The Dairy-Maids of Porter Brook (Part 2)

Jack Black

Seize the Lambsfoot! Seize the Day!
Platinum Member
Joined
Dec 2, 2005
Messages
69,126


Part 1 (read this first ;)): http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showthread.php/1229530-The-Dairy-Maids-of-Porter-Brook-(Part-1)





The great poet Chaucer has praised Sheffield whittles,
For without knives and forks, how could folk eat their victuals?
As for our penknives, extensive our trade is,
Likewise our scissors, they’re praised by the ladies;
Our razors long time abroad famous have been,
Like our women and wit, they’re bright but they’re keen,
The bounty of nature on Sheffield town smiles,
Yet could other trades work if we did not make files?


(from The Cutler’s Song, 18th century Sheffield ballad)​




Today, Endcliffe Park (formerly known as Endcliffe Woods) is one of Sheffield’s most popular public recreation spaces. It is also one of the oldest, opened in 1887 to commemorate the Jubilee of Queen Victoria, in whose memory there is both a statue and monument in the park, as well as a large commemorative stone. Long before it was a park though, men came here to work at the water-wheels that once stood along the banks of the River Porter as it flows towards the centre of Sheffield, and its eventual confluence with the River Sheaf.





The Porter enters the park close to the end of Rustlings Road, under which the river flows. After only a few yards, there is an old weir, and the remains of the inlet sluice of the first dam can clearly be seen. When the park was being developed, this pond was designated for water-fowl, and islands were added to make it more scenic and allow the birds to nest. It was formerly the dam of the old Nether Spurgear Wheel (also known as Third Endcliffe Wheel or Greystones Wheel), constructed by John Ibberson in 1749. By 1794 Joseph Ibberson was employing ten grinders, and the cutlery wheel had ten trows. In 1802, the wheel was sold to a filesmith called Daniel Bramall, who enlarged the dam. Despite taking on two partners, Bramall was declared bankrupt in 1824, and the wheel was bought by Thomas Sansom & Sons, an already well-established Sheffield cutlery firm with a Royal Warrant, producing pen and pocket knives, table cutlery, and razors. By 1830, Sansom & Sons had enlarged the wheel and had seventeen trows.

However in 1833, with Thomas Sansom in his seventies, and presumably more or less retired (he was to die three years later), there was a family dispute. Amid considerable acrimony, Thomas Sansom & Sons continued to exist in a reduced form, with eldest son William in competition as W.Sansom & Co, and disputing the ongoing use of the company name by his brothers.

In 1838, only two years after his father, Abraham, the middle Sansom brother died, and in the 1840’s, the surviving brother, John, was joined in partnership by George Howson (who had been an apprentice cutler to the firm since 1803, and later a merchant’s clerk) and James William Harrison. When George Howson died in1847, his son William took over his business interests, and in 1849, Sansom & Sons was wound up. Its assets became the basis for the great Sheffield cutlery firm of Harrison Brothers & Howson, under William Howson and James William and Henry Harrison. The partners made vast fortunes, living in huge mansions on the edge of the city. When Henry Harrison died aged 68 in 1892 he left £123,938, and when his brother James passed on at 80, five years later, he left the sum of £239,675. This was at the time when an ordinary grinder might consider himself lucky to earn £2 a week, and probably not live long into his thirties.



In 1859, along with the other Endcliffe Wheels, the Nether Spurgear Wheel was sold by Harrison Brothers & Howson to Robert Younge, a wine merchant. By 1875, Younge’s nephew, Francis Otter, owned the wheel, and while it was still in good working order, it was not used after this date. The long attractive dam is well-loved by the local people, and the ducks and other water-fowl are invariably well-fed throughout the year.



A quarter of a mile downsteam, there is another weir, with the remains of the sluice-gate, and the head goit of what was once the dam of the Holme Wheel (also sometimes referred to as the Leather Wheel). The wheel was constructed by a cutler called Isaac Staniforth around 1729, and originally had four trows. In 1769, Johnathan Hall rebuilt and enlarged the wheel, and by 1794 it was running eleven trows, with George Naylor as tenant. By 1801, the wheel had grown to sixteen trows, with George Oates tenanted here. The Carr family bought the wheel in 1811, and in 1831, it was sold to Thomas Sansom. The wheel was by this time running seventeen trows. A head of water of seventeen feet and six inches turned the wheel, which was four feet and nine inches wide.









In 1849, Harrison Brothers & Howson took over the wheel, and the ownership subsequently passed to Robert Younge, and then Francis Otter, just as the Upper Spurgear Wheel. By 1891 the wheel was no longer in use, and after the area was acquired by Sheffield Corporation, the dam was turned into a boating lake and designated for ice-skating. I remember the boats myself, and though I’ve never seen anyone skating on the pond, I have walked on its frozen surface several times as a boy.









I have a reminder of the steps up to the dam in the form of a substantial scar on my right wrist, acquired when I fell while carrying a glass jar while on a school environmental studies trip. Close by, near to where the grinding hull once stood, an old woman used to come once a year with a giant set of weighing scales. You sat in a chair, and for the price of a penny she would tell you your weight.

















The river flows on through Endcliffe Woods, once a central feature of the park, its cobbled causeways are now overgrown and all but forgotten. On the opposite bank of the Porter is a large playing field, and backing onto the river is Endcliffe Park Cafe, which was once owned by the same family as run the cafe at Forge Dam (see Part 1). The local area has changed a lot over the years, and this is reflected in changes to the park. While the menu has certainly improved since the days of meat-paste sandwiches, the cafe is now frequented by middle-class ‘yummy mummys’, and the park can be positively over-run with joggers at certain times of the year. The simple attractions of a set of stepping-stones and a humble set of swings have been replaced by all manner of fenced-in, safe-surfaced, fancy rides and roundabouts, which now block the corner of the river where generations of youngsters tested their metal trying to leap across it.



During World War Two, Sheffield was heavily bombed, and communal air-raid shelters were dug into the playing field. On June 22nd 1944, tragedy came to Endcliffe Park, when a badly stricken US B-17 Flying Fortress flew low over the field, and crashed in the woods on the other side of the Porter, just ahead of the Victorian stepping-stones. The brave men of Mi Amigo, flew the burning plane over the city, crashing in the woods, the only fatalities themselves. They were:

• Lt John Kriegshauser (Missouri) - pilot

• 2nd Lt Lyle Curtis (Idaho) - co-pilot

• 2nd Lt John Humphrey (Illinois) - navigator

• 2nd Lt Melchor Hernandez (California) - bombardier

• S/Sgt Harry Estabrooks (Kansas) - engineer and top-turret gunner

• Sgt Charles Tuttle (Kentucky) - ball-turret gunner

• S/Sgt Robert Mayfield (Illinois) - radio operator

• Sgt Vito Ambrosio (New York) - right waist gunner

• M/Sgt G. Malcolm Williams (Oklahoma) - left waist gunner

• Sgt Maurice Robbins (Texas) - tail gunner

Their courage and their sacrifice is remembered at an annual ceremony held on the crash-site every year. You can read the full moving tale of Mi Amigo here - http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/s...-)?p=11886436&highlight=mi+amigo#post11886436 – and I hope you will do so.

 
Last edited:


Seventy years later, the little River Porter continues to flow on, and soon we come to the next weir and tail-goit sluice, which once served Endcliffe Wheel, which in 1706 was known as Elcliffe Wheel. The tenants in 1706 were John Savage and Widow Newton, and it subsequently passed to William Savage and Benjamin Newton, who were listed as tenants from 1714. By 1730, William Savage shared the wheel with a scissorsmith, Nicholas Ratcliffe, and in 1769 Nicholas’ son John inherited his father’s half of the wheel tools and one trow. By 1801 the wheel had been expanded to ten trows, with William Sykes renting the wheel, and ten knife grinders working the trows.

In 1803, William Loy took over the tenancy from Sykes, and in 1818 there was a change in ownership of the wheel when William Wilson (of whose family we shall hear more in Part 3) bought 50 acres of the Broomhall estate, on which Endcliffe Wheel was situated. In the 1850’s, the afore-mentioned Carr family bought the wheel, the tenants then being Harrison Brothers & Howson. As with the other Endcliffe wheels, the wheel was subsequently bought by Robert Younge, and ownership later passed to his nephew Francis Otter, who had it in 1875.







When Endcliffe Park was opened, the dam of Endcliffe Wheel was turned into a swimming pool. This was later filled-in in the late 1950’s, though a row of weeping willow trees remained well into the 1980’s.





We now find ourselves at Hunter’s Bar, named after the toll bar which operated here until midnight on the 31st October 1884. However, before we leave the park for the now busy suburban roads, there is an old weir where the tail goit for the next wheel along the Porter once began. That is all which remains of the Upper Lescar Wheel, which was built between 1753 and 1754. Even earlier, two separate wheels, known as Leche Carr, existed as long ago as 1584.



In 1753, cutler Richard Hall, took out a lease to build a wheel here. By 1777 the wheel was tenanted by Joseph and Benjamin Broomhead, and there were fourteen trows and fourteen employees. In 1831, John Dewsnap bought the wheel, which he was already leasing prior to this. He sold it to Henry Wilson in 1854, and for twenty years, from 1855, Wilson leased the wheel to James Howard. The wheel operated until at least 1893, but was then demolished, and the dam was filled in. Shops and houses were built over the site, and while its location can still be traced, there is nothing left of it in existence.

Opposite where the Upper Lescar Wheel stood is Hunter’s Bar school, which I attended between the ages of four and twelve. The River Porter flows past Hunter’s Bar on the other side of busy Ecclesall Road, first going under Brocco Bank, and then past a row of almshouses, built at the end of the 19th century, and donated to the city by cutlery manufacturer George Woofindin to home local people in their dotage. Like the convalescent home Mr Woofindin also donated to the city, and as with some of the city’s parks, the houses now appear to have been sold off like the family silver.



The Porter re-crosses Ecclesall Road, winding round the side of Endcliffe Methodist Church, under Neiil Road, and running down the side of Meadow Terrace, where the second of the wheels in this area was once situated.

There is some confusion over the early history of the wheels which stood in this area. As mentioned above, two wheels known collectively as Leche Carr, existed as far back as 1584. Historians sometimes seem to confuse the two wheels, while the site of a ‘Greaves Wheel ‘is unknown. The Nether Lescar Wheel, as it was later called, may go back to 1604. By 1744, after a series of tenants, cutler Richard Hall enlarged both the dam and buildings. By the time of Hall’s death in 1779, the wheel was known as Nether Lescar, and employed eleven men working at eleven trows. In 1812, by which time a trow had been added, Thomas Dyson, a scissor grinder, bought the wheel.



Nether Lescar Wheel was again sold in 1830, to George Younge. By the time it was sold again in 1851, a rolling mill and forge had been installed, and it was referred to as Porter Wheel Steel Works. Twenty years later, Messrs Robert Smith & Co were running the forge, but by 1890, the dam was a marsh and the old hull a ruin. Steel Road still runs close to where the tail-goit would have entered the Nether Lescar dam, and the name of the wheel survives in the popular Lescar Hotel public house, where I once worked as a twenty-year old. Back then it was known locally as ‘The George & Dragon’, after George the landlord and his wife, Margaret. There was a small cutlery works behind the Lescar Hotel when I was a boy, but I’m unfortunately unable to remember the name. It seems a shame though to pass the Lescar, long under new management, without calling in for a pint ;)

Part 3 will follow in a few days.



Cheers! ;)

Jack



Part 3: http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showthread.php/1232523-The-Dairy-Maids-of-Porter-Brook-(Part-3)
 
Last edited:
Jack,

Again you did a great job, very interesting read and the photos really help take a person back to the days gone by. - :thumbup::cool:

Question - Has it ever flooded badly (and I'm sure it has) in theses rivers, that it ever effected some of these dams and wheels? Or even the buildings near by that you know of?
 
Last edited:
Another great installment, Jack! The history of Sheffield is so interesting and you are preserving it and I am learning a lot. Thank you

And now...I need a Harrison and Howson knife:eek::D:thumbup:
 
Enjoying the trip and the history Jack. :thumbup::)

I like thinking about all of the wonderful craftsmen of days long gone by and at the same time, it makes me a bit sad. :)
 
Thanks a lot for the kind words guys. I've just added some additional info about Harrison Brothers & Howson, sorry for the late edit :thumbup:

Question - Has it ever flooded badly (and I'm sure it has) in theses rivers, that it ever effected some of these dams and wheels? Or even the buildings near by that you know of?

The Porter only floods occasionally, and it is never that bad. However, it would be enough to stop the water-wheels being used. A more common problem was one of the river becoming 'backed-up' because of the operation of some of the dams and goits downstream, jamming up the wheels further upstream.

Even in 2007, when torrential rain brought almost unprecedented flooding to Sheffield, the little Porter was not so badly affected as the other Sheffield rivers. The main flooding point for the river is at its confluence with the Sheaf.

The worst flood of Sheffield's history was in 1864, and caused by a burst dam, which sent thousands of gallons of water coursing down the valley of the River Loxley to the north of Sheffield. The wheels along the route were largely destroyed, and over 250 people lost their lives.
 
I'd like to know who those two old miseries are on the top (black n white) photo of the Holme Dam! :D
 
Thanks a lot Gev, much appreciated :thumbup: ;)
 
Last edited:
Crikey! I've been mucking about Sheffield for 20 years and I'm even related (sort of) to George Cunningham, one-time Sheffield littlemeister and artist and I never knew ANY of this. Many thanks Jack for your fascinating posts. I look forward to part 3.
 
Thanks for another fascinating installment Jack! I love the photographs of all that stonework in the weirs, and sluice ways, steps and walls. Generations have come and gone, yet they sit steadfast, testament to the men who toiled to harness those waters.
 
Very fascinating history and I love your style of writing it, almost as if a tour. Thanks for taking the time to put these together. It is much appreciated.

Chris
 
Interesting that there was a Mayfield on the Mi Amigo.

Thanks again Jack.

You should start a guid service man.
 
Crikey! I've been mucking about Sheffield for 20 years and I'm even related (sort of) to George Cunningham, one-time Sheffield littlemeister and artist and I never knew ANY of this. Many thanks Jack for your fascinating posts. I look forward to part 3.

Thanks Donn, I'll hope to get Part 3 up early next week if not before (it's taking me a long time to upload pics at the moment). I love George Cunningham's artwork, and of course he did more than one painting of Endcliffe Park. I've only read the second volume of his memoirs - More George! - but found it both hilarious and heart-warming. I have bought several copies for friends, including Duncan here on the forum. My grandparents, and later my mother and father, lived on Bath Street, and I spent many years living in the same area myself, so it is fascinating to read George's memories. A shame there appears to be virtually nothing about him online.

Thanks for another fascinating installment Jack! I love the photographs of all that stonework in the weirs, and sluice ways, steps and walls. Generations have come and gone, yet they sit steadfast, testament to the men who toiled to harness those waters.

Thanks Duane, absolutely, very eloquently put my friend :thumbup:

Very fascinating history and I love your style of writing it, almost as if a tour. Thanks for taking the time to put these together. It is much appreciated.

Thanks Chris :)

Interesting that there was a Mayfield on the Mi Amigo.

Thanks again Jack.

You should start a guide service man.

Yes indeed, and it's not a common name at all. Thanks Mykel. Sheffield City Council doesn't even have a tourist office, so I doubt they would hire me, I did do some local history guiding in the centre of Sheffield back in the 1980's though. These days I just bore my daughter, who accompanied me on a couple of my research trips for this virtual tour! :D
 
Here's an appropriate painting by cutler turned artist and author George Cunningham (see above), showing the frozen dam of the old Holme Wheel - Endcliffe Park duck pond in the 1930's. George called the painting The Munky Rack



A weekend in Endcliffe Park in the middle of a cold snap.

The water, well-frozen by nights of hard frosts, entices young and old alike to venture onto the ice to try their skating skills. Groups of youths, yelling and screeching, hurtle in long lines into the bank pursued by dogs barking frantically as they try to stay upright on the strange surface. Onlookers parade up and down, some no doubt hoping to strike it lucky:

This is what they call Munky Rack. Lasses walk one way and lads other way, then lads say summat and if lasses say summat back they've clicked.

From the first volume of George's autobiography By George!
 
Sensational!
A fantastic history. Well done Jack. I love seeing "then and now " pictures.
As an aside you have also solved one of the most frustrating and disappointing puzzles I have ever tried to solve.
Being a simple lad from Nottingham I've always been interested in the legend of Robin Hood aka Robin of Locksley aka various other names.
The question was -where is Locksley or is it Loxley? I gave up the search way before the internet arrived.There was no Loxley in my 1970 AA guide to Britain which ended up getting beer spilled on it.
Now it seems so obvious-its a river not a town or village.
Cheers.
 
Thanks Meako, much appreciated my friend :thumbup:

Yes, much as the River Porter has a Porter Valley, so the Loxley has a Loxley Valley. One of my earliest memories as a child was a bank holiday trip up the Loxley Valley with my extended family, and a trip to the Robin Hood pub, which I'm sad to say is now no longer there. I don't know the area as well as I do the Porter Valley, but might do something about it at some point. I'll see if there are any books about it the next time I'm over in Sheffield, and hopefully you now have enough info to research it on the internet :thumbup:
 
Thanks for that -it's just one of those things I had a yearning to find out years ago but then life kinda got in the way.
Your article refreshed my memory if you like.
I just had a quick scout round for my AA guide but can't find.
Thankfully I just downloaded a copy of the 1965 movie "She" (who must be obeyed) so I'll ask her when she gets in.
Interestingly the Porters are one of Mt Keira's oldest families a massive 6 generations have farmed ,worked and lived in the area.
Keira Glen, a new estate, was part of Porters farm is just over the creek from me.

I'm reminded of the art of Thelwell - with all that colour and chaos going on.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top