- Joined
- Sep 5, 2016
- Messages
- 62
Several times in the past, I have praised Schrade knives as being an outstanding budget knife company, and with good reason. 9 out of 10 times, I have had a very positive experience with these knives, and with the value the company offered, the 1 out of 10 negative experiences were always well worth it...
One of my favorite models has always been the SCHF43, aka the Jessica X, designed by Chris Tanner of the youtube channel "PreparedMind101". The original model was an excellent all purpose tool, and was famously durable as hell. In fact, it was nearly indestructible...check out the youtube review from Tactical, "what it took to kill Jessica X". Well, Schrade has come under new ownership since the recent purchase of the company by Smith & Wesson, and it is clear some element of quality control has definitely fallen by the wayside. Recently, Chris Tanner tested the newest generation of the SCHF43, which is now made with a hollow grind, rather than the saber grind of the original design. Whether it was simply the grind change that ruined this knife, or Schrade is using cheaper steel or an inferior heat treat, something at Schrade has undeniably changed for the worse. In the link below, you can see Chris Tanner destroy 15 new SCHF43 knives with simple tip strength tests...
This result is especially disturbing when you consider that this model was one of Schrade's most durable, one that survived countless torture tests on youtube, including the notorious "Gauntlet" series of reviews. While this result only concretely proves that Schrade has made one particular model much cheaper and inferior in design, it would only be logical to assume the company as a whole has taken an enormous step backwards in terms of quality control. Until it is proven otherwise, I will assume that there has been a significant drop off in quality at Schrade knives, and I will no longer be buying their products.
One of my favorite models has always been the SCHF43, aka the Jessica X, designed by Chris Tanner of the youtube channel "PreparedMind101". The original model was an excellent all purpose tool, and was famously durable as hell. In fact, it was nearly indestructible...check out the youtube review from Tactical, "what it took to kill Jessica X". Well, Schrade has come under new ownership since the recent purchase of the company by Smith & Wesson, and it is clear some element of quality control has definitely fallen by the wayside. Recently, Chris Tanner tested the newest generation of the SCHF43, which is now made with a hollow grind, rather than the saber grind of the original design. Whether it was simply the grind change that ruined this knife, or Schrade is using cheaper steel or an inferior heat treat, something at Schrade has undeniably changed for the worse. In the link below, you can see Chris Tanner destroy 15 new SCHF43 knives with simple tip strength tests...
This result is especially disturbing when you consider that this model was one of Schrade's most durable, one that survived countless torture tests on youtube, including the notorious "Gauntlet" series of reviews. While this result only concretely proves that Schrade has made one particular model much cheaper and inferior in design, it would only be logical to assume the company as a whole has taken an enormous step backwards in terms of quality control. Until it is proven otherwise, I will assume that there has been a significant drop off in quality at Schrade knives, and I will no longer be buying their products.