0.25 Inch Thick Knife or 1/4 Inch thick

Joined
Mar 14, 2012
Messages
228
Hello knife people, Can someone recommened me a nice thick 0.25 - 1/4 inch knife? No Becker BK2's or Esee 5's please, and under $150 price mark.

Thanks a lot
Edit: 5" blade or smaller too please
 
Last edited:
Kabar potbelly and Ontario Ranger RD series are somewhere between .25 and 1/4" and less than 150.
 
You may want to re-think the .250 thick though. I was sure that I wanted a .250 thick 5-6 inch blade knife until I bought one. It was just too thick. It was terrible at slicing and too short to chop. The only thing it was good at was batoning because it was shaped like a wedge. I am now using a .140 thick knife for the same role and I am much happier with my current knife. That's just my two cents on the matter. Good luck buddy!
 
Last edited:
My go-to chopper is the recon scout at 5/16th inch. Been years and it hasnt let me down. I own the sk5 and smIII versions but the sk5 one is the one I beat on
 
You may want to re-think the .250 thick though. I was sure that I wanted a .250 thick 5-6 inch blade knife until I bought one. It was just too thick. It was terrible at slicing and too short to chop. The only thing it was good at was batoning because it was shaped like a wedge. I am now using a .140 thick knife for the same role and I am much happier with my current knife. That's just my two cents on the matter. Good luck buddy!

Do you think the Fallkniven F1 or S1 is better?
 
I don't have experience with either one of those knives but I do know that Fallkniven has quite the following and I have only heard good things about both.
 
I've got a custom coming that is right in your price range, 154CM, .227", ~4" blade, chisel ground and tapered tang. But it is a riggng knife and they need a thick spine to hold up to being beat on with a belay pin or mallet for getting through thick rope. Check in with Daniel Fairly Knives, he's going to do a run of these knives sometime in the future.


-Xander
 
What about an Entrek? For example the 11 Bravo? It is spot on for what you want.
 
You might want to include your plans for use of the knife. You could find several 5" blades and have them all different as well as different steels. Total flat ground, chisel ground. Drop point, Tanto, deep belly, slight recurve. I agree that 1/4 thick is to much for most uses.
 
You want a knife that is 5" or less and quarter inch (or 1/4 or .25 inches) thick but that isn't one of the two most popular knives that meet those specs. Are we to assume you want a fixed blade or are you looking for a folder? It would probably help to know what you want to do with it and it might help to know why ESEE5 and BK2 don't do it for you (cost / color / shape - what?).


---

Beckerhead #42
 
It can get complicated.

If you start looking at different steel types, the tougher steels can give you just as much(or more) impact toughness with less thickness.
Then, you can investigate the better slicing ability of the thinner blade, but still have a knife that's as tough as a thicker one with a lesser steel would be.
Steels like CPM-3V are like that. For example, A2 is considered a good tough tool steel for survival knives or hard-use knives. But CPM-3V is twice as tough as A2, and depending on the RC hardness used it might be nearly triple the toughness of A2. That's some very tough stuff. So, you don't necessarily need as thick of a blade when you use a steel like that. And then you can have a lighter knife that's just as tough, and you can exploit the thinner blade for better slicing geometry.
That's just a quick look into what you can get out of the higher alloy steels. It's not just that they might be tougher, or more wear resistant, but the way the maker can use those properties to give you a knife that works as tough as a big thick heavy knife, with a thinner knife that can slice better too.
Busse INFI is also tough like that, but way out of your price range.

For some nice CPM-3V knives, you can probably find one of a smaller size from Fehrman Knives near your price range. You can also get a Bark River Necker 2 3V for about $110 in skeleton form. Scales would cost more. These would be knives in the 3.5" blade length area.
Bark River has a pretty wide selection in CPM-3V in some longer knives too, but they are a bit higher(or a lot higher in some cases) than your stated price range. Same with Fehrman.
If you can live with a 3.5" blade length, the Bark River Necker 2 3V is well under your price limit, and is a very nice knife.
 
I'd second the Scrap Yard 511 . It's 3/16 thick , but Scrap Yard make VERY hard use knives . They are up for sale on thier site right now and you can get one and odred the sheath with it for less than the price you want to spend .


................................................
HOLD MY BEER AND WATCH THIS !
 
You want a knife that is 5" or less and quarter inch (or 1/4 or .25 inches) thick but that isn't one of the two most popular knives that meet those specs. Are we to assume you want a fixed blade or are you looking for a folder? It would probably help to know what you want to do with it and it might help to know why ESEE5 and BK2 don't do it for you (cost / color / shape - what?).


---

Beckerhead #42

I'm planning on getting the Esee-5 really soon and just want another knife. And the BK2 I will be getting later And If anyone knows a folder with 1/4" thick blade would be nice
 
Back
Top