BK9 vs. ZF War Sword vs. ZF Chopper

Joined
Jan 22, 2003
Messages
16
I'd like to get some opinions on the three knives; The Becker BK9, Kabar ZF War Sword and Kabar ZF Chopper. I'm not into the whole Zombie thing, but the price for performance ratio seems to be high on these ZF series. I like they come with black grips to replace the neon green ones. I don't like that the knife is made overseas, but given it's price point, it's hard to ignore for that reason.

I have been unemployed for 2 years now, so cash is tight. I have been doing a lot of backwoods hiking in my free time, and have come to the conclusion I need a big chopping knife for preparing firewood. I've been carrying a hatchet, but it's heavy and it seems to strike wood about 50% of my swings. (That's an exaggeration, but you know what I mean!)

I carry a Chris Reeve Shadow IV that I've had for several years. This will not change, it will handle everything but cutting wood, digging fire pits and basically being abused!

I had been wanting an Esee Junglas, but I can't justify spending over $150 at this point. Maybe someday if my employment status changes.

I've read all the reviews and seen all the videos on the BK9. I know what it's capable of. I know it's a quality knife. Not just for it's price, but overall, it's a great blade and should serve me well for the rest of my life. I like that.

I've seen a few reviews on the ZF War Sword. It seems to be a decent chopper as well. Not as good as the BK9, but it's also about 40% less than the BK9.

I have yet to see anyone actually chopping wood with the ZF Chopper. I'd like to get some more input on this blade.

So, given the three, my intended use and my situation, which do you think I should choose? I know it's easy to just say BK9 and forget about it. But these other 2 knives are throwing a serious monkeywrench in my decision making process. The $30-$40 saved is a half tank of gas in my truck or food for my dog. I can always upgrade to the BK9 or Junglas later and probably would, which would make the ZF knife good for throwing in the SHTF toolbox in the truck.
 
If by Chopper you mean Chop Stick, pretty sure they're not out yet. ocnLogan should be around soon to give you some good info as he's got a war sword and BK9. You should also put some serious consideration into the Cutlass Machete. It's less than fifty bucks and is an awesome, awesome chopping machine. I beat the absolute heck out of mine and have had no issues. I'm also really bad at sharpening but I can manage to clean up that edge without any worries. I'll probably try the original KA-BAR kukri next, and that has a great reputation and is five bucks cheaper than even the Cutlass, but if it wasn't for that I'd probably buy two more Cutlasses to keep at my mountain place and in my truck.
 
I'm with BRL - we're Toooj fanboys. Check out the Cutlass, Kukri, Grass Machete or Warthog. Heavy-duty choppers that take an excellent edge, resharpen easily, and are plenty comfortable to use. Inexpensive, too.
 
The BK9 was my first Becker. It replaced a small hatchet that I used to carry in my pack. At my age, a lighter pack is most welcome and I found the BK9 to be more versatile than the hatchet I used to carry at a fraction of the weight. I have a larger axe I keep in the rig but for hiking and overniters, the BK9 is perfect for shelters, clearing, fire and other small camp chores. I am not familiar with your other choices but for 80 bucks, I think the BK9 is pretty much the best value in a chopping/cutting tool that I have found. In fact, I don't think you can beat any of the Beckers for the money...I've since added a BK2 and BK13. I'll probably buy a few more too before it's all said and done...
 
If by Chopper you mean Chop Stick, pretty sure they're not out yet. ocnLogan should be around soon to give you some good info as he's got a war sword and BK9. You should also put some serious consideration into the Cutlass Machete. It's less than fifty bucks and is an awesome, awesome chopping machine. I beat the absolute heck out of mine and have had no issues. I'm also really bad at sharpening but I can manage to clean up that edge without any worries. I'll probably try the original KA-BAR kukri next, and that has a great reputation and is five bucks cheaper than even the Cutlass, but if it wasn't for that I'd probably buy two more Cutlasses to keep at my mountain place and in my truck.

I was just going to skip over this thread, but since now I'm somehow obliged to post I guess I'll share my info :p.

I was actually wondering the same thing when I got my ZK War Sword. I was looking at the ZK War Sword the Heavy Bowie and the BK9 primarily. Sadly there were no reviews of the war sword where the people did anything other than just fondle it.

So I went with the War Sword because it was a great deal, and then later won a BK9, and immediately did a review.
http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/s...-vs-KaBar-ZK-War-Sword-(PHOTO-HEAVY-and-EPIC)

The short version is that I like the BK9 "better", because it does what I was looking for better than the War Sword. That said, I wasn't buying it primarily as a chopper, but as something to use as a large camp knife that would see use batoning wood that had been split by my folding saw. Now, if you're going to be chopping with it primarily, then I would follow the sage advice of BRL and go with something like a cutlass machete. The BK9 and War Sword are great knives, but the extra size the cutlass has on them, as well as the shape really should give it a chopping advantage. BRL should have a BK9 in his hand sometime soon if I'm not mistaken, and then maybe he can do a comparison of them.

Another great blade to consider as a chopper would be the Condor 14in Golok, and its even cheaper than any of the ones listed here.

And I'm not sure what the Kabar ZF Chopper is, unless its the chop stick which was just announced. But I really don't see what use that type of blade shape would be good for, as the grind on that thing is super small, but hey, I don't know everything :D.

Good luck with whatever you do man :).
 
the chop stick would make a great batoning fro :)

how it chops? we'll see soon. hello orcs :D
 
On the 9 and the mentioned Toooj designs, the cutlass and the kukri:

The Becker handles like a large knife, the Tsujimotos like short machetes. I find that I chop more effectively with the Tsujimotos, and of the 2, the kukri feels more natural to snap cut. Light stalks, heavy grass, dense foliage... I can see the Tsujimotos outperforming the Becker in this type of chore.

However, the 9 feels better to baton with, and seems more solid and compact. I feel more confident battening with the v grind of the Becker than with the hollow grinds of the Tsujimotos (this is opinion, I have not tested extensively). The 9 is also easier to use for finer work. Straight blade is also easier to make sheathes for. The large recurves may need added features (open spine, extra snaps, etc.).

Wish I had some ZK input for you as well. Hope this helps.
 
Back
Top