Who makes "Winchester" knives?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Jan 27, 2006
Messages
107
I carry a multi-tool with the Winchester label, just like the guys who make the rifle. It has been a good, dependable tool, which I use a great deal at work for everything from pulling stuck green cards out of wallets to taking the screws off the quarter panel covers of a car to look for dope. I have seen sheath knives with the same label. They are very inexpensive, which, as you know by now, is important to me. Recently I noticed knives for sale on the Net that were identified as Winchester by Gerber. Does Gerber make those knives and multitools?
 
I have an old bone handle Winchester pocket knife that was made in 1927. I'm told it was made by E. Simmons Cutlery.
 
Thing is, Gerber apparently doesn't make Gerber knives anymore. It's just a brand, like Winchester, Remington, Smith & Wesson, that is attached to imports from Asia. Buck may be going that way from recent reports here.

Using a brand asociated in the general public consciousness with high quality for lesser goods is nothing new. White Consolidated did it with Tappen, Frigidaire, et al. Look at all the classic old U.S. watch brands like "Hamilton." Same deal. "White Stag" used to be the top brand for outdoor gear. Now it's a very cheap line indeed.

Use the imbedded good will to sell lesser goods -- as long as you can get away with it.

$.02
 
I was given a new Chinese Winchester SAK-type knife this past Christmas. It's about the same quality as the ones in the 49 cent bin near the hardware store register. I wouldn't trust it.
 
I can't say for a certainly, but I heard that the Winchester knives are now owned by and being made by Fiskars...a name which I associate with scissors and I am not aware of any of the names of really high end scissors.
 
OldMan1 said:
I can't say for a certainly, but I heard that the Winchester knives are now owned by and being made by Fiskars...a name which I associate with scissors and I am not aware of any of the names of really high end scissors.

Fiskars is a multi-national corporation that bought Gerber years ago. They sell products under twenty-odd brands, including "Winchester."

Where did you hear that "Fiskars" is actually making "Winchester" knives and what would that mean in terms of quality or place of manufacture?
 
wade said:
meeker got it right, China.

Until recently the name "China" appeared on the blade, but now it doesn't have to so long as it appears on the packaging (This refers to Winchester items, as told to me by a person working at Gerber).
 
Fiskars makes good scissors, but Gerber went downhill when Fiskars bought them out. I don't know about the Remington knives, but buying a name isn't always a disaster. Some Browning knives seem pretty good. Does anyone know who manufactures them?
 
Some Browning knives are made in Seki City and a least one model is made by Mcusta.
 
I have a small Winchester 2 blade penknife marked China. A real piece of junk. Blades mushy, don't 'walk and talk' and have some sideplay. Plastic, faux stag scales don't fit properly. It looked good on the internet pics. but I've been burned like that before. It was too cheap to bother sending back. The Case on the other hand cost £60 and was worse than the £10 Winchester. Had the same faults plus a deep scratch on the blade.
Put me off both brands for life.
 
Esav Benyamin said:
Their 3-blade hunters are solid working knives and the Ice Storm looks really good. Looks sort of like a Mcusta blade. :)

I have an Icestorm. VG-10 Al handles. Haven't used it much, impulse/closeout purchase, but looks to be a strong knife. Good lock-up. Guess that makes mine a Seki-City.(VG-10)
 
The Ice Storm is made by Mcusta, same quality at a much better price. My old circa 1927 Winchester still walks and talks like the day it was made.
 
Old topic or not...
We have some Winchester-brand multi-tools at work, and they are junk compared to similar products from Victorinox or Leatherman.
It wouldn't surprise me if the Winchester multi-tool is made at the same factory as the cheap Gerber multi-tools, 'cause those are junk too. :grumpy:

P.S., Welcome to Bladeforums, Robbie!
 
I have a cheap $5 winchester knife that I carried for quite a while before I had many decent knives. Nothing special but it did cut things which you can't always say for cheap Chinese pieces of crap. Like all cheap brands it probably varies in quality from item to item, but I'd shy away from the multitools. I am interested in that huge bowie they make but I'd rather spend my $20 on a couple more mora's since I know they are quality.
 
I have seen knives and multitools with the Winchester brand. Most were made in China, or Malaysia or some such place. However, I have a vintage winchester knife now that is very high quality. The steel is tough, difficult to put an edge on, but once you do, it stays a long time, and after that, all you usually need to do to get it sharp again is run it over a sharpening steel a few times to get the fine edge back in alignment. It took a good while with a diamond impregnated steel hone to get that fine edge on it, but so far it's held it's edge quite well, and once needed the steel. Of course, it doesn't see very hard use, just light duty most of the time. It's too pretty to carry constantly, and use for any and every purpose. I did have one multitool with that brand that also seemed of high quality, but others were junk.
Now, I want to make one thing perfectly clear, the Chinese can and will make very high quality items if the company that imports them wants them high quality, it's to their fault if the company selling them wants cheap, low quality stuff. So if you're ticked about everything being made in China and of low quality, holler at the importers and companies here that order it. They seem to want low quality thinking you'll just buy more. If a store or company burns you, don't do any more business with them, if enough people do that, they might take the hint. At one time, being made in China was a mark of excellence. They only made high quality items. I don't know if any of you remember when being "made in Japan" was about the same as "made in China" is today. Now made in Japan is usually a mark of quality if it's a newer item.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top