Thoughts on Mushroom Knives?

Joined
Dec 14, 2019
Messages
46
Merry Christmas! I'm a knife knut and a shroomer. I've got a bunch of knives, so as I got more into foraging wild mushrooms I employed many of my different knives, including one I bought on a whim and didn't use for years previously (the hori hori).

I naturally looked for "mushroom knives" to add to my collection but they all seemed like silly, inferior combinations of a proper knife and a proper brush. I still think this way. My current "mushroom knife" is 4 knives:

https://postimg.cc/YL74LF94

Top to bottom:

1.) I always have a dedicated woods knife/Puukko of some sort. This is my slicer and wood carver as needed. When I need to slice off specimens carefully so that they will grow back, I use this. I sometimes use it to carve small location marks on trees as I explore new territory.

2.) folding pruner (multipurpose blade). This sees the most use because it's cheap, ready, and sharp enough for most situations.

3.) Hori Hori knife. This is the true workhorse, the "shroomslayer" to rule them all! Well, there are some species that require one to dig them up for a correct identification or else you might die. So yeah, a blade meant to dig is a great thing. Also, in nature there's a lot of weird unexpected obstacles, so this tool with its plain and serrated edge designed for rooting around is kind of my main blade.

4.) Small machete for handling vines and such. This Ontario knives machete has seen little use, but it's a solid piece of kit. I love how the tip is sharpened so it can be used as a palm-driven chisel.

If I could only have one for shrooming it would be the hori hori ShroomSlayer. Yes it's a gardening tool, arguably not even a "knife" (even though it comes with a sharpening stone).

Your thoughts? Any other secret shroomers around here?
 
Other than Morell mushrooms , i have not tried to pursue other shrooms at this time. Mostly from a fear of accidentally harming myself from said unknown shrooms. I usually use a swiss army knife and a endura 4 in the little i do shroom wise.
 
I leave all wild mushrooms alone.
I don't recognize the various mushrooms from the various toad stools.

The only wild mushroom I know is (allegedly) "safe" to eat (according to the Army and Marines field guides, at any rate) is the shelf mushroom.

I ain't so sure the Army and Marines survival manuals are correct.

It would not be the first time (or the last) that the military lied to their enlisted and officers.
 
Supposedly the Spyderco Civilian is used by some for mushroom harvesting. The thin tip and serrations make it a workhorse. It's has a pocke clip, so it's not suitable for this forum.
 
If I could only have one for shrooming it would be the hori hori ShroomSlayer. Yes it's a gardening tool, arguably not even a "knife" (even though it comes with a sharpening stone).
It's hard to go wrong with a hori hori. I've got one and it's my go to gardening tool... And when leek season hits it goes in my edc bag. Sounds to me like you have a good system worked out.
 
Well, there are a handful of "foolproof" shroom. Most shelf mushrooms are too woody to eat, but fresh oysters (not a "shelf mushroom" but might be referred to as such) are choice and delicious. I had some this week.
 
Most of the time woods soils are pretty soft and using a knife is no big deal to dig. But if I dug a lot, I would use something along the line of the BK (oops this knife is not traditional).

I have only picked some of the easily identifiable mushrooms to eat. I have several mushroom field guides, but I am not hard core enough to spend much time researching them beyond the picture.
 
When I was 16 I ate some and proceeded to be stuck in a blanket for what felt like a life time. Better than liver damage I suppose.

I feel like a pruner style knife looks really nice..I love the Bose pruner pattern but sharpening would be difficult I imagine.
 
When I was 16 I ate some and proceeded to be stuck in a blanket for what felt like a life time. Better than liver damage I suppose.

I feel like a pruner style knife looks really nice..I love the Bose pruner pattern but sharpening would be difficult I imagine.
That sound pretty intense. Glad you made it out of that blanket.

Yeah, the pruner is nice. Sharpening isn't difficult with ceramic rods, but it's really hard to strop without the tip digging into the leather. I only need a utility edge on that blade, though.
 
This is my pretty neat mushroom knife with sheath, made by a used to be BF member - Wild Boar Knives.

Not really a knife used for tree conks in spite of the photo (no stem shrooms in the house at this moment, in late December) but a great knife for filling the basket with edibles :thumbsup:

View attachment 1256703


View attachment 1256704


Happy hunting.

Ray

That's a very good-looking knife and sheath. I'll look out for something like that.
 
Back
Top