Some Knife Test Photos

Mistwalker

Gold Member
Joined
Dec 22, 2007
Messages
18,679
My partner Andrew had been wanting to play with the X for a while. Know the different materials available on his land, I thought it sounded like fun. So Sunday afternoon, in a drizzling rain, I let him check it out versus bamboo, wood, and some very dense rubber that is half an inch thick. The rain and dark skies made action shots a challenge, but I managed a few decent photos of the knife in use. And apparently now I am supposed to supply him with one of these too...

Not a lot of text to read this time, I thought I would just share some of the photos.

DSC_4670_zpsmjz4fjxy.jpg


DSC_4701_zps13qyu5yh.jpg


DSC_4702_zpswggpty8h.jpg


DSC_4704_zpsjzcycdqc.jpg


DSC_4705_zpsg3n7xnjz.jpg


DSC_4716_zps43dqz9x6.jpg


DSC_4718_zpsxuolzngk.jpg


DSC_4720_zpst87fyj1v.jpg


DSC_4721_zps8tptjopu.jpg


DSC_4727_zpsktn0xk7h.jpg


DSC_4728_zpswtpleil9.jpg


DSC_4735_zpsnfvy7qkl.jpg


DSC_4738_zps4o2gwljg.jpg


DSC_4740_zpsgnnqgova.jpg


DSC_4839_zpsxwptzid9.jpg


DSC_4852_zps9ujr3r9e.jpg


DSC_4869_zpss8pual8q.jpg


DSC_4870_zpsunr3pi7s.jpg


DSC_4888_zps52lskx5c.jpg


DSC_4900_zpsvtxfpdfd.jpg


DSC_4904_zpsshmkxxe8.jpg


DSC_4916_zpstyygpcfl.jpg


DSC_4930_zpsvfwcny4h.jpg


DSC_4945_zps72kk3hwp.jpg


DSC_4959_zps5vdacklp.jpg


DSC_4960_zpscg8sfiv0.jpg


DSC_4961_zps4sekbp8x.jpg


DSC_4962_zpsi3g4jhrk.jpg


DSC_4963_zps4aytye1w.jpg


DSC_4967_zpsjw0i1jkd.jpg


DSC_4982_zpsbfwu47on.jpg


DSC_4992_zpsnmxlcq9w.jpg


DSC_4995_zpstxdha8rg.jpg


DSC_5000_zpsgeqqeqjq.jpg


DSC_5013_zpsamfyjtwf.jpg


DSC_5017_zpstbgymstt.jpg


DSC_5018_zpsripurwo6.jpg


DSC_5029_zpsz0uadq2n.jpg


DSC_5036_zpsoroqp8fd.jpg



…...
 
Great thread Brian! You have the gift for capturing photos that show knives performing the way the makers intended. I love the motion shots. That is a big bad-ass knife that performs as good as it looks.

Thanks for posting this series of photos. Awesome blade and performance!

Phil
 
Great thread Brian! You have the gift for capturing photos that show knives performing the way the makers intended. I love the motion shots. That is a big bad-ass knife that performs as good as it looks.

Thanks for posting this series of photos. Awesome blade and performance!

Phil

Thank you Phil! Dylan and I go back a ways. We both joined BF the same year, we talked quite a bit through the forums and then met at Blade the first year he was offering his knives for sale. I got the honor of getting to put one of his earliest knives through hell for a while, and was really impressed with his work as a whole. His ergonomics were awesome, his grinds were fantastic, and his heat treat was spot on. We have had a lot of discussions on knife use and functionality over the years and we have a lot of similar thoughts on the matter. This knife came about from a discussion on the tools we would want in an apocalyptic environment. I have and use axes, and though I do like using hawks some, I am really not a big axe fan. I really prefer a large knife. machetes tend to run a little thin for my tastes in most cases, and then in large knives most production knives seem to either be too thick and have too much mass for my tastes, or they are thinner but not tough enough to handle the hard work that I wanted one to handle. Dylan has a great talent for blending his blade geometry together for the right combination of balance, cutting performance, lateral strength, and overall durability. He knows where to remove unnecessary mass without sacrificing strength. When I described the knife I wanted, I thought about what environmental elements I might encounter in such a world. I wanted it to perform in a variety of cutting tasks, in a variety of environments from temperate forest, to the swamps in the deep south.

DSC_4301_zpswkq5at3v.jpg


DSC_4277_zps1f20qxg2.jpg


DSC_1415_zpssdumto59.jpg


DSC_1697_zpsc1jww5my.jpg


DSC_1295_zpsqwxnrxpe.jpg




So I drew out a knife with a 10 inch blade to give me reach, but still be small enough to tuck away in a pack for discretion if needs be. I wanted the elements I liked most about the Bowie, Kukri, and Barong blended together without the elements I didn't like about each. I wanted a slight re-curve for the mechanical advantage of enhance cutting ability in a fatigued physical state, an oval cross section to the handle for good blade control in finer work, and Dylan's awesome contours for both the secure purchase and hand comfort in long term use. I wanted a forward weight distribution for good inertia development with enough mass in the front half of the blade to bite well in chopping, combined with a point sharp enough to penetrate tough hides. I wanted it to function well as a tool in an organic environment, to make other tools with, shelters, fire prep, and general camp work. I also had to take into consideration how I would want it to perform well in an defensive / offensive role as well. These conversations between Dylan and I always flow very smoothly. He has a lot of knowledge in that head of his, and it is really easy for us to get on the same page blade wise. So he took it from there. He refined the drawing and put it to steel in his usual stellar fashion. Though we needed to tweak the handle just a bit for the final version, he essentially nailed it right out of he gate and produced exactly what I needed and wanted.

10968082_883696415024665_316593258_n_zpsvvozfiik.jpg


Capture_zpso6tsgtzf.jpg


11248690_936377799718190_6869687262586993852_o_zpsz7l1pcss.jpg


11182717_913569895332314_2643100136575803096_o_zpswoohecgp.jpg


10504842_913569891998981_4656732154214564053_o_zps8knecdmr.jpg


11187171_913569761998994_2995560854936799813_o_zps5bfi9uz4.jpg


11212123_913569768665660_8906263093596713377_o_zpsozd64ceu.jpg


11163280_913569778665659_3805312617611989978_o_zpsaley2tfe.jpg


11174299_913569775332326_4725529616086229012_o_zps4knl28r4.jpg


12034394_992856650736971_7406137575546783121_o_zpswhpzoiuc.jpg


12182737_992869780735658_8219495465742092414_o_zpswwskgkrc.jpg



.
 
Last edited:
Wow Brian. Great write up and I especially liked your response to Comprehensivist as you explain the history and purpose. Did you do the drawing or is that something Dylan Fletcher did based on your ideas? That is an excellent drawing. No CAD stuff.... just an old fashion pencil drawing.

I do think it is an excellent substitute for a hatchet or small axe.

Anyway, I enjoyed this write up and the pictures. That is one heck of a blade. It pretty much is a high end short machete (but more) with the 15" overall length.

The photos overall are fantastic. I guess you shot that with an DSLR as a video and then grab the individual images. Very cool.

I haven't cut enough bamboo to really get a sense if the knife cuts normal trees such as we have here in East TN and the Southeast. But the shots with the oak tree (I believe) demonstrate the chopping ability.

How was the edge (sharpness) after testing?
 
Last edited:
Wow Brian. Great write up and I especially liked your response to Comprehensivist as you explain the history and purpose. Did you do the drawing or is that something Dylan Fletcher did based on your ideas? That is an excellent drawing. No CAD stuff.... just an old fashion pencil drawing.

I do think it is an excellent substitute for a hatchet or small axe.

Anyway, I enjoyed this write up and the pictures. That is one heck of a blade. It pretty much is a high end short machete (but more) with the 15" overall length.

The photos overall are fantastic. I guess you shot that with an DSLR as a video and then grab the individual images. Very cool.

I haven't cut enough bamboo to really get a sense if the knife cuts normal trees such as we have here in East TN and the Southeast. But the shots with the oak tree (I believe) demonstrate the chopping ability.

How was the edge (sharpness) after testing?

Thanks man. I did the original drawing, more of a rough sketch, of the overall shape and elements I wanted in the knife. Then Dylan refined it to the working drawing to suit his style of knife making.

I think so too, and while I wanted a weight forward design and some reach, here in the south a hatchet can be very limited in functionality for me. A longer blade serves me better in more uses.

Thank you, actually those were all still shots taken on a rainy day with crappy lighting. Andrew and I plan to get together again on a day with better light :)

Bamboo is a good test material here in my opinion. It can be very hard in the colder months.

So far the edge is doing very well, I haven't sharpened it yet, but I probably will before I attack the bamboo again :)
 
Brian, great shots as always. Always love your threads.

So Dylan... how bout a run of Griffin Xs?
 
This is one of the greatest threads EVARRRR!

I'm going back to Andrew's this weekend, to work on a project. Apparently he wan'ts to play with the X more when it isn't raining and muddy. He was very complimentary of your work earlier today :)
 
Last edited:
I'd be willing to bet that Dylan had a big grin on his face crafting this one Brian!
Great writeup and pics as usual.
 
I'd be willing to bet that Dylan had a big grin on his face crafting this one Brian!
Great writeup and pics as usual.

I've had the opportunity to watch Dylan grind blades a few times and you are probably right there. Ethan saw it on a trip I made to his house a couple of months ago, and then played with it more this last gathering, smiling the whole time. Apparently it is one of my designs that he gives his 110% approval to :) I love what happens when Dylan takes one of my sketches and the subsequent discussion, and then brings the design to life. I can't wait for the next one, I will actually be able to carry in regularly, and in public even :D
 
You should call it the budget buster 'cause I can't afford one right now. :D

Awesome design, even better execution. Dylan seems like one of those mercurial artisan types. Without the patchouli.
 
You should call it the budget buster 'cause I can't afford one right now. :D

Awesome design, even better execution. Dylan seems like one of those mercurial artisan types. Without the patchouli.

Lol, with him pricing them at $350, the last I heard anyway, he is already trying to make them as affordable as he can for a handmade knife of this size and one of his awesome sheaths.

Dylan is awesome. He is as much fun to work with as he is to talk to. He has an uncanny ability to translate data and design functionality into blade profile and geometry very smoothly. He is one of a handful of knife makers I know who grasps so much of the overall function of blades from small ones to large ones. He is one of a few I know who is so anal about the quality of the work he produces. Then he is one of even fewer whose tools I will trust with my life in the middle of nowhere. I've hung out with him a few times, and watched him get into his work. It would take a lot of patchouli to mask the scent of all the steel and handle material dust :D
 
Back
Top