Anybody like the Gerber Bear Grylls knives??

I've got several in the BG line, and actually use them. Not had one implode or cause the Earth to stop spinning yet.

I've tested every feature on them, and not found any that don't work as advertised, the initial problems with the first run pommels, (which was largely overhyped based on just a few knives breaking, but then were repeatedly referenced over and over online, making it look like more knives had broke than actually did) was corrected and the 2 gen. ones seem to be holding up OK. The new "pro" version has some solid changes, that I suspect if it were released in a coyote brown or black theme with no BG logo on it, it would be readily accepted by a lot of folks.

The knife enthusiast world should be big enough to accept everyone, not just the high end crowd. (unless you don't own a ZT, then your weird!) :)
 
I own the compact parang, compact multitool, compact scout and ultimate with serrations. I have to say that they are nice but quality lacks. if they were made better I would own more of them. I broke the ultimate. the compact multitool for the most part is useless by the fact that I can only open a few tools. the parang is amazing but I cant for the life of me sharpen it myself and the compact scout is nice but the lockup is worrying by the fact that that there is a gap between the blade and lock
 
How would the BG line hold up for use as a dedicated combat knife, like the Fairbairn Sykes knife?
 
i suspect if it were released in a coyote brown or black theme with no BG logo on it said:
Exactly. I dont have a BG knife, but the newest variant seems to be a solid design. I dont see how someone can call themselves a "knife enthusiast" and not appreciate a good design regardless of the price point or manufacturer. Is it the best knife ever? Absolutely not, but it definitely has its merits.
Click to expand...
 
It's interesting that the orange of the BG series is decried, but orange paracord adornments and lanyards are popular for high visibility.

But back to the BG 31-001063 model knife. Definitely not a survival knife. But is it structurally sound enough to serve as a dedicated fixed blade fighting knife like the Fairbairn Sykes? Great for combat but sucky for general utility work.
 
No, I do not like them. I did not like the LMF either. And I despise the type of hyped up survivaltainment that the show promotes. Now, "Naked and Afraid" on the other hand. Holy crap that is real as it gets.
 
Well I have had the BG Scout for almost 2 years. Have camped, hiked, and used it mountain trout fishing. Also edc carried a lot.You can't asked for a better designed knife for both function and durability. The thing will stand up to most anything and just keeps going. Even after all this time not even a little blade play. I have Kershaw, Case, CRKT, Kabar, Buck, and Victorinox knives and in my 30 years of using and carrying knives I can say it is as good as any of them.
 
No, no, nope, I can get a schrade with 1095 steel for about 40 bucks. I'm really starting to like schrade with their new 2015 lineup, the schf36, 37, and 38 specifically.
 
I'd rather drink my own piss. Or squeeze water from elephant caca. Not unfounded either. Saw one fail on a good friend of mine right in front of me. Tip broke off whittling wood. (Yes, it shocked the hell out of me too) I gave him my now irreplaceable custom to finish the job, and it did - no problem.
 
Yeps Jay is correct, he used the USK serrated in the NZ episodes..

IIRC the composition of the USKs are 7cr17mov and the LMFII I believe is 9cr19mov. Could be wrong. The steel isn't really that much of an issue. Where I think it goes wrong is in the heat treat. The USKs are Chinese made and I would assume Chinese treated. How good their heat treat is is probably quite debatable due to their lesser QC standards. The LMFII is still made in Oregon so I'm guessing that the HT for them would probably be better. Again, could be wrong.

I used to own both types of the first gen. USKs and an LMFII but unfortunately I never got to punish the crap out of them before I got rid of them and started buying Beckers and Kabars.

I will be frankly honest with you, the handles on the USKs (to me) were incredibly comfortable. I loved them. Don't know if there were any hot spots when using them because again, I really only used the serrated version lightly. I knew nothing of knives and steels back then and to me I thought "this knife is really cool!" and actually looked forward to really using the hell out of it but then I got 'spoiled' when I bought a BK2 and started to research steels.

Anyway OP, if you have one, use it. If you want one, get it. It's your choice and if you like it who cares what others say. If it fails, goes dull or you don't like it, just chalk it up to experience. It's not like you'll be that much out of pocket.

Just my 2 drachmas anyway..

Springy..
 
Last edited:
I got one, and I use it a lot camping. Fire lighting etc. I have used the hammer pommel to drive in tent stakes - sure not 2 feet long - but just general camp use, and food prep. Never found it wanting. Holds a great edge. Cheap enough that if it does break I won't lose any sleep. Gave one to one of my son's friends who is an apprentice landscaper. He uses it daily for all kinds of cutting - very happy with the edge retention. I mean it's a $50 to $60 knife - be reasonable.
Good question though. Got a lot of good interesting responses.
 
I don't mind Bear Grylls, he is legit special forces and has my respect, he also has some good survival tips on his show and has serious knowledge as a survivalist. I don't blame him for trying to make a buck on those knives. But personally, I hate marketing gimmicks like this, if your product is good people will buy it without attaching someones name and likeness to it. Personally I wouldn't buy one.
 
My son spotted the BG Compact Fixed Blade at a store in Oregon, and asked me to buy it for him. Price tag was $40.

Blade design should hold up to the abuse he can give it. Steel not bad. Handle comfortable, secure sheath, orange color makes it easy to spot. So I bought it for him.

OP, if you have a Bear Grylls from Gerber and you like it, then use it. If you want to buy one, then buy it. You will learn something from either experience.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top