User Report

LFH

Joined
Feb 24, 2005
Messages
469
Hi Guys and Gals,

We have wrapped up our deer hunting for the year and I thought I would give a few impressions of the knives.

I retired my old two dot 110 and replaced it with a new Alaskan S30V and an Alaskan Vanguard S30V with the rubber handle.

They both out performed the old two dot. I was able to field dress 4 deer with no noticable dulling of the 110. The old two dot would be noticablly dull after 2 deer.

Then I used the 192 for quartering and final processing. It is still sharp enough that I could do more. We do all of our own processing all the way to the freezer. And no, I didn't use the Alaskans for cutting steaks and such. The old electric knife is still more efficent for that part.

It only took a few strokes with either of them to have to re-educate my cutting stroke, as a slight touch and I was cutting through the hide.

So it looks like S30V is now my blade for hunting. Now if I can just learn how to get them sharpened back to being as razor sharp as they came from the factory, I will be in good shape.

The only thing I wished for was that the 192 would have been a clip blade like the 110. Would have been a bit better for separating the meat off the bones and stripping the meat off the carcas.
 
I like the fixed blades for field dressing, particularily the 118. Don't you find that with the folders, they fill up with gore? Still, the 110 would do the job no doubt!
 
I guess I been gutting deer for so long that "gore" isn't a problem. I won't take a bad shot so haven't dealt with a "gut shot" in I can't remember when. If that is what you are calling gore.

A 110 gets bloody for sure, and if a deer has a lot of fat, it will build up on any blade. Folder or fixed. As I finish putting the deer parts in the cooler, the last thing that goes in are the knives after they are wiped off.

Back in camp or home, a hard stream of hot water has them cleaned up as far as the blood and fat. Hot soapy water and a brush finishes cleaning them up. I been doing that to my two dot since I bought it new.

For what it is worth, that two dot is still in pretty good shape. Strong snap, tight blade, but with the normal scratches one gets with as much use as it has gotten.
 
LFH said:
For what it is worth, that two dot is still in pretty good shape. Strong snap, tight blade, but with the normal scratches one gets with as much use as it has gotten.
LFH, You re-enforce what I've always believed. If you take care of your knives; don't abuse them, perform proper maintenance, they will last a lot longer, and look a lot better over time than most think. :thumbup:
 
Definitely agree with you there Mike and LFH...the pair of 2 liners and most of the other knives that I have look like new. I also do the soft cotton thing and until Trax got me going on the hard paste wax, I used cornstarch to remove any swirl marks. Took a lot of rubbing but it worked...Gotta add however that I do have a few that I've used the heck out of in a metal fine blanking environment so they do look kinda rough...
 
I haven't used my Alaskan Guide 110 in S30V for any significant cutting yet (just arm hair and maybe a kleenex box). For some reason, I keep finding myself using my standard 110 when I'm home and the Spyderco Endura I carry in my pocket when I'm out and about. I think it's because I have some kind of weird emotional problem. I've got the AG 110 super sharp, sharper than I can get the Endura, so I want to "preserve" it in case I'm in some kind of emergency where a super sharp slicer is needed. I'm weird.
 
Rhino,,

Give it up and go ahead and use the AG. You will be glad you did. I was amazed at how well the S30V performed. Half the fun in using them is sharpening them up again. Well, kinda, sorta, maybe... :rolleyes: :D

Or do like I did and grab an extra AG for reserve,,,or two... :o

oh. and as to cleaning the 110, I do put a small drop or two of 3n1 or sewing machine oil after I wash it down good.
 
The S30V is good stuff. I have been so impressed with it, that except for fillet knives it is all I use.

It is actually softer then the BG-42 and AST-34/154 CM yet it wears better then either. That means you get ductility with your edge retention.

Did you notice any corrossion at all? I have been pretty impressed with that as well. I tend not to abuse tools but I balance that with not being a big maintenance guy either.

All in all, S30V is my favorite steel.
 
Must ... use ... AK Guide 110 ... must find out ... how ... good S30V really ... is ... can't seem to ... must ... got to ... reach the ... kryptonite ... ungh . . .
 
I normally use my Mayo TNT as an EDC (I work at the courthouse and it would not go over very well if I strolled by the courtrooms with a 110 on my belt) :eek: :eek: So far the S30V steel has shown to hold an edge and also to be fairly easy to re-sharpen. I really love the steel and the TNT for that matter! :D :thumbup:
 
I had a proto Buck/Mayo TNT and then had Tom Mayo sign it at a shot show. I finally retired it after using it to trim some drywall repairs we were doing to a house we were selling. I thought...what the heck am I doing??

I grabbed another one to take its place as EDC and put that one away.

Dad, Joe, Sarah (my precious Daughter) and I all ended up with Mayos in S30V as EDC's
 
Back
Top