Review: Ontario Old Hickory 7" Butcher Knife

Joined
Nov 1, 2004
Messages
3,352
This is the Old Hickory Butcher Knife, model 77. I bought and a sheath it for use as a general outdoor knife, as it has a lot of the features I want in a nice camping knife: full tang, carbon steel blade, wooden handle, nice edge and blade shape. It kind of reminds me of a bowie. You can find these knives for about $7. Yup, seven dollars. Here are the details...

Handle Details: The handle is about 4.7" long and made of American hickory. It's straight, and swells just a tiny bit toward the butt. It's buffed and given a burnt look. The left handle scale is etched OLD HICKORY, while the right scale is blank. Both scales are held on via two brass rivets. The blade tang is fully exposed. There was no lanyard hole, so I drilled one myself. This size and shape of handle is really nice for kitchen work, but also gives a very satisfying grip in the woods. There were no splinters or cracks in the wood, and it required very little sanding. It did not irritate my hand at all, even when dressing deer and chopping wood with it. I used the butt only once, just to play, and I broke a cinderblock with it. The wood was slightly dented, but otherwise unharmed.

Blade Details: The blade is 7" long, and made of 1095 carbon (not stainless) steel. It's .056" thick and is hollow ground. Rockwell on mine tested at 56. It is shaped like a typical butcher knife, with a slight clip point and a swell that rises above the rest of the blade in the back. This is to hammer on; at least that's what I've always used that swell for. It came out of the package with a pretty dull edge, but was made sharp in a few minutes. I decided to make this a Scandanavian edge instead of the hollow grind, and this took about an hour to do. But the performance is much better. This blade keeps a very sharp edge, like all carbon blades. However, it tarnishes very easily. I got a nice, dark patina on mine after only about 20 minutes of work chopping wood.
The blade lends itself very well to chopping as well as slicing. Like a bowie. It's plenty thick enough for medium to heavy chopping, while still having a thin enough edge for skinning game. I think this might be my outdoor knife of choice when I go into the woods; it just does everything so darned well.

I also purchased this brown leather belt sheath for it at the whopping price of $4 http://www.bladematrix.tv/index.asp?PageAction=VIEWPROD&ProdID=35015. This keeps it at my side and truly makes this kitchen knife a real outdoor beast. Try it out for yourself, and see how you like a quality knife and sheath for $11 that will give you plenty of use in the woods.

Check out the Old Hickory line here... http://www.ontarioknife.com/oldhickory.html
 
I got real respect for these knives when I tried to break one. Put it into a vise, leaned against it with all my weight--and it just tossed me right back, with a little contempt. I think these things are way undervalued. You can sometimes get several at once on eBay, saving the shipping costs. It seems to me not a bad idea to include a few in your gear, just in case you lose one, drop one into a lake, want to trade one, one gets stolen, etc. For the price of one of the highly-regarded expensive knives you see people rave about on these forums, you could get a hundred of these. And if you just had two or three, you'd be likelier still to have a knife if bad things happened and you lost a knife overboard, misplaced it, etc.
 
So you just lay the original bevel flat to the stone and hone like a Mora? Thats an approach I've not heard of, but sounds good. Where did you find the steel type? I havent seen it listed on knifecenter, where I usually look for these. I've tinkered with the notion of replacing the handles with some Micarta and stainless tubing, but dont have any of either. I currently have a 6" boning knife that used to be for cutting fireproofing from beams and columns. I decided to refinish it, and I think it would look better with fireproofing on it. The hardness is a little low for my taste, but allows them to be drilled and filed to remove extra damage, and customize.
 
I've always wondered about these, and their larger brothers. Unfortunately, there have also been some spectacular failures. Some of the pix are gone, but you can get an idea what happened from the context. It's difficult to say exactly what happened, but it does reinforce the observation made over the years about inconsistent heat treat/tempering of Ontario products.
 
So you just lay the original bevel flat to the stone and hone like a Mora? Thats an approach I've not heard of, but sounds good. Where did you find the steel type?

Yeah, I reground the edge. It was originally hollow ground, but is now Scandanavian. It seems to work better for outdoor use.
I found the steel stype on Ontario's website (linked to it in the first post).
 
i have many old hickory's, fine blades for the price! iv'e been looking for a sheath for my 7" butcher, think i'll look into bladematrix. iv'e also been looking for a sheath for my 6" OH skinner. any ideals would be helpfull. thanks - skimmerhorn
 
i have many old hickory's, fine blades for the price! iv'e been looking for a sheath for my 7" butcher, think i'll look into bladematrix. iv'e also been looking for a sheath for my 6" OH skinner. any ideals would be helpfull. thanks - skimmerhorn

I've thought about making sheaths kind of along these lines:

http://www.dixiegunworks.com/product_info.php?products_id=1539

or

http://www.trackofthewolf.com/(S(f4...atId=9&subId=57&styleId=217&partNum=SHEATH-7R

Possibly adding a blue-jeans-type button to the front, to allow you the alternative of just sliding the sheath and knife under your belt--with the button hanging over the belt and keeping the knife and sheath from sliding out.
 
Regarding that sheath style, I made one for my Russell Green River Hunter and do not care for it. I am a big guy that style carries the knife higher making it uncomfortable. I am making a more traditional pouch sheath as it is easier than loosing weight.

Also, I just got an Old Hickory 8" Chef's knife for $.99 on Ebay!!!
 
I have one of the 14" blade biggies that I use as a machete for light brush in the yard, seems to work real purty-like so far. Of course I've never tried it on anything over 1" in diameter, since pure common sense tells me that blade stock that thin doesn't stand a chance.
 
so these are pretty good?
my dad picked up a set in oman maybe 20-30 years ago.
it included maybe 8+ knives.
i can't get them to get an edge though.
i always (so did dad) thought they were fairly average knives.
 
Jeff Randall of RAT Cutlery recommends Old Hickory as one alternative in his and Mike Perrin's awesome book "Adventure Travel in the Third World."
 
the old hickory was my regular woods knife most of the time from age 9 or 10 up to 15-16. I carried a scout or small SAK for EDC, but when I went into the swamps around my house, I had an old hickory. I ran a trapline for muckrat, and made nemerous sheaths from the pelts.

They wee great knives then.
 
An OH 6" is one of my favorite kitchen knives, hard to beat especially for the price. With a little pimping they make decent outdoors knives to:

oh6ada0.jpg
 
This knife is 18 inches overall length, with a 11 1/2 inch blade, 1/4 inch thick. A friend of mine bought it at a sale of ranching equipment in Montana. It has been rehandled at some time and the back of the blade is really beaten up. I think it was used to break down cattle carcasses after slaughter. I will try to post a picture when my wife returns next week with the digital camera. Oh it also has a tapered tang!
 
Back
Top