Survive! Knives GSO Necker II - Photo-heavy review with a couple comparisons

chiral.grolim

Universal Kydex Sheath Extension
Joined
Dec 2, 2008
Messages
6,422
Survive! Knives GSO Necker II - Review and Comparison with photos


Guy Seiferd's neck-knife design was originally released as a minimal cutting tool with a stout little sheepsfoot ring-blade and short tang to which a lanyard would be strapped for higher retention:

Y9yHK6JVAAPGHmMDbNKzSDU8h2Ag6ZLcQ5Dyl9HLulM=w1105-h758-no

9e4MB0HCt4bD_653sY8cv5DaFhHbmIbv4yValTcs1Wo=w569-h758-no

at-eeJF1G03_zCORthGtJrMdpkVTGlRkn7jK8E8FU_M=w1012-h758-no


That design was modified slightly and is still available from the S!K website: http://surviveknives.com/knives/gso-series/necker.html


Popular demand was for a full-handle version of the knife, the Necker II: http://surviveknives.com/knives/gso-series/necker-ii.html

P1020268.JPG

P1020264.JPG

P1020271.JPG


Specs:
Length: 2.25" Blade (tip to choil cutting edge) + 0.15" choil + 4.12" Handle = ~6.5" OAL
Blade Width: 0.5" saber-flat + 0.83" flat primary bevel + 0.04" edge bevel = 1.37" above the choil, dropping to the point.
Thickness: 0.156" stock down 4.5dps to 0.025" edge bevel, ~20dps
Handle width/thickness: 0.6" x ~1" palm, ring-hole 1.15 x 0.95. Skeletonized tang with hidden lanyard hole.
Blade material: Crucible CPM-20CV hardened/tempered to 58-59 Rc by Peter's Heat Treat, stonewashed finish.
Handles: rough canvas micarta (other options available)
Weight: 3.45 oz, 5.15 with sheath

At 0.156" stock thickness and 0.025" edge thickness, this is a stout little knife! Like a cut-down version of the GSO-4.1. The thick spine does provide plenty of platform for a lot of thumb pressure, it features the same well-done jimping - series of 1/16" valleys and plateaus - that provide excellent traction without being uncomfortable, and thickness is maintained to within an inch of the tip, providing a lot of strength for prying.

P1020265.JPG

P1020270.JPG

P1020267.JPG


Finishing along the spine/belly was smoother on this knife than any other GSO I've recieved, the cutting-marks only visible within the ring. The edges of the spine and ring are slightly rounded for comfort :thumbup: so you won't be striking your firesteel without a dedicated scraper.

The ring is more comfortable than might be expected, plenty large for even my heavy work gloves, though I admit to being unaccustomed to such a design, prefering my middle and index fingers to make full contact and to have more material under my index finger for control. But the ring does add a measure of security - as an integral guard, no way your finger is slipping onto the blade ;) and you can also let go the handle to use your fingers for other activities such as tying rope in a knot or tugging at the innards of an animal being dressed, etc. The sheepsfoot blade isn't designed for piercing but works quite well for gutting and skinning with its dramatic drop-point and that slight belly-curve :thumbup:

s8fFK9AY_91_EgnIhbH5ey_Obebrp9EDFL0PsxgMIOw=w678-h758-no

P1020309.JPG

I4wiX2ClZygZ4LbzwEFVE2rJS3-_JEXrmhu0qS4WFKU=w512-h757-no

jYiGEUHpn8SF2CAGikmMU0asISDQt2tuj82g7K8Rgco=w530-h758-no

-AWEvcGhaag8VgM7UxYjPsjiAO03tdKbKiXQz_KDmYg=w1014-h758-no

gtiuFLFv9OkoTUCfYbATO53cT_KmlKQ7kziaoSGMXqs=w619-h758-no


The rough micarta handle scales are well affixed with aligned screw-heads (another Survive! trademark? :cool: ) and the surface provides excellent traction in wet or dry conditions. The scales are surprisingly well designed, providing added thickness at the spine and contoured around the ring to distribute pressure and aid in indexing and control. :thumbup::thumbup:
This thickness is maintained as the handle curves into the pocket of the hand, ends with a well-rounded pommel. This time there is no heel-flare to cause discomfort as on the GSO-4.1. The handle returns to the index-ring with a similar curve but is tapered along the belly so the last two fingers can more easily grasp the end, then it widens to full thickness for the middle-finger seated just below the ring. This is a reeaaly well thought-out handle. Even the nibs just below the blade are well-designed - curved for comfort and still thick enough to provide a platform for your fingers in a forward pinch-grip. The design accommodates numerous hand positions beyond simple use of the ring. The knife balances casually on the middle-finger grooves just below the ring.

P1020269.JPG

ayRfcex9yg-g-IVA3TcxsCLNTXZ1GaIBjKsxEKuNQbQ=w689-h758-no

Bkv46IVYQqyfztw8brawRB_AQMdmoqnAeyEIC-stgl0=w1278-h668-no


The steel is CPM-20CV, Crucible's version of M390, with 1.9% Carbon and 4% Vanadium along with 1% molybdenum and 0.6% tungsten for carbides, 20% chromium to pick up the rest and offer excellent corrosion resistance besides. S!K lists the steel as hardened to 58-59Rc which may be a bit soft but they do use Peter's HT who are well respected for what they do. Ankerson here on bladeforums put similar M390 through is edge-retention regime: http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/s...based-on-Edge-Retention-cutting-5-8-quot-rope

Needless to type, this is "high-end" steel.

NeckerII%2Bsteel%2Bchart.jpg


The sheath:
Once again kydex-bender Kiah proves to be an asset to be Survive! Knives. I consider his work second to none. The sheath is constructed of 0.093" kydex with a seamless 'pancake' design and chamfered edges for comfort, is ambidextrous with a multi-positionable MOLLE-compatible G-clip for attachment to a 2" belt (or less) or pocket, waist-band, gear-webbing, etc.

P1020261.JPG

P1020259.JPG

P1020262.JPG

P1020263.JPG


The sheath is well formed for a VERY secure fit. One criticism - you may want to route-out the mouth a bit to accept the blade more easily when re-sheathing. There is absolutely no rattle and no fear of the knife coming loose without a deliberate tug. Enough of the ring is left exposed to make for easy deployment, a thumbramp is incorporated for further facilitation. It features a small 'weep-hole' on either side for moisture and cleaning but is otherwise maintenance free and very durable. The slots allow not only alternate positioning of the clip but also use of straps, cord, a tek-lok or an extension, etc. Or you can remove the clip and use the provided break-away bead-chain for neck-carry. Again, for the price it is hard to find a better built, better designed sheath :thumbup::thumbup:

CpkS_V1HX1J0nEDW2RbpXze4veOHYUhhI8LomFR8jXg=w723-h758-no

P1020282.JPG

P1020284.JPG

P1020291.JPG

P1020292.JPG

P1020295.JPG

P1020297.JPG

P1020300.JPG

AtXeXC9o21qT6yUJSrQ6J-BZyDffZ6na_hXmsfGs0U4=w612-h758-no

tP5L5OYtu2k_XWLl1PPzpJx57v9u66Qba0yQYkWiJtg=w438-h758-no


With the extension piece I make that fits all Survive! knives:
rQzJSgsRjph78uh4j0o7Y2M4yqHIoh0CMs4qL34inQ8=w569-h758-no

26mi7bwcNU3HpUTtkuL7rnKC3d3fJcc5q0VOOEO5pGk=w683-h758-no

EPEJM0SYIgOUC3CUiro2HmVSBLgap_pwZUXQN34Jr8M=w523-h758-no


On a Maxpedition Sitka (among the most versatile packs on the market, imho :thumbup:):
IjhaTyWqrIJkKrzjxm2whEZNQKVY3o2yYtnWTsLH0Ic=w767-h758-no

gKCN4lUsCoNMXU9QWQSk0HxQouehRuzv063dpnmMGAo=w600-h758-no

ohQiqjG53i6MyNzF6mwaENipXupUd3JrbAwalbdNdHk=w1278-h683-no

be6l8oahYCDk0h_vY2Uapju3lLP6Z2T_Bs3VIub7D8I=w709-h758-no


The Necker II costs ~$145 (including shipping) right now, with a variety of sheath and handle-scale options/upgrades. This is not an inexpensive knife, but it shows in the design, materials, construction, and even the sheath. It is a tough knife built to handle rough outdoor use while requiring little in the way of maintenance in any environment. It also has a rather unique look...
 
Let's compare this knife to a couple others of similar size: ESEE Izula and Benchmade H&K Plan D

CJmvxjip0Z3i5xrAeBHVNi1GIlWcptBslrmOv0ZlMIo=w780-h758-no

P1020302.JPG


The ESEE Izula is approximately the same stock thickness as the GSO. The Izula tapers more to the point but remains slightly thicker behind the edge (~0.030") - still a "beefy" little knife. Designed as a 'neck-knife' the short profile and scale-less skeletonized tang bring it to a mere 2 oz naked. The thick stock provides a nice surface for applying thumb-pressure behind the blade which is great since the blade is thick and the durable coating creates such drag that it takes a LOT of force to make a deep cut. I took the shoulders of the edge on this Izula to improve cutting performance and it holds up well.

P1020311.JPG

7q9XspgYN0hpRMoRN_f-YPEyBV1CoCdZb79oR9RgLJs=w593-h758-no

P1020303.JPG

X-5hrgWbw10zYTyIFCBJisRxaPSYIv87fRM-m1R6v4c=w648-h758-no


At 6.25" OAL, the Izula is slightly shorter than the GSO but also features more cutting edge (~2.63") in the sweeping belly of the drop-point design. The handle is a little too short for a full 4-finger grip in 'medium' hands but the rounded tang prevents discomfort in the pocket of the hand. ESEE offers the Izula II with slightly longer handle if you need more leverage, equalling the GSO, though I prefer the short model for this blade length. They also offer micarta scales for more width. Even the simple shoe-string wrap on mine provides sufficient comfort for light cutting and shallow carving. The Izula II comes standard with micarta scales and is ~1/4" longer overall than the GSO, weighs in at ~3.2oz (1/4oz less than the GSO).

P1010445.JPG

P1010441.JPG

P1010442.JPG

P1010443.JPG

P1010439.JPG

P1010434.JPG


Like the GSO, there isn't much blade on the Izula, but the knife is well designed in the orientation of blade to handle. It has a forward cant such that, with the handle settled in the pocket of your hand, the blade leans over your index fingers to meet the material to be cut, transfering resistance right into the pocket of your hand so that leverage from the wrist is less necessary. Again, the thick geometry certainly increases that resistance to penetration, but the blade's forward lean makes it easier to overcome, less fatiguing. The thick coating gives decent traction for one's thumb, and there is also rounded jimping that not only prevents a slip but also doesn't eat your hand like a Spyderco or other designs.

The Izula features and small sharpening notch at the choil and a 3/16" ricasso that forms an integral guard under which the handle is grooved back.

Made of simple 1095 spring steel @ <57Rc, it is a tough little knife to meet ESEE's lifetime replacement warranty. It won't have the apex-strength or anything approaching the wear-resistance of the GSO, the thick coating makes it an inferior slicer (naked models won't suffer from that), but its light-weight and slim design along with classic drop-point blade with a full flat grind grant it the qualities against which other 'neck' knives should be judged. I am a fan of the Izula, a good option for those who want a smaller knife with a more traditional design than the GSO (or can't stand the ring).

The Izula factory sheath is injection-molded plastic, of quite decent but very much inferior design to that of the GSO.

The Izula II costs ~$60, the Izula II ~$80 with a few different coating-color options, and after-market sheaths and scales available for added cost that can push the price higher for a tough, well-designed, reliable little knife of simple steel that is easy to resharpen. It is suitable for a variety of tasks, from whittling to skinning.


P1020313.JPG

bV77xEtiDq_BwLH6jYEDGh9Kw3L5hrYGhhKB7_Krdnw=w452-h758-no


The H&K Plan D is, to be honest, more what I expected the GSO Necker II to be like. The Plan D is small (only 5.65" OAL, a three-finger knife), light-weight (2.4oz, 4.2 w/ sheath) and thin - 0.114" stock ground full-flat across 0.88" width down to 0.015" behind the edge, < 15dps to the apex. That 0.114" gives enough lateral strength for most utility work and the 0.015" edge is excellent, ~2X thinner than the other two, providing much higher slicing performance than the Izula or GSO along its 2.25" straight-edge. True to the Wharncliffe design, it features no belly sweep and tapers along the full length of the blade, although the point features a flat 'clip' rather than a curved descent. It has a beautiful grind with a sharp point for detail work and easy piercing (superior to either the GSO or Izula) but not so strong for drilling/prying.

y_Z3a_rCBtmq4mz2WbhWdWWspKxvAc8DSxMxHeMdebg=w577-h758-no

GnKw3Lz8Vnig8Azp47Jn5o8JPYdtva4IGUttOV_Y-nQ=w614-h757-no

MaQFEPrHEaREeu0Kyr3tGlqqTUx44WcUo4yTJIQvxI0=w572-h758-no


This is not a woodcraft knife nor is it a kitchen knife, it was clearly design for self-defense / tactical use but would make an excellent shop/utility blade. Above the well-countoured 3"-long grivory (plastic) scales (which are pretty well textured, providing good retention and no discomfort to bare hands), the blade is canted ~45 degrees with a section of wide thumb-jimping for added traction (and again reasonably comfortable, 1/8" valleys and plateaus). This forward lean aids in stabbing and slashing, whether held with a standard 'hammer' grip or inverted like a karambit.

The Plan D features a 5/32" choil to aid full-grinding of the blade, but it also features an integral guard that protrudes ~1/8" from the blade-edge like a lot of Spydercos. The index-groove is slightly smaller than the GSO's ring, and the corners of the spine/guard/tang are all relatively sharp - nice for stroking a ferro-rod but not so nice for bare fingers, especially in the index groove :thumbdown: The scales are also not quite flush with the tang, corners exposed along the perimeter. That typed, the handle is well contoured and fits naturally in the hand. The large ricasso and guard aid in how the blade sits in the sheath.

The sheath is listed by Benchmade as molded kydex. It is thin and light with relatively low retention to aid in quick-draw for self-defense (presumably). However it is very wide for its blade and the metal clip is likewise wide, not something for IWB or discreet carry, certainly not a neck-sheath. The clip securely holds 2.3" belt or a strap or waist-band. The clip is versible, but cannot be rotated.

The Plan D's N680 steel features a lot less carbon than CPM-20CV or 1095 (0.54% vs 1.9% and 0.95%) and almost no vanadium but has a touch of molybdenum (same as 20CV) and sufficient chromium for decent abrasion-resistance (~154CM level) and nitrogen to free more of that chromium for corrosion resistance. It won't hold it's edge as long as the GSO's 20CV but will beat out the Izula's 1095 any day of the week, and being almost 2X thinner behind the edge is a pleasure to slice with compared to the other two :thumbup::thumbup:
The coating is pretty decent as well - thin and relatively slick while quite durable (scratch-resistant).

The Benchmade Plan D costs ~$55, again there may be aftermarket scales & sheaths at additional cost.



Comparing the design of these knives...
The Benchmade is most suitable as a utility/shop knife as well as a self-defense tool, with fine-grained steel and good slicing geometry, very light weight. But it isn't meant as a neck-knife or for outdoor activities or 'survival'. I wouldn't want to process a chicken much less a deer with this knife.
The 3-finger Izula is most suitable as a neck-knife being more compact, and it is designed for outdoor use. I wouldn't hesitate to use it for processing livestock or game, though the shoe-string handle would soon need replacing ;). It's a simple knife of simple steel, kinda pricey for the make-up but reliable and with a strong warranty.
The Necker II works better as a pocket/belt knife for me, but can be neck-carry. Fit & finish of the GSO is excellent as usual, even moreso with the polished perimeter. The knife came face-shaving sharp (video below) and ready to use. The 20CV will hold its edge through abrasive cutting for a long time, and it sharpens-up with relative ease on diamonds or ceramic carbide. It held its edge well through cardboard, rope, wood-carving, processing a rooster, and even cutting apart an old can. The hardest task for it was whittling - the thick spine provides a lot of platform for thumb-pressure, but I prefer more handle beneath my index finger, and the thick edge doesn't penetrate all that well, which also hampers slicing performance htough Guy maks up for that by sending his knives out with a well-refined edge :thumbup:. Bring that edge down a few thousandths of an inch and performance will jump even more. :thumbup:

Is the GSO worth the high price over the Izula or H&K? Given the superior materials, construction, design, sheath, finish - there is no question that this is a quality piece of work meant to be relied upon, like all Survive! knives. The added costs are easily found there, "you get what you pay for". This particular GSO will not appeal to all, but I thought it worthy of a review. Thanks for reading and please comment.


nHeb4Jjn2HN2BmZrNosKE0dsevGtNoAQv-OFOjfedAo=w1278-h723-no

P1020345.JPG

P1020348.JPG

P1020448.JPG

P1020451.JPG

P1020453.JPG


Video Uploads

[video=youtube;cVhPCqPR05Q]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cVhPCqPR05Q[/video]

[video=youtube;O-z66ajgeCo]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O-z66ajgeCo[/video]
 
Excellent review, very through!!! Thanks for taking the time and effect to put this together :thumbup::thumbup:
 
It's an interesting design for sure. Haven't made up my mind if I want one yet though. Thanks for the review.
 
Great pics and useful info. Especially like the in-hand photos and wish every knife review did that :)
My necker 2 was just shipped. Looks like a useful, high-quality tool.
 
Very nice job. I enjoyed reading. That Guy Seiferd is a class act. I caught him on the phone one day. I now own a GSO 4.1 in a very limited S90V he had some steel for.
 
Really great review. Any chance of top down and bottom up shots of the handle so we can see the contouring? That sounds interesting, the way you described it.
 
Really great review. Any chance of top down and bottom up shots of the handle so we can see the contouring? That sounds interesting, the way you described it.

There's a pic near the top of the pag looking down at the spine, the back-pocket pic may give the best view up from the belly, and there are a bunch of different angles featured in the photos i took... I hope something in there helps to illustrate what I'm trying to describe...
 
Impressive review. If I didn't already own one, It may have influenced my decision. I love mine. My original Necker is now relegated to the drawer. It's a great little knife. I don't own many neck knives, but read another review somewhere that called it an Izula Killer. I wouldn't know for myself, because I was never impressed enough by reviews of the Izula to get one. As for the HK. Haven't considered it. I may need to take a look at it now. Thanks!

Ryan
 
Impressive review. If I didn't already own one, It may have influenced my decision. I love mine. My original Necker is now relegated to the drawer. It's a great little knife. I don't own many neck knives, but read another review somewhere that called it an Izula Killer. I wouldn't know for myself, because I was never impressed enough by reviews of the Izula to get one. As for the HK. Haven't considered it. I may need to take a look at it now. Thanks!

Ryan

Great review. Thank you.

Thanks for reading. I should note that it has come to my attention that Survive! is currently offering these at 20% discount to move current inventory and begin production on new models while they finish up previous orders, so the final price on their site is only ~$83. If you're thinking about getting one of these, NOW is the time.
 
Very impressed with the substantial review; went much further than I expected, and looked at some competition also. I can't think of anything that you've left out. Your little girl was the BEST.
Thanks for the review. I love S!K and have had several, GSO 3.5 and 4.1, but not this one...yet.
 
I've been looking for a neck knife to wear while I'm on patrol as a leo. Mostly as a last ditch defensive blade. Is this easily concealed under a shirt?
 
I've been looking for a neck knife to wear while I'm on patrol as a leo. Mostly as a last ditch defensive blade. Is this easily concealed under a shirt?

The handle is rather thick and full 4-finger length, it is also hard micarta or G10, not very comfortable nor discreet under a shirt hanging from your neck unless you hung it under your arm-pit as shown in the neck-carry pics. I would prefer the Benchmade Plan D or some other knife altogether for such carry, the Izula also isn't very discrete. A better alternative would be to conceal the knife NOT around your neck but under your shirt at the waste as shown in one of the other pics. The smaller benchmade is more easily concealed here as well, but all 3 could work. Is there a reason it would need to be around your neck?
 
I have no room on my duty belt and policy says no fixed blades so it would need to be hidden anyway. Neck carry seems like a good place.
 
Thanks for the great review! I own a bunch of NIIs as well as an Izula 2, a number of folders and I also own a bunch of high end 3" and 4" knives and I consistently reach for the NII for every day, around the house cutting chores. I agree that it's not a great knife to whittle with but it cuts cardboard, cordage, carpet and packing materials like butter. It would be cool to see it how it does skinning a deer. Now I've got them in my car, in all of my packs and around the house. It makes such a great companion to the GSO 4.1, 5, 5.1 or equivalently sized knives. Anyway it's one of my favorite knives.
 
Back
Top