Phoynix, so you live your life without risk? Its all a game of percentages, so yes, you don't know, but then again, I don't know how well the asbestos is sealed into the cement in the building I live in. You either prove your knife as best you can, then stay inside that envelope, or you develop the skill and learn when something is too far, or you never try anything because you might fail. It goes without saying that battoning got a little over-done as a fad, but just like everything else, in context it has its place. Sure I'm going to be careful, but that's because where I live the wood is so tough spyderco is going to use some in a sprint run before too long! But in easy wood, or the right conditions, why not?
I've also never been lost next to a pile of bucked cord-wood, so I suppose its a bit of a silly point anyway, but whenever there is a right and wrong way to do something, even if the right way is risky, I'd still rather know all the details, than just have "don't do it" be an answer.