tinfoil hat timmy
Gold Member
- Joined
- Aug 21, 2014
- Messages
- 18,555
Take for sure.
Doesnt matter how long the knife will hold the dull that I put on it.
Doesnt matter how long the knife will hold the dull that I put on it.
Putting Ka-Bar and Buck on the same "truck stop" scale as Gerber and the like is laughable.
I've never had an issue getting through an entire moose with Ka-Bar's 1095 CroVan or Buck's 420HC.
You can't drive older cars as many miles without working on them. New cars you can drive them but when there is a problem your stuck
I would rather buy a restored 1969 Camaro and work on adjusting the carb when you drive up the mountains to adjust to altitude than having a new model car that basically runs good but costs a bunch to fix when it does break.
The '67-69 Camaro I can work on and I can also sell it and get my money back or make a profit.
IMHO & the way I read that, it's sort of contradictory.With diamonds , sharpening is not a great problem .
And how hard is it to touch-up / hone a slightly dulled edge ? It's the work of seconds .
A broken , bent , or baldly chipped blade is not so easy to correct .
So toughness is paramount , IMO .
Don't bother. Some people just like to talk a good game but when it comes down to it, their actions don't follow through with their words. Same guy bitching about super steel cost and difficulty in sharpening said super steels is after an expensive otf in elmax and looking to preorder the new hotness protech Malibu in 20cv that never even makes it to the shelves because it sells out so quickly. Hypocrites make actual discourse difficult...Well, I asked twice for you to share your experience sharpening so-called super steels and you didn't acknowledge me either time. That's unfortunate as if you do actually have the experience to make the claim, "Sick of all these so called supersteels that take more effort than they are worth," then it can be very helpful and educational to others to share that experience.
Don't bother. Some people just like to talk a good game but when it comes down to it, their actions don't follow through with their words. Same guy bitching about super steel cost and difficulty in sharpening said super steels is after an expensive otf in elmax and looking to preorder the new hotness protech Malibu in 20cv that never even makes it to the shelves because it sells out so quickly. Hypocrites make actual discourse difficult...
Never answered my inquiry of if that $385 GT 040 would be worth the cost if the steel was 440a. It's not about the steel, right? Oh well. Some people just like to say things.Agreed. I have since seen he is also chasing an OTF in S35VN. That screams naturally aspirated '67 Camaro to me. I'll be done with that inquiry now.
Not to be that guy, but a Buck from 1990 is supposed to have 425M, and that steel isn't as high in wear resistance as some of the more modern steels. Sounds like the stones may be loaded up or something. Do they sharpen other knives well?Myth? I have some oil stones that won't even scratch my 1990 Buck 301 blades. I have to use diamond stones to sharpen them.
That old 425M was well known for being more difficult to sharpen while not holding an edge any better than the current 420HC. It is probably the carbide size, as a guess. It can be chippy and that is what makes me think that. Still, it is not too difficult to sharpen. Buck used to put an odd convex edge on their knives. It would get thin and then thicken out behind the edge. This made the knives a bit more durable in use. However, when people tried to sharpen them, they would inevitably hit the blade stock where it thickens out and not the edge. Then they would think it was hard to sharpen.Not to be that guy, but a Buck from 1990 is supposed to have 425M, and that steel isn't as high in wear resistance as some of the more modern steels. Sounds like the stones may be loaded up or something. Do they sharpen other knives well?
Glad you had good results with your Buck.
IME, I would put Gerber well above K-Bar or Buck. Although I do not care for any of these.
Don't bother. Some people just like to talk a good game but when it comes down to it, their actions don't follow through with their words. Same guy bitching about super steel cost and difficulty in sharpening said super steels is after an expensive otf in elmax and looking to preorder the new hotness protech Malibu in 20cv that never even makes it to the shelves because it sells out so quickly. Hypocrites make actual discourse difficult...
Did you answer this:My answer was already in the post if you read it. Want me to repost it?
If so, yes please repost as I can't seem to find it.So if that GT 040 was made with 440a, you'd pay the same price? It isn't about the steel that drives the price of that knife, right?
Not to be that guy, but a Buck from 1990 is supposed to have 425M, and that steel isn't as high in wear resistance as some of the more modern steels. Sounds like the stones may be loaded up or something. Do they sharpen other knives well?