Did most of you start out with Lansky and upgrade, or go straight to another option?
The first edges that were "adequate" (adequate means sort of pretty much shave sharp . . . ish . . ) that I ever produced (after sharpening since I was a little kid up to my thirties) were on high end edge tools for hand tool woodworking. I used a Veritas jig designed to hold plane blades and chisels.
I found out about it from FineWoodWorking magazine articles. They recommended using at least three stones in a progression. I was using one stone (King 1000 ) and one of those funny things . . . what are they called ? . . . strrrrrr? . . . plaaaap ? . . . oh yes . . . strop.
Once I tested the edge off the jig using a stone progression :
Well lets see what we have here . . .
will it "shave" hair . . . come on . . . just scrape one little hair off so I can quit all this business and get back to work . . .
OH MY GOSH ! ! ! !
I JUST SHAVED A LITTLE CURL OFF ONE OF THE HAIRS WHILE IT WAS STILL IN MY ARM AND THEN ACCIDENTALLY SPLIT ANOTHER HAIR NEXT TO IT RIGHT DOWN THE MIDDLE.
F_____ hand sharpening and leather things with dirt on them.
I'm HOME !
I'm HOME ! I'M HOHHHHMMME !
It was just natural to then go looking for a jig to put my pocket knives in.
I stumbled into the Aligner
and stumbled right out again. It wouldn't hold normal old pocket knives like a medium Stockman (seriously ! ! ! ? What good is it ! ! ! ? ). Wouldn't sharpen at a low angle ( ditto ).
Edge Pro . . .
I'm HOME ! I'm HOME ! I'M . . . etc., etc., etc.