TOPS Frog Market Special

CRH

Joined
Jan 17, 2004
Messages
432
Man, I gotta get me one of these, Frog Market Specials!

fms05.jpg


Strikes me as a very ancient and very useful blade pattern. This one is speaking to me in the kindred spirit sort of way. I'm tempted to pre-order directly from TOPS but I'll hold off in hopes of more reasonable prices once it's released.
 
Designed by Steven Dick. I remember reading his article on one of his recent SE Asia trips, which apparently inspired this model, in one of the knife mags.
 
The knife doesn't look very sharp, as you can see on the tomato part.
The cutting the technique is awful - The maker needs to see a lot more videos of cutting examples, the salmon part must have been a joke :)

This knife will never ever hit my kitchen. The profile is horrible. i dint like anything about this knife.
Sorry, just my 2 cents :)
 
Dull is all a mater of sharpening even on the best knives. The meat cutters around Hanoi could probably teach you a few tricks about technique Oivind.
 
Dull is all a mater of sharpening even on the best knives. The meat cutters around Hanoi could probably teach you a few tricks about technique Oivind.

I'm getting visions of an old and tiny Vietnamese lady - or man - in a blood smeared apron lecturing me on filleting techniques while animatedly waving the blade about my face. :D
 
CRH, I finally watched the video, and as the man said he (and I) are not chefs. I think the tomato part problem was partly because he was sitting down. The part about the knife cutting meat looked like the blade was sharp to me. For me I got the softest hot house tomato I had, and the FMS sliced it cleanly and with no problems. That is all I have done so far with the FMS, but with its thin stock it should be a great slicer. John
 
CRH, I finally watched the video, and as the man said he (and I) are not chefs. I think the tomato part problem was partly because he was sitting down. The part about the knife cutting meat looked like the blade was sharp to me. For me I got the softest hot house tomato I had, and the FMS sliced it cleanly and with no problems. That is all I have done so far with the FMS, but with its thin stock it should be a great slicer. John

Yup...
 
The guy in the video is no chef, but that is fine. This is gonna be a great tool for real kitchen work.
I trust Steven Dick and his experience.
 
Cook here. I see a few things other than $88 bucks for 1/16th 1095. Curious about the heat treat quality and what that "finish" is.

The patterns been around for a while, seen a few hanging in mostly butcher shops in Hanoi. In vietnam I saw more cheap nakiri type profiles being used for veg and other misc utility. This knife is mostly a honesuki profile save the very wide heel. This is a better boning knife than a veg slicer, although it can do it. The steep angle is designed to really utilize the tip for precision work, not really as an efficient slicer, which $88 bucks doesn't seem so bad for butchery kit knife. Most shun types will run you $180-$200. Which brings me back to the unused material at the heel. Had the guy in the video been standing and holding the knife up on top, the slicing tasks it could do would have been better leveraged as others above stated. Still I don't think anyone on a kitchen line is going to really use a knife like this for anything other than butchering birds, fish, small game. Home cooks and outdoors types could use it as more a utility knife and be just fine. Although I'm not sure about the how the coating will hold up to corrosion when cutting acidic foods whether it patinas well or just rusts. Fun idea though, didn't even get to the handles, but on a butcher knife of this angle, you're gonna be more on the tip of the knife than the back. That said it's hard to compete with a $60 FKM or MAC version molydenumV stainless steel.
 
Last edited:
Looks like a great knife for pinching the spine on. I think it's a very versatile blade shape/size by the look of things. Sort of a hybrid of a mini chef's knife and a petty knife.
 
I posted this in another thread but I thought it might fit in here as well.

I couldn't resist the FMS shipped to my door for $79.00 so I went and did it. I'm glad I did because it is a cool knife and could sell for more in my opinion. It is a little smaller than I pictured but after using it I can appreciate the size. So far it has been amazing in the kitchen, I can't get enough of it.

I'm not sure what the "Black River Wash" coating is, but I really like it. It looks like bare steel with a patina of some kind but very smooth and slick. I have been giving it a rinse and drying before putting it away and have had no problems with rust of any kind.

The thickness is 1/16th but not all the way to the edge. If you look very closely, you can see that about 1" up, just where the finish changes color, the blade tapers to a very thin edge. Nothing else I have tried cuts quite like it.





I modified the sheath and the guard area to offer a little more room for my index finger.
I set a Q tip with a little vinegar on the fresh grind to darken it up to match the finish.




 
Back
Top