Marbles Woodcraft Knife

Codger_64

Moderator
Joined
Oct 8, 2004
Messages
62,324
I grew up using carbon steel knives, so naturally I am attracted to them more than the shiny polished stainless and other “designer” steels now so in vogue. Most of my knives over the years, and those now in my collection are 1095HC. As I examine the newer designs, and the newer materials, I can’t help but become curious about earlier designs. “Ancestor patterns” I call them. Today’s fad seems to be knives that are part ax, part bowie, and try to pack in as much versatility in function as possible.

WSK’s, as Wilderness Survival Knives are now called, were once known as “Woodlore” or “Woodcraft” knives. These knives were, according to many writers, among the first knives specifically designed for hunters. Prior to the early 1900's, outdoorsmen were using relatively thin bladed knives that could be found in most kitchen drawers, or unweildy bowie designs which were sorely lacking when it came to most camp and hunting chores.

A strange amalgamation of Dal Deweese and Webster Marbles, both accomplished outdoorsmen and hunters, resulted in the Marble’s Safety Ax Dal Deweese knife. Webster was not convinced that Dal’s design was the ideal hunting knife, and shortly introduced his own knife, the Marble’s Ideal. Later he came up with an even newer design, the Woodcraft. He felt it was such a revolutionary design that in 1915 he applied for a patent on it which was granted in 1916. That patent expired in 1934, and since then many companies have copied or adapted the Woodcraft blade design, and many more adapted certain features for their own blade designs.

What most people probably think of as a “matchstrike” on the spine of the first Woodcrafts was a crosshatched area ahead of the guard meant to be a safety feature for grip traction in wet, slippery conditions, and after the first year or so evolved into lateral grooves which we now call thumb grooves.

The mushroom shaped aluminum pommel added security to the grip, and made more certain withdrawing the knife from the sheath or flesh. This pommel shape has also been copied, adapted, and used by many companies on both sporting and military knives.

Exactly who came up with the leather washer handles with fiber and metal spacers for decoration, I haven’t a clue, but this knife did have those features from the beginning. In fact, H. Platts’ 1934 patent for the split tang using “H” shaped leather washers (Western Cutlery) was an improvement of the design, and the blade shown in his patent drawing is a dead ringer for the Woodcraft.


Stag handles were used as well, and also leather handles with stag crown pommels. The stag handle knives bring premiums from collectors, as do war year knives with a black plastic pommel.

Without doing an exhaustive search, the first mention I have come across of the word Woodcraft is on the title page of the original 1910 Boy Scouts Of America manual. But it quite obviously was a word in popular use before then. It referred to the skills of woodland living as applied by woodsmen and indians.

The Marble’s Woodcraft knife was quite popular, and was produced from circa 1915 through the mid 1950's. Marbles changed ownership a few times, and I believe regular knife production was halted in the mid/late seventies, then restarted by subsequent new owners, and the Woodcraft is now once more available, albeit with a slightly shorter blade.

I’ve seen the magazine ads for these Woodcraft knives all my life, but never bought one til now. The one I bought was an old one, made betweem 1916 and 1934 by the markings. It came with the original sheath, a rarity from my gleanings of the forums, though it does need some restitching, and the cost was comparable to the MSRP for a new one, around $60. I’ll play with this older knife a while, then if I am pleased with the design and feel, I may order one of the new ones, even though I understand they are the more modern steel, still carbon. And I must admit, the jigged bone looks good. And the curly oak. Maybe someone here who has the newer production will tell us something about it.
http://www.marblesoutdoors.com/cutlery/woodcraft.html


Codger
 
Just like Nessmuk and Horace Kephart, Webster Marble knew what outdoorsman needed in their cutting tools and they delivered simple functional designs that have stood the test of time. These older designs are what I love to make. Clean, simple lines that are comfortable to use and easy on the mind. No instruction manuel needed.:D
Scott
 
Nope, old school is still the best school!

Nessmuk said it best...

"A word as to knives. These are of prime necessity, and should be of the best, both as to shape and temper".

Simple and straightforward! Marbles knives worked and work WELL!
 
A Woodcraft II and a mini-Woodcraft
vestWood.gif

The Woodcraft II had a thinner blade (the way I like 'em).
That can be seen here
wdcfrtops.gif

A standard Woodcraft in the middle, mini and II on the sides.
These are all from Mike Stewart's tenure at Marbles.
Someday I'll pick up one of those old soldiers to round out the set.
 
Haven't seen a Western blank before! Neat!

11j20rt.jpg


Here is a Woodcraft pattern Belknap sold circa 1955 in their Blue Grass line. Is it a Marble's, a Western, or a ......Schrade Cut Co 360 like this one?
11j22rq.jpg
 
I have always loved woodcrafters, I own a couple of them. I was looking on one of the knife sites tonight and saw a P.J.Tomes woodcrafter and a Joe Cordova woodcrafter for sale, they were beautiful.
 
I think one of the biggest problems manufacturers have with this style of knife is that not many people use them anymore. How often have you just got into something (hobby, sport etc) and the thing that repulsed you the most (meaning the least aesthetic) turns out to be your favourite when you actually learn more.

Take a full convex for example, they just dont look sexy, but hot damn do they cut well!

As I have learned more about various things I have come to find a design apealing and attractive because I full understand the function, rather than just the way it pleases the eye.
 
For many years I was a patent illustrator. I would meet with the patent attorney and the inventor, review the item's details, purpose, function, anything that might be of the least importance in gaining the most offensive and defensive rights in the eventual claims, brief description (BD) and detailed description (DD). As is the case in any field, some of the inventors were absolute fruitcakes, but many were brilliant and had great insight. One particular inventor who is now quite popular with his own sporting product line of merchandise, T.V. show, and even signature boat line, said something that stuck with me re/fishing lures/hunting gadgets. "It's not designed to catch the dayum bass, it's designed to catch the dayum fisherman!" I think this applies to many knife designs as well, and failing to catch the eye and imagination of the knife buyer has been the ruin of several knife companies. Not that many people will buy an archaic design made from archaic materials. And unless that person is a serious collector of the brand who has to have one of everything and two or more of some (I do NOT know anyone like that, do you?), once the initial sale is made, that buyer is out of the market. I remember an interview with an official of Schrade where he lamented that the knives were so well made, you won't need another. "Built to Last A Lifetime" was one of their slogans.

Codger
 
This pic is from my website gallery. This was one I came up with that was a blend of me and the Woodcraft. My handle design combined with the lines of the Woodcraft blade in O1 carbon steel. I absolutely love those older hunting knife designs of the 20's through the 50's. Bob Loveless changed the hunting knife blade style's popularity in the 60's with his now infamous drop point hunter.
Scott

wcrb3.jpg
 
"It's not designed to catch the dayum bass, it's designed to catch the dayum fisherman!"

So true, yet sad in a way. I like to buy from those I perceive to have a passion for the subject rather than one solely driven by margin.
 
Kinfolks-50.jpg


This was my Dad's Boy Scout knife. It was in much better shape before he gave it to me to "use" at age 10 or 11...when I was into throwing knives into the ground. I guess that I watched too many cowboy and indian TV shows, or Daniel Boone, starring Fess Parker.

The false edge would seem to be perfect for removing hog/porcine hairs, by scraping, after the boiling-water cleaning of the carcass. Usually a dull-ish knife is recommended for that job, so, the false edge would seem to fulfill that purpose well.

GeoThorn

P.S. I hope that, indeed, the knife pictured above was patterned after the Marbles/Western Woodcraft. I posted the photo because that knife's blade shape looks similar to the original Woodcrafts, the Skinner, in particular, and the age range is about right for when copies/knock-offs would have been running around in the marketplace.

Anyway, if you gentlemen believe that the above picture isn't what you believe is representative of a Marbles/Western Woodcraft knock-off by Kinfolks, I'll remove it. I learn a lot of good information here at BladeForums, so, I don't want to dilute or otherwise mislead this thread.
 
Still a nice knife GeoThorn. Memories of it's origin and time spent with it while learning make it even nicer.

Scott, I like your rendition of the pattern. It looks similar to the Schrade 147 in the spine profile. In fact a lot of the hunting knives that came after the Woodcraft sport vestiges of the spine, belly and point design of the Marble's knife. Sometimes the spine peak is lowered, sometimes moved fore or aft. Here is a line drawing of the 147.
11j9pnc.jpg


And a pic of the knife.
11j9qag.jpg


Not copied from the earlier Woodcraft, but the resemblence is there.

Codger
 
One of the great patterns and one that Kephart lauded in his "Camping & Woodcraft".

Aside from the larger (in stag) and smaller (in leather) Marble's versions, I also have something similar in 52100 forged by master smith Rick Dunkerley several years ago:

standard.jpg


Here's the stag handled Marble's in 52100:

standard.jpg
 
Speaking of Kephart, this is my lastest Kephart design made knife. All of these old timers know what was best in a cutting tool. Did I mention I love making these old style designs? :D
Scott

kephart.JPG
 
I don't recall seeing that pattern in my Kephart volumes nor is it a woodcraft style pattern.
 
Ah, the old Colclesser catalog. I haven't seen that in a long time.

Colclesser also made the "tomahawk" that Kephart carried with him afield. It sported a 2.5" bit, an 8 oz. head and hickory handle.

It was amongst his most valued possessions which he stated "I use oftener than I do my jackknife".
 
Back
Top