I heated the pipe to maybe 215 degrees F in my oven and, wearing leather gloves, I forced the knife into the hot, soft, pipe. I quickly clamped the portion of the pipe containing the blade between a couple of bits of timber to squash it flat. When the pipe cooled. I trimmed it to make a very safe and hygienic sheath. I clean it using a bottle brush.

Victory2_zpsbtghwzaq.jpg


I braided some cord to make a relatively wide, textured belt. I fixed the sheath to this belt so that it would lie horizontally. I wear the knife in front, and I can reach it with either hand... which is handy if my right hand is busy holding on to the leg of an uncooperative pig. I will often wear the knife under a loose jacket to prevent the handle catching in scrub. This also means that I look slightly less like a savage to strangers who I might meet along the way.

Victory Knives are made by the New Zealand company E. Goddard Limited. They have been making knives for around 88 years. During the second world war they evidently produced combat knives for the US army. My first decent ‘factory’ sheath knife was made by E. Goddard... it was given the brand name ‘Green River’ and the model was ‘Bushman’s Friend’. Goddard still make a knife with a similar blade, but now it has a plastic handle and it is called an ‘Outdoor Knife’. They produce practical knives for many different purposes, including a popular diving/rescue knife. When I was the purchasing officer at a large fish processing factory, I bought dozens of Victory knives. They were chosen because they were economical, they held a good edge, they did not corrode when soaked in sanitising chemicals, they were classed as hygienic... and the workers seemed to like them. Interestingly, I recall that some of the filleters sharpened their knives to have a bevel on only one side of the blade. I assume that this helped to ensure greater flesh recovery from the carcass. My family have used one long Victory filleting knife for many years... it sits in a rusty old boat shed in the Marlborough Sounds and it gives great service every time (it’s the one with the white handle in the picture below. The dark fish are blue cod, the others are large ‘spotties’... both good eating).

Fishknives_zpsy1mywprt.jpg


Will I get rid of all my other knives now? Nah. I still like having a selection, and I generally have more than one blade with me when tramping around the hillsides. But if I could only have one hunting knife right now, this would be it.

Best wishes from New Zealand... Stephen Coote.

StephenCoote2015_zps7jyfoibb.jpg
 
This seems like a very good knife with very good value. This knives with flat grinds are easy to sharpen and cut very well.
Butcher knives were the only kind used in older days for butchering, trapping, cooking, wood working, everything.
Thanks for the review.The sheath idea is very good.

Andre.
 
Nice job...

I have made a sheath or two out of PVC that I use for my surf fishing blades. Cheap and durable.

Ps. An ole' salty fisherman I knew who made just about everything out of PVC told me that in a pinch you can heat PVC off of your truck's exhaust pipe. A tip in case you needed to make or repair something in a pinch.
 
Thanks for the comments.

Plastic pipe sheaths are safe, hygienic and practical even if they don't look traditional. I've also used food-grade plastic conveyor belt and plastic fire hose to make sheaths.
 
I am very much a fan of that blade shape (grey handled one) for hunting and general knife use in the woods. It may not be ideal for skinning, but I am very comfortable with it.
 
Back
Top