I received this 3.5" Roper stockman two weeks ago. An affordable carbon steel (1065) traditional.
At first I was a bit dissapointed: fit and finish wasn't up to par with Rough Rider at a slightly higher price, but that didn't really bother me. What did bother me was that there was absolutely no snap in all the blades.
But after a bath and oiled up the snap has improved incredibly: all blades have good snap now. After totin' it around for the last two weeks I quite like this knife
The most striking F&F 'issues' that I perceived are:
* The spey blade rests against the liner.
* The sheepsfoot blade rests against the spey and that is also the direction it will be pushed when opening the blade.
* Some pins are a bit proud: they catch on your fingers when you move them over the scales.
What I really like is the sleek main blade, long secondaries, the jigging and color of the bone and the fact that is has carbon steel blades.
Interesting observation on the long secondaries: they are longer than the secondaries on the equally sized GEC #66 Calf Roper, but with a larger tang the cutting edge is roughly the same length.
Mark