Spyderco Aqua Salt Review

Joined
Oct 5, 2006
Messages
3,124
Spyderco Aqua Salt Review - Part 1

attachment.php


Introduction

I received a Spyderco Aqua as part of a pass around here along with a Ladybug 3 Salt: http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=761145. The Aqua Salt is the first Spyderco fixed blade I’ve handled. It comes in your choice of black or marine yellow fiberglass reinforced nylon (FRN) handles, an H1 rustproof steel blade, and either plain or serrated (SpyderEdge) blade. It also comes with a very nicely made injection molded FRN sheath. The MSRP is $119.95 and our favorite online retailers sell it for about $72.

The Aqua Salt is a good sized knife -- bigger than any Spyderco folder other than the Military. Here is how it compares to the some of our favorite fixed blades.

attachment.php


I don't have many fixed blades, so here's a visual comparison to some popular Spyderco folders. If I had to describe the Aqua Salt in one sentence, I'd say: "It's a fixed blade Endura." This photo may give you that sense:

attachment.php

attachment.php


Blade

Like all Spyderco "Salt" series knives, the Aqua‘s blade is made from H1, which I understand to be a type of ceramic. My own experience with H1 consists of about two years with a Spyderco Tasman Salt and then a Spyderco Atlantic Salt. They have seen extensive use in both fresh and salt water and I have never seen any corrosion.

Both of my Salts have a plain edge along the first 10-15% of the blade, followed by 85-90% SpyderEdge serrations. The plain-edged tip is useful for detail work. The serrations have never needed sharpening, but I’ve touched up the plain-edged section and found it easier to sharpen than VG-10 or S30V. My unscientific assessment of H1 is that it doesn’t hold an edge as well as the top steels, but holds its own vs AUS 8, AUS 6, 440C, etc. The Aqua Salt 3 came typically Spyderco sharp and I would expect similar corrosion and edge-retention performance to what I’ve experienced. There are some reports that H1 actually hardens with use. Ed Schempp from Spyderco writes about that here: http://www.byrdknife.com/forums/showthread.php?t=23639
and here: http://www.spyderco.com/forums/showthread.php?t=23741

The blade tang extends 3/4 of the way into the handle (as shown in postings below) and feels sturdy. The hollow ground blade is also relatively thick. A swedge is cut near the tip, reducing weight and increasing penetrating power. It wouldn't be a Spyderco without the hole, so a small one is milled near the end of the blade where it meets the handle. It might be useful with a lanyard, I suppose, or tying the blade to a shaft for a makeshift spear.

The serrations on the Aqua Salt are shallower than those on other SpyderEdge knives and provide more of a sawtooth profile than say, my Pacific Salt. In field use, I found the edge to work very well as a functional saw. It made short work of some woody weeds. This photo shows a Pacific Salt blade on top of the Aqua Salt.

attachment.php
 
Last edited:
Spyderco Aqua Salt Review - Part 2

attachment.php

attachment.php


Handle

The Aqua Salt feels great in the hand. It is just the right size and width and contoured just the right way. One of the complaints sometimes heard about Spyderco folders is that the handles are too thin. That isn't the case with this fixed blade. It gives you plenty to grab and the bi-directional texturing makes it non-slip. The high visability yellow handles are also a plus -- though they can get dirty pretty quickly. Non knife people seem to react better to yellow handled "tool" knives and they are easier to find when dropped. I once grounded my WaveRunner and my Tasman Salt fell out of my pocket unnoticed. I happened to spot it under three feet of seawater, though. I don't think that would have happened with tactical black.

attachment.php


Ergonomics & Use

The supplied sheath is nice. It looks good with clean edges and an embossed Spyder logo. The "G" clip is repositionable and holds securely to a belt or straps or waistband. The blade locks in place with a positive click and I can't imagine it falling out by accident. Since I have an office job, my carry time on the Aqua Salt has been limited to after hours use. I had it with me this weekend when I was changing the battery on my lawn tractor and dropped a wrench across both battery contacts. The insulated Aqua Salt handle was useful in moving the wrench without touching the contacts -- something I couldn't have done with most of my folders. When I had cutting chores, I was always surprised that the Aqua Salt was so sharp -- for some reason it doesn't look sharp to me. My perception might be colored by having handled several dull "dive" knives in the past.

Conclusions

The Aqua Salt is made in Seki, Japan. The fit and finish is very good. As you might expect with a fixed blade, there is no preceptible bladeplay. The hollowed ground blade looks perfect, and the handle is well finished. I wrote above that the Aqua Salt is a fixed blade Endura. Another description might be that it's a modern version of the Mora knife. Much like the Spyderco Endura is sometimes called the modern version of the Buck 110, the Aqua Salt improves on a classic. Where the Mora is the classic fishing, hunting, and workingman's outdoor knife, the Aqua Salt provides a more ergonomic, grippier handle and corrosion free steel. There are heavier duty knives, but few with utility to weight ratio you get with the Aqua Salt.

Thanks to Sal Glesser, Joyce Laituri and the folks at Spyderco, plus BladeForums and Frank K. for putting the pass-around together and letting me handle the knife. I'll report back in a few days with final conclusions.

attachment.php
 
Last edited:
wish i had one of those a coupal years back. we had about 8 small sharks to clean & even my electric knife was bogging down. shark skin is tough as fiberglass. if i start spending more time at the coast i'm going to get one of these knives.
dennis
 
Thanks for another outstanding review!

My impressions of the Aqua Salt is hat it is a very solid feeling knife and a little heavier than I expected. I don't know how far back the tang goes, but from the feel of it I would guess at least half way. I found the handle comfortable, but a bit on the small side for someone with big hands. The blade/serrations really did seem to cut well.


The yellow handles is great for use around water, as you mentioned. In fact If I remember right yellow is the color of the spectrum that can be seen the farthest through water.

I think the sheath is not Kydex or the like, but injection molded FRN of some sort.


Dennis, I think that the Aqua would be a great knife for cutting up sharks! I remember cutting up some sand sharks for bait and the skin was like leather sand paper.


If anyone is interested in getting the Aqua Salt, now is the time to do it since it is on the discontinued list for 2011.
 
Thanks for the review and pictures!

I got the plain edge version to check out recently and it is a great knife. When I first held it, it was lighter than I thought it'd be lol. If I remember correctly, the tang does go 1/3 to 1/2 of the way into the handle...pretty sure there is a pic on here somewhere or possibly the spyderco site.

EDIT: For your viewing pleasure:
attachment.php


Seems it is almost 3/4 of the way! Even better.
 
Well done! Wonderful photos also.

Anyone ever contemplate a flotation lanyard for one of these?
 
Well done! Wonderful photos also.

Anyone ever contemplate a flotation lanyard for one of these?

Do they make any that are strong enough to float this knife without being huge? The buoy looking ones come to mind, though they can be bulky. Another idea is to simply tether it to you, though that presents it's own problems.
 
Do they make any that are strong enough to float this knife without being huge? The buoy looking ones come to mind, though they can be bulky. Another idea is to simply tether it to you, though that presents it's own problems.

I would assume that those foam floats they use on boat keys would do the trick...this thing only weighs 4.2 ounces!

It might be a PITA, but someone out there ought to be able to incorporate such a thing into a cool lanyard?
 
Thanks for the review and pictures!

I got the plain edge version to check out recently and it is a great knife. When I first held it, it was lighter than I thought it'd be lol. If I remember correctly, the tang does go 1/3 to 1/2 of the way into the handle...pretty sure there is a pic on here somewhere or possibly the spyderco site.

EDIT: For your viewing pleasure:
attachment.php


Seems it is almost 3/4 of the way! Even better.

Thanks much for posting the pic of the tang! That's about the length of tang I imagined going by balance/feel. I thought the Aqua felt slightly more handle heavy and solid than a Mora Clipper and other Spyderco fixed blades with molded FRN handles such as the Moran and Temperance 1, which (I think?) have shorter tangs.


I forgot to mention that I really like the Aqua's smaller serration pattern since it seems to have all of the cutting power of larger serrations, but cuts much smoother without snagging.
 
Thanks much for posting the pic of the tang! That's about the length of tang I imagined going by balance/feel. I thought the Aqua felt slightly more handle heavy and solid than a Mora Clipper and other Spyderco fixed blades with molded FRN handles such as the Moran and Temperance 1, which (I think?) have shorter tangs.


I forgot to mention that I really like the Aqua's smaller serration pattern since it seems to have all of the cutting power of larger serrations, but cuts much smoother without snagging.

No problem. I haven't handled any Spyderco fixed blades other than the Temperance II and the Aqua Salt. As far as the tang on those goes, I definitely don't recall reading/seeing anything on that.

Didn't even notice that the serration pattern was smaller. Though that does seem like it'd be a plus.
 
Here are X rays of a mora clipper and a temperance 1 posted by Franco G on the Spyderco forum:

tempereance_mora_Xrayed.jpg
 
I understand that Sal Glesser has indicated that the Aqua Salt will be re-released soon with a black coated blade. It was posted both on BF & Spyderco forums somewhere. I will be in for at least one of these for sure and perhaps two (PE & SE). :thumbup::congratulatory::applouse::triumphant::glee:

Wow what a lot of emoticon selection! Nice!
 
Please let there be a re-release. I've been looking for an Aqua for so long my eyes hurt. I prefer the yellow frn but would take any configuration I could find if I could just find one.
I sure hope Sal does it. I'm in for 3 or 4 of them if he does.
 
Don't mean to reopen this thread a year later but I was considering buying one for diving and gutting fish. it appears to be a good knife for water enthusiasts.
 
Diving? Check
Rustproof? Check
Sharp? Check
Great sheath? Check

CAM02751_zpsqx4qaxbd.jpg


Lightweight? Check
Excellent grip? Check
Cutting power? Check
Stabby and pointy? Check

CAM02018_zps9tmi4exy.jpg
 
Thanks glad to see you are still on this thread and especially that you like these knives. There were a few negative reviews on the sheath that it apparently dulls the straight edge blade. Other then that they only had good things to say about the knife.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top