URGENT! I need opinions on the quality of Chicago Cutlery kitchen knives.

Joined
Jul 2, 1999
Messages
1,347

Hello all,

My brother is looking for a decent set of kitchen knives. there is a set in my book from Chicago Cutlery that he would like but I don't know a thing about their knives. It is a 14 piece set with wooden block.

If anyone knows anything about these knives please let me know. Thanks.

------------------

Louis Buccellato
http://www.themartialway.com
Knives, Weapons and equipment. Best prices anywhere.
-------------

"only the paranoid will survive"
 
Better than the cheapo foreign stuff, but not much.

------------------
Danbo, soul brother of Rambo
 
Junk in my opinion. Every Chicago Cutlery knife we purchased has had the blade break at the tip and they do not sharpen! Buy something like Wustoff which will last for lifetime.
 
I like them. They are good knives, in fact they hold a better edge than my Wusthof knives. Yep I have both
 
My wifes family has always had Chicago Cultery so when we got married thats what we got also. They are good knifes. I don't have any problems with them.

One thing is there seems to be diffrent qualities of CC. If you get them at someplace like Target or Walmat the blades are thinner. If you get them at the more expensive stores like Daytons or Yonkers (I'm in the Midwest here folks) the blades are thicker and the wood handles seem better.

So check around.
Good luck
 
Before I knew much about knives, other than I like 'em, I bought some CC stuff on the recommendation of an aquaintence and occasional knife maker. As I recall he told me the blades are 440 C. That sounded good, so I bought a paring knife and a large chef's knife. The paring knife's blade broke after a few months. Not at the tip, but right in the middle. It did so while cutting stuff on the poly board - normal use. I've still go the big one, and it works okay and holds and edge reasonably well. But I can't imagine there isn't much better stuff available for competitive prices. Just my experience.
 
I have CC knives and I like them. However, most were purchased when CC knives were made in this country. More recent, "off-shore", CC's do not seem to me to have the same over-all quality that the older, domestic, CC knives did. Since the person in question is looking seriously at a block of Chicago Cutlery knives, it seems to me that a set of "high-end" knives like Wusthof's may not be in the picture. Might I recommend, then, that Old Hickory's knives be considered"? OH's fit and finish is now at least as good as CC's, their walnut handles are at least as pretty ( if not always quite as "ergonmic") as CC's, and their 1095 carbon steel blades take and hold an edge a lot better than CC's "mystery stainless" blades. (I find it interesting that, a few years back, CC came out with a line of knives that featured 440A as a "premium steel"! Kind of makes one wonder about their "regular steel"!) OH knives are good quality American-made knives that are offered at a low price that almost conceals how good these knives really are. A few precautions against rust and, occasionally, a good sharpening right out of the box gives the OH user an inexpensive knife that will often outperform much more expensive knives.

------------------
 
I have always found the wood handles on any kitchen knife to be un-sanitary. When preparing chicken and meat, the "remains" can be tough to clean. Wood also has to be maintained with oils and such, no throwing them in diswashers for sure. The synthetic handles seemed better suited for longer life in the kitchen.

I remember quite a few years back Consumer Reports rated Chicago Cutlery overall #1 in there un-biased testing. I was personally amused, as they did have all the major German brands up against it. If you like USA made stuff, check out the Chef Choice line of kitchen knives. Very hard to beat.
 
Chef's Choice - are they the brand you can get at Lechter's ? If so, I like them and coincidentally am thinking of going tonight and getting either a full block or a chef & boning individually (turkey day coming!). I have the steak knives and they are sharp, serrated, full-tang, nice black synthetic handles. I like the looks of the cooking set because they are plain edge, with the full-tang construction. My current kitchen set is an old "Laser" serrated set, wiggly handles showing age and un-sharpenable tiny serrations.
 
I have a set (14 piece) and really like them. The steel is relatively soft and is super easy to sharpen (and the diamond coated CC steel works great).
I got mine as a wedding gift and have put a few miles on them
smile.gif



------------------
"People sleep peaceably in their beds at night only because rough men stand ready to do violence on their behalf."
George Orwell
"Those who hold the thin blue line keep order, and insure that anarchy and chaos will not prevail." Chad (1992)
"He who lives by the sword dies by the sword. He who dies by the sword did not train hard enough" -Chad (1999)
chad234@email.com
 
a long time ago CC was good - but with the move to "off shore" production - I'm not hearing good things .. If you want good go to a Restrant and Bar supply store and check out what they offer - Dexter-Russells are not too spendy and hold up well for me - as do the older lines of Case and Robinson (?) kitchen knives.. and you really don't need 14 and a hardwood block. couple parers, a 4 and 6" boner, and a long slicer work well.


------------------
Don't wrestle with the hogs - they enjoy it and you get dirty !
Jonesy
 
Back
Top