I was wiping down one of my Cold Steel 1917 Frontier Bowie knives last night. While doing so, I couldn't help but to think about the current times and the way so many people today think. On the man made goods issue, like knives, many folks in our society never learned to appreciate things that, while often less perfect in their final execution, are great representations of old school manufacturing. Of course some things made in old school fashion today are closer to perfection when the item is made by a custom knife maker, but the time required for that extra refinement usually comes at a much higher price tag.
While watching an episode of 'Forged in Fire', the participants were given 10 hours to make a knife of the type they were shown at the show's start. The participants were not beginners, they were true custom knife makers with a lot of experience in everything from forging knife blades, to the final fit, finishing, and construction of handles and all.
Watching the program showing short glimpses of all the work needed to make these knives by the participants, really gives the viewer a greater appreciation for this work.
The end result were specimens that one would think are pretty crude in their appearance, but these masters of the craft were not using CNC machinery or any other really state of the art modern equipment. Also, ten hours is not the kind of time frame a custom knife maker requires to achieve his full level of quality.
Then one looks at something like these Cold Steel Frontier Bowie knives, knives that have hand forged blades that require all sorts of steps afterwards for their completion, and much of that work being done by methods that modern knife companies would balk at. They would see them as being way too time consuming and too high in actual manual labor, not to mention causing too many deviations from one piece to another. Tie all that with them still being made in numbers that are considered "mass produced", (even if far from it when compared to more modern manufacturing methods), and with the workers being under time constraints to keep the products flowing and profitable... one should easily be able to see that the end product is still quite an achievement.
The Windlass Steelcrafts firm, (the company that makes these Bowie knives for Cold Steel), has had that video out where they show some of their processes during manufacturing. The start of that process has men in less than a modern environment heating steel and banging away at shaping blades by hammer and anvil. Even the tools themselves, (like those hammers and anvils), are primitive looking. To think that for just over one hundred American dollars, you can actually purchase a specimen, (like one of these bowie knives), that represents that sort of "old school" and dying commercial manufacturing method. I think that is quite the cool thing!
I believe that CNC use, along with so many other modern day knife manufacturing equipment, has made the newer generations of average knife buying folks more oblivious to what was all involved in making such items like these knives. So, they often expect an affordable priced hand made product to be as perfect as the one made mostly with modern equipment. Again, a custom knife maker can do this, and then some, but the man hours involved usually place those knives in the "very expensive" category.
When I watch the Windlass Steelcrafts video, and then handle one of my Frontier Bowie knives, I still feel an amazement of what they have achieved, (especially at the prices they go for), with such rudimentary tools and with the limited time they likely allow the workers to do what they do.
One hundred American dollars will not usually buy you much of anything nowadays, and I really believe these to be an incredible bargain.
My being 55 years old may be part of the reason I view them in this manner. Newer generations of folks were not overlapped in living in old school manufacturing times, they have been groomed to mostly, (if not completely), appreciate modern tech manufacturing, not "old school" manufacturing.
The Natchez and Laredo Bowie knives by Cold Steel will very much represent items being made using State of the Art manufacturing equipment, while the 1917 Frontier Bowie will mostly represent the opposite of that. Both types, (old tech & new tech), have a place in my collection, and for different reasons