• The BladeForums.com 2024 Traditional Knife is ready to order! See this thread for details: https://www.bladeforums.com/threads/bladeforums-2024-traditional-knife.2003187/
    Price is $300 ea (shipped within CONUS). Now open to the forums as a whole. If you live outside the US, I will contact you after your order for extra shipping charges. If there are customs issues? On you.

    User Name
    Serial number request
  • Merry Christmas and Happy Hannukah from all of us here on BladeForums! We hope that your holidays are filled with cheer!

Knife pet Peeves.

"Gimiky" knives... I like plain, sturdy blades that feel like something is in your hand. The more basic (or as some consider "ugly") the better. I'd rather the time and $$ be spent on durablity and edge quality than looking pretty.

Combo edges.. what's the fascination?? Give me a plain edge ANY DAY.

Prices ...are rediculous on some knives... paying for a name is BS! I believe in quality but $200 for a production knife is insane when it has all of $30 max in parts and about an hr of labor on the high side.

Edges... is it really hard to put a good edge on a knife when that's the end all purpose of your product?
 
hmmm...

Here we go, in order of irritation, starting with the most irritating.

Low ride pocket clips - can't stand them, won't buy a knife with one unless there's another place to mount the clip. The sole purpose of a pocket clip is to make the knife accessible, not to hide it. I like being able to get to my knife without having to worry that I'm going to pulled everything else out of my pocket with it.

I do carry a slipjoint everyday, but I want my main EDC easy to get to, not hidden in my pocket.

Digital camo - I think it's by far the stupidest idea I've ever seen for a knife and no one seems to understand why. What's the point of camouflage? It's to make things harder to see by breaking up their outlines. Why on earth would you want your knife to be harder to see? What happens when you drop it on the ground in low light? Oops, it blends right in, better come back in the morning to look for it.

Chisel grinds - How about driving a car with drive wheels only on one side?

Coated stainless - I've gone over this one before. There's no functional reason to coat S30V. Coated carbon blades are fine and I prefer a coating in fixed blades. But a coated stainless folder is just for looks.

Sharp edges that aren't used for cutting - As much as I love Spyderco, this is a problem with a lot of them. The worst offender is the Centofante with the point at the top of the thumb ramp, but at least that one has holes for tip up. The edge of the tang sticking out is one of the things keeping me from buying a Paramilitary.

Assisted opening - I just don't like it. I tried, and there are some knvies that I really like that are AO. My biggest beef with them is that some of them are hard to close. I got bitten pretty good when a Camillus Heat snapped back open when I tried to close it with wet hands. If I find a knife that I like, being AO wouldn't keep me from buying it, but I'd have to handle it first (I do want a Kershaw Leek).

I'm sure there more. But I like my knives to be well designed, ergonomic and easily visible if dropped and accessible when I need it.
 
Non-functional Jimping
Serrations
Unsharpenable edges- I have come to accept dull edges but when the grinds are so bad that hours on the sharpmaker wont fix it, Im talking to you Great Eastern Cutlery, it kind of ruins the knife
knives that talk mainly about weapons potential and cutting through leather jackets and stuff in their descriptions, if you are marketing to civilians stop advertising the knife as a Weapon and start advertising as a tool. become part of the solution not the problem
Knives that have crappy steel but are otherwise made of top quality materials and are over 100 dollars
 
I hate it when fan boys shorten the name of their favorite company's knives
to something a five year old girl would use like: Sebbie, Barkie, Spydie, etc.

I'm glad I'm not the only one who feels this way. I hate 'slippie' for slipjoint worst of all. Ugh.

Oh yeah, combo edges blow. Pick a style and stick to it!
 
Serrations- If I want a steak knife, I'll dig around in the kitchen drawers.
Non-AO flippers that won't flip.
Any AUS steel less than -8.
The term "surgical stainless".
Recurves.
VG-10 that micro-chips when cutting anything.
Glass-filled-nylon sheaths that dull the edge when inserting or withdrawing the blade.
 
In no particular order:

1) Assisted openers--honestly, how lazy are we that we can't just use our thumbs a little bit more? I can open most thumb stud/hole knives as fast or faster. As far as I'm concerned it's just one more thing to get gummed up or break. If you're gonna' be lazy at least use a flipper.

2) Serrations on knives that aren't meant for cutting rope. ...Or other similar tasks. Honestly they just rip things to shreds and bind up on material. Gimme' a plain edge.

3) The myth that serrations are hard or impossible to sharpen. --this comment usually comes from the old duffer who's never used anything other than a rectangular stone...without realizing that the edges of said stone can be used to sharpen them without any change in technique...you just have to tilt it at an angle.

4) Tanto tips. --First off, tantos don't have tips like that. At all. But beyond the misnomer all they do is limit functionality (unless you need a paint scraper with you at all times) and the supposed strength gained in the design is iffy at best. Often times the blade stock at the tip is very thin and will snap the same as any other geometry. And I've never heard of a tip snapping vertically...

5) Chisel grinds--I'd like to hear someone come up with any advantage this would have outside of sushi knives or carpenter's axes. They simply don't belong on normal knives.

6) Coatings--even on carbon steel. I just don't like them. I love a nice patina though. :D

7) Liner/frame locks--again, I just don't like them. Doesn't stop me from buying the occasional model that has them, but it's a bit of a turnoff.

8) Knives that have an inflated sense of self-worth--For a good example of this, see CS's higher-end folders. I'm just not going to pay that much for a piece of AUS-8 (which is a nice enough steel but not worth what they're asking) and aluminum that scratches the second you look at it wrong. If a knife is not a good value for the price I will not buy it, regardless of how nice it may or may not be.

9) The AutoLAWKS system--Way for a company to fix what ain't broken. Not to mention that you can't just take the spring out of it. It's loose then. Fail.

10) Bead-blasted finishes--Seriously? It kind of defeats to point of making a knife out of stainless if you're just going to do a stupid thing like that to it. I've seen knives made of highly stain-resistant steel rust in someones pocket because it had been bead blasted. It decreases corrosion resistance and makes the blade a real b*** to clean.

11) Adjustable pivots that aren't D-shaped-- Honestly it's just a pain to have to dig out two torx drivers just to take the darn pivot apart.

12) Recurved blades--Another personal preference thing. They aren't for everyone and they sure aren't for me.

13) Butter knives with stiff blades--Yes, really. I can't stand them. The whole point of a butter knife is to spread things. So why make it inflexible? This is possibly the biggest frustration for me since (to the best of my knowledge) there isn't really much "high-performance silverware" on the market. Even ritzy butter knives tend to be rigid.






Well I feel a lot better now! Whew! :D
 
I hate it when fan boys (and girls) shorten the name of their favorite company's knives
to something a five year old girl would use like: Sebbie, Barkie, Spydie, etc. The sad thing is that it becomes the standard after a bit on the forums. :p

Yeah, I also do it despite loathing the tendency. But my truncations are borne of sloth, e.g. I'll type Para becuase Paramiltary takes twice as long, and similarly Seb for Sebenza. It's absolutely not about me getting "folksy." It's those nauseating cutsie ones that make me want to slam my head through the computer screen and eat the shards of glass. Topping this particular list are two of your faves...er, sorry, favourites: Sebbie:barf: and Barkie:jerkit:. No problems with those typing/saying it, only with the sound of the word itself.
 
Insisting it has to be tip up/down. Don't tell me the same tired litany of combative bs one is better than another. Fighting with knives is already pretty low on the scale of intelligence.

Insisting that knife fighting or knife self defense is actually feasible. What part of DOJ stats don't you understand - guns and anything else but a knife is highly preferred by everyone.

Insisting combat use of a knife means against another soldier. That is reserved exclusively for bayonets, which aren't real good knives - spring tempered and file sharpened. Even elite forces just use a knife for chores, not as a weapon. Real weapons fire projectiles.

Anybody that asks which of two knives that both use S30V and Titanium is better. They have way more money than self discipline and character to figure out what they need. Don't buy either, you obviously aren't ready yet.

Whining about sheeple. Real warriors know they pay their salary, they're lovable, and maybe one day they will get it. They also know anti socials hate them, and their contempt is a great pre-incident indicator to future acts of violence. So, they monitor board chat and track the dysfunctional. They're easy to spot, they collect knives, have no life, and no woman.

Chatting about what the poster is clueless about. It's like wearing an orange jumpsuit to talk about what the military is like when you never served. If you haven't studied a technical science, don't post about heat treat or alloys. And if you don't own the knife, butt out. You don't know. Just because you have a keyboard doesn't make any opinion you have instantly credible. Your self esteem is not our problem.

And OMG, donttextonaforumLearnfrickinEnglishalreadyoklol?Itsnotstudyhall.
 
blah blah blah "sebie" Blah blah "barkie" etc etc "cgfbm" Blah blah "bucks are old school" so on & so forth "sng" oh yeah, and they stole that hole in the blade from the bug knife. and this has all been posted B4. and spelling and punctuation are 10% of your grade. you have 37 post, he has a million, which one is smarterer? G-10 is bad, tractor tire grips rule!!!!! jerkit smiley jerkit frown...

I like all knives. No real pet peeves here..:D
 
Last edited:
Half stops on slippies
blade play
Tanto tips
Tip up or tip down only
Poor customer service
Fantasy knives, daggers, swords etc...
 
"A Mother-In-Law that keeps sending me Pakistani knives made out of recycled soup cans."

I get weird display pieces from my mom with things like wolf heads on the handle, from the Avon catalog or something. Talk about hidden tang? I think these things are NO tang. Then she asks me where i've put them. I tell her I can't display them just anywhere and that i'll have to wait until I get that man-cave built.

My Mother-in-law has done it to me several times! She actually bought me a "camping" knife from Fingerhut and it was literally in pieces when I received it in the mail. A crappy "hunting" knife from Pakistan with plastic deer glued on the handles and the blade bent with little force from my hand. A crappy Chinese folder that I can't even look at and a $hitty knife that says "Marines" on the handle for absolutely no reason. The liner lock looks like tin foil.
 
Beadblasted blades
Coated blades that show wear
Americanized Tantos
Tip-down only carry
Partial serrations
Chisel grinds
Chisel-ground serrations that aren't right-hand oriented
Crappy knives that people show you after seeing your knife, hoping you'll be impressed.
 
Last edited:
I hate typing full names for knives when Milie will get the point across. After all I'm not a secretary.
 
i instantly dont trust any non full tang (as in the type with 2 scales attached not just exposed) knife that hits my paws
 
Choils that are just large enough for 1/2 to 3/4 of your finger. Either make the choil large enough so a normal adult can use it or get rid of it (or at least reduce it to a very small size).

DancesWithKnives
 
Choils that are just large enough for 1/2 to 3/4 of your finger. Either make the choil large enough so a normal adult can use it or get rid of it (or at least reduce it to a very small size).

DancesWithKnives

i dislike choils. Yah, they are often way too small, and seem to love to use that super sharp edge on whatever part of my pointer sticks out. A choil should be only there to make sharpening a little easier, not to give me a way to test the sharpness of knives on my index.
 
I hate typing full names for knives when Milie will get the point across. After all I'm not a secretary.

Mil and Mili don't look like "My Little Pony" gibberish and are legitimate abbreviations.
 
young guys at work ( construction ) thay carry a cell phone , a text thingy, cigarettes, lighter, and other misc. junk , BUT no knife because its too " heavy ".
 
-Dull knives
-Knives that have a great overall design, but horrible edge geometry.
-Poor fit and finish on "high end" knives.
-Extreme advertising that is inconsistent with typical knife usage.
-Breaking a knife just to see how much abuse it takes to break it.
-Unlicensed copies of legitimate knives.
-Good designs with less than optimal steel.
-Poor quality knives sold at premium prices.
 
Back
Top