- Joined
- May 5, 2008
- Messages
- 1,665
I have lived in NJ almost my whole life. I have collected and carried knives almost 1/2 my life, never had any problems
with anyone saying this or that is illegal. I had been always told that if you put the blade across your palm, if the blade
doesn't exceed the palm length, then if you were pulled over for any reason by law enforcement, you were ok. Now whether
that is true or not I don't know but it was always words I lived by.
So my g-friend gets into an accident the other day (by herself) - and since she was coming from having drink with friends she got
herself into a little bit of trouble. An officer started going thru her purse - and she had some of my knives in there, the
biggest being a Boker Rhino, which has a 3 in blade. She told me the officer started taking the knives out of her purse
and said she shouldn't be having these and just took them. She also had an collapsible baton in the car I gave her YEARS ago and they
took that as well, saying its illegal.
Now, I looked up Legal knife sizes in NJ, and another forum discussing this mentioned this "...The law doesn't use a size or length for knives. NJ law focuses on the legitimacy of carrying it at a specific time or place. In other words, if you can justify having or carrying that particular knife, you're okay, if not, problems. Jersey itself has some problems with some of their weapons laws..."
So please enlighten me - was the police right in taking those items - and if so, am I legally allowed to get them back..?
JB
with anyone saying this or that is illegal. I had been always told that if you put the blade across your palm, if the blade
doesn't exceed the palm length, then if you were pulled over for any reason by law enforcement, you were ok. Now whether
that is true or not I don't know but it was always words I lived by.
So my g-friend gets into an accident the other day (by herself) - and since she was coming from having drink with friends she got
herself into a little bit of trouble. An officer started going thru her purse - and she had some of my knives in there, the
biggest being a Boker Rhino, which has a 3 in blade. She told me the officer started taking the knives out of her purse
and said she shouldn't be having these and just took them. She also had an collapsible baton in the car I gave her YEARS ago and they
took that as well, saying its illegal.
Now, I looked up Legal knife sizes in NJ, and another forum discussing this mentioned this "...The law doesn't use a size or length for knives. NJ law focuses on the legitimacy of carrying it at a specific time or place. In other words, if you can justify having or carrying that particular knife, you're okay, if not, problems. Jersey itself has some problems with some of their weapons laws..."
So please enlighten me - was the police right in taking those items - and if so, am I legally allowed to get them back..?
JB